Canadian court scraps royalty for online downloads

July 12, 2012 by CHARMAINE NORONHA

(AP) — Canada's Supreme Court ruled Thursday that songwriters and music publishers are not entitled to royalties for song and video game downloads. It also determined that artists should be compensated when music is streamed online.

The high court ruled that downloading an individual file is not considered a communication to the public within the Copyright Act. However, streaming online is not a private transaction and should be subject to fees currently in place.

Streaming refers to watching or listening to videos and music online while downloading refers to saving a file to your hard drive.

The partly overturned a lower court decision that had allowed an organization representing musicians and the recording industry, known as the Society of Composers, Authors and Music Publishers, to collect tariffs for both activities for its members.

"Although a download and stream are both 'transmissions' in technical terms ... they are not both 'communications' for the purposes of the Copyright Act. This is clear from the (Copyright) board's definition of a stream as a transmission of data that allows the user to listen or view the content at the time of transmission and that is not meant to be reproduced," the court said in its ruling.

"Unlike a download, the experience of a stream is much more akin to a broadcast performance."

That decision was linked to another that dealt with software companies that sell their video games online. The court ruled 5-4 that those firms shouldn't pay royalties for the music that's featured in those video games every time a consumer downloads it online.

"There is no practical difference between buying a durable copy of the work in a store, receiving a copy in the mail, or downloading an identical copy using the Internet," wrote Justices Rosalie Abella and Michael Moldaver.

"ESA (Entertainment Software Association) has already paid reproduction royalties to the copyright owners for the video games."

Copyright royalties are approved by the Copyright Board of Canada, and if those who have to pay them disagree, they can ask for a judicial review and fight them at the Federal Court of Appeal.

The court's decision on downloading and royalties, among five copyright-related cases settled Thursday, means telecommunications companies that offer music services won't have to pay as much to copyright collection agencies.

In another of the rulings Thursday, the justices said online music stores will not have to pay royalties on song previews to publishers and songwriters.

The high court ruled song previews — what a customer would listen to before purchasing digital music from online retailers such as an iTune — constitutes research under copyright legislation and thus the consumer should not pay a royalty.

"Short, low-quality previews do not compete with, or adversely affect, the downloading of the works themselves. Instead, their effect is to increase the sale and dissemination of copyrighted musical works," said the ruling.

The court also determined that record labels and recording artists should not eligible for royalties from movie and TV soundtracks, as they are considered categorically different than traditional sound recordings.

Eric Baptiste, the CEO of the Society of Composers, Authors and , commended the high court's ruling on streaming but was disappointed with the other rulings.

"We will continue to fight for the legal rights of our members to be compensated fairly for their work," he said.

The fifth ruling found that photocopying textbooks for classroom use in public schools does not infringe copyright laws, and should not be subject to a tariff, contrary to a previous Copyright Board conclusion that photocopies did not constitute "fair dealing" and required a fee. However, the matter will return to the Board for reconsideration.

All five cases were initially heard by the Supreme Court last December.

Explore further: Music downloading hearing can't be streamed online


Related Stories

Music downloading hearing can't be streamed online

April 16, 2009

(AP) -- Oral arguments in a music downloading lawsuit filed by the recording industry against a Boston University student can't be streamed online, a federal appeals court ruled Thursday.

Dutch court: Web site must remove copyright works

August 26, 2009

(AP) -- A civil court on Wednesday ordered Dutch Web site Mininova to remove within three months all files on its servers that point to copyrighted works or face a fine of up to euro5 million ($7.16 million).

German rules against YouTube in rights case

April 20, 2012

(AP) -- A German court has ruled that online video platform YouTube must install filters to prevent users from uploading some music videos whose rights are held by a music-royalties collecting body.

Court won't reduce student's music download fine

May 21, 2012

(AP) -- The Supreme Court has refused to take up a Boston University student's constitutional challenge to a $675,000 penalty for illegally downloading 30 songs and sharing them on the Internet.

EU court OKs resale of software licenses

July 3, 2012

(AP) — The European Union's highest court ruled Tuesday that software makers cannot keep people who download programs from selling their licenses for those programs to others — as long as they disable their own ...

Recommended for you

The ethics of robot love

November 25, 2015

There was to have been a conference in Malaysia last week called Love and Sex with Robots but it was cancelled. Malaysian police branded it "illegal" and "ridiculous". "There is nothing scientific about sex with robots," ...

Glider pilots aim for the stratosphere

November 20, 2015

Talk about serendipity. Einar Enevoldson was strolling past a scientist's office in 1991 when he noticed a freshly printed image tacked to the wall. He was thunderstruck; it showed faint particles in the sky that proved something ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.