Prey pay a steep price to elude predators

Jul 11, 2012 By Krishna Ramanujan
A tobacco hornworm caterpillar and a stink bug predator. Ellen Woods (2011 Cornell graduate)

( -- When the threat of predators lurks, prey often eat less to avoid being out in the open and vulnerable to attack.

But a new study of caterpillars (Manduca sexta) and stink bugs (Podisus maculiventris) that feed on them finds that when threatened, these caterpillars do feed up to 40 percent less, yet they still develop faster and gain the same amount of weight as unthreatened caterpillars.

By doing so, they quickly become too big to be eaten. This allows young caterpillars to avoid a fundamental conflict for many organisms -- a choice between growing big or defending themselves against predators. Other studies have shown that employ a similar strategy to escape predators by increasing their rate of development into and leaving the environment quickly, but they pay the price of being small thereafter.

The study, published July 9 in the , describes how in the first few days of being threatened, the caterpillars became more efficient at extracting nitrogen from tomato plants they ate, and the in their bodies increased.

"Even though the mass of threatened caterpillars was the same [as unthreatened caterpillars], they are fundamentally different creatures, and they are made of more lipids and less sugars," said Jennifer Thaler, a Cornell associate professor of insect ecology and the paper's lead author.

At the same time, Thaler and colleagues suspected there would be costs to the quick growth and heightened efficiency in digesting food. "There's no free lunch," Thaler added.

After nine days, the threatened caterpillars ate more than unthreatened caterpillars, but they processed their food with about 35 percent less efficiency than the control caterpillars. The researchers speculate that even though the threatened caterpillars are still vulnerable to predation, they may be forced to eat more to maintain their weight as the mechanism that allowed them to process their food more efficiently no longer functions. "They may have to eat more to keep up, otherwise they would grow more slowly," Thaler said. Still, more research is needed to better understand why their food processing efficiency declines at the end, she added.

"When we think about the major ecological factors that structure ecological communities, predation is one of the key forces," said Thaler. "So, we know predation is important, but we have little idea how it is influencing individuals. The definition of a predator is that it eats prey, but this ignores the fact that the mere presence of predators, regardless of whether they actually eat a caterpillar, causes the changes documented in the prey. We didn't realize the surviving caterpillars would be completely different."

In the study, the researchers set up small field cages, with three and six second instar caterpillars, two to three days after hatching. (Instars refer to the different stages of development between hatching and the time of pupation.) Also, they added a stink bug, a predator that feeds on plants and crops, but also eats soft-bodied caterpillars in the spring after mating. The ' beaks poke the caterpillars and drain their fluids. To keep the caterpillars alive in the experiment, the beaks were snipped to allow the bugs to threaten and stress the caterpillars but not kill them.

After three days, the researchers measured how much of the tomato was eaten and weighed the caterpillars.

In the lab, the researchers started with in their second instar with clipped stink bug , but kept them together for nine days, switching them to a new tomato plant every three days, to test the longer term effects of predation.

Paper cones were placed around the stems of the plants to collect the insects' waste (frass) to analyze its carbon and nitrogen content, and at the end of the experiments, the caterpillar bodies were frozen and analyzed for proteins, carbohydrates and sugars.

For each experiment, controls were also established.

Co-authors include Scott McArt, a graduate student in Thaler's lab, and Ian Kaplan, an assistant professor of insect ecology at Purdue University. The study was funded by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

Explore further: Birds 'weigh' peanuts and choose heavier ones

Related Stories

Fat, thin caterpillars are studied

Sep 21, 2006

A U.S.-led international team of scientists says there's no obesity epidemic among insects and the researchers believe they now know why.

Caterpillars aren't so bird brained after all

Apr 04, 2011

( -- Caterpillars that masquerade as twigs to avoid becoming a bird's dinner are actually using clever behavioural strategies to outwit their predators, according to a new study.

Beware: More caterpillars may be arriving

Nov 17, 2005

As global warming affects the Earth's climate, a Tulane University scientist is predicting a significant increase in caterpillars and agricultural damage.

Recommended for you

Birds 'weigh' peanuts and choose heavier ones

May 23, 2015

Many animals feed on seeds, acorns or nuts. The common feature of these are that they have shells and there is no direct way to know what's inside. How do the animals know how much and what quality of food ...

Estuaries protect Dungeness crabs from deadly parasites

May 22, 2015

Parasitic worms can pose a serious threat to the Dungeness crab, a commercially important fishery species found along the west coast of North America. The worms are thought to have caused or contributed to ...

An evolutionary heads-up—the brain size advantage

May 22, 2015

A larger brain brings better cognitive performance. And so it seems only logical that a larger brain would offer a higher survival potential. In the course of evolution, large brains should therefore win ...

Our bond with dogs may go back more than 27,000 years

May 21, 2015

Dogs' special relationship to humans may go back 27,000 to 40,000 years, according to genomic analysis of an ancient Taimyr wolf bone reported in the Cell Press journal Current Biology on May 21. Earlier genome ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.