Design Structure Matrix analysis: Better product design through a simple square chart

Jul 30, 2012 by Peter Dizikes
A DSM model showing the real estate development process. Image courtesy of MIT Press

Suppose you were asked to streamline the process of real estate development. Or to better organize the offices of an international manufacturer. Or to explain how the parts of a digital printer interact. The complexities of all these tasks would likely seem daunting.

Now suppose someone said you could accomplish these assignments by drawing a simple square chart on a piece of graph paper. No need for buggy , labyrinthine flow charts or bloated Venn diagrams. Sound appealing?

Welcome to the world of Design Structure Matrix (DSM) modeling, a management exercise that forms one branch of MIT’s long-running institutional fascination with the analysis of complex systems. A DSM chart is a way of simplifying complex engineering tasks — say, the design of computer hardware or engines — in order to make them more efficient.

Specifically, DSM analysis helps firms turn product design into a productive routine, rather than an ad-hoc process continually being reinvented — a point MIT management professor Steven D. Eppinger emphasizes in his new book, Design Structure Matrix Methods and Applications, co-written with Tyson Browning of Texas Christian University and recently published by MIT Press. It is the first such book, outlining DSM techniques for a general audience of engineers and managers, published in three decades.

“Engineering work is procedural and repeatable,” Eppinger says. “People think of engineering as a matter of always developing something new, unlike business operations, where you do something over and over again. But we’ve learned that, no, maybe you repeat engineering work five or 20 times in your career instead of 100 times a day, but there’s a process there. And if you can write down that process, you can improve it.”

Repeat after me

DSM modeling, as Eppinger and Browning see it, applies to three main areas of business: the design process, organizations and products. The “matrix” in DSM refers to the fact that a DSM analysis is represented by a square chart with boxes inside — much like a piece of graph paper. A DSM chart, with units of a system listed along the x-axis and y-axis of the chart, simply maps the intersections of those elements, with simple observations or data about the way the units interact.

Consider a DSM chart of the entire process needed to develop a piece of commercial real estate. (Using DSM to analyze the design process, Eppinger notes, is the most popular application of DSM modeling.) In 2009, for instance, MIT graduate students Benjamin Bulloch and John Sullivan created a DSM chart for nearly 100 different activities that the real estate development firm Jones Lang LaSalle needed to complete in order to finish a project. By listing those activities along both axes of the chart, the researchers were able to see how many part of the project interacted with each other — how many specific steps directly related to the leasing process, say.

In some engineering projects, this means repeating steps in order to make sure they are performed properly. In fact the distinction between necessary repetitions in engineering and wasteful ones is, Eppinger says, one of the most important insights to emerge from DSM analysis.

“Not all iterations are bad,” he says. “You might think of rework as waste, but some iterations are fundamental and have to be built into the process, due to the cutting-edge nature of the design work and the uncertainty inherent in it. On the other hand, there are iterations that are slow and painful and frustrating and should probably be avoided. Those are the ones that derive from making mistakes or not having the right information when it’s available.”

Tracking the flow of information is one aim of applying DSM modeling to organizations. In one case, Eppinger worked with managers at the Timken Company, a global manufacturer, to assess where various parts of the business — product design, technology development, business development and oversight of its manufacturing development — should be physically located at its offices in Ohio. This DSM chart helped the firm decide where to locate the managers of its units so they would interact most effectively.

When applying DSM models to products, Eppinger notes, the aim of the analysis is to visualize the “difference between modular and integrative elements” of an object, to see which of these interact. One paradigmatic DSM chart from 2007, created in part by former MIT doctoral student Eun Suk Suh, listed 84 components of Xerox’s iGen3 digital printing system, on both the left-hand side and top of the chart; color-coding the squares in which parts interacted enabling the company to see all the connections within its product, and helped Xerox update the technology for the next generation of the product.

Tomorrow, biotech?

Soon after joining the MIT faculty in 1988, Eppinger became interested in DSM after reading an article about it in an academic journal. “I said, ‘That’s interesting, I wonder why nobody uses this?’” he recalls. Companies, he found, generally did not know about DSM — but became interested after learning about it.

Today, engineers say they appreciate the work of Eppinger and Browning. Georges Fadel, a professor of mechanical engineering at Clemson University, says they “do an excellent job” explaining DSM modeling.

The term DSM itself was coined in the 1970s by Don Steward, a professor at California State University at Sacramento. But Eppinger, Fadel says, helped “put DSM on the map. He took it and showed it’s important to see if we can understand visually.”

And while DSM modeling has been adopted most widely in the automotive, aerospace and electronics industries, Eppinger says he is optimistic that it will spread further. “I’d certainly like to see more applications in medicine, health care devices, pharmaceuticals and biotech companies,” Eppinger says. “I’d like to see more applications in energy. There is still lots of work to be done in those areas.”

Explore further: Firm combines 3-D printing with ancient foundry method

More information:… sp?ttype=2&tid=12819

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Study looks more closely at personality disorders

Sep 21, 2011

A newly published paper from Rhode Island Hospital argues against the proposed changes to redefine the number of personality disorders in the upcoming Diagnostic Statistical Manual, 5th edition (DSM-5). In their study, the ...

Driving change in diagnosis of personality disorders

Jan 26, 2011

University of Notre Dame psychologist Lee Anna Clark recently began work on a five-year study that will contribute to revolutionizing the way personality disorders are diagnosed and further cement Clark’s standing as ...

Autism expert on proposed changes to autism diagnosis

Jan 23, 2012

(Medical Xpress) -- Autism has been the subject of much discussion recently due to proposed changes in diagnostic criteria, as laid out in the forthcoming fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental D ...

Recommended for you

Firm combines 3-D printing with ancient foundry method

Mar 27, 2015

A century-old firm that's done custom metal work for some of the nation's most prestigious buildings has combined 3-D printing and an ancient foundry process for a project at the National Archives Building in Washington, ...

Wearable device helps vision-impaired avoid collision

Mar 26, 2015

People who have lost some of their peripheral vision, such as those with retinitis pigmentosa, glaucoma, or brain injury that causes half visual field loss, often face mobility challenges and increased likelihood ...

Applications of optical fibre for sensors

Mar 26, 2015

Mikel Bravo-Acha's PhD thesis has focused on the applications of optical fibre as a sensor. In the course of his research, conducted at the NUP/UPNA-Public University of Navarre, he monitored a sensor fitted to optical fibre ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.