Where we split from sharks: Common ancestor comes into focus

Jun 13, 2012
A latex mold of the braincase of Acanthodes bronni (left) is compared to the braincase of a modern dogfish (squalus). Credit: Megan Doherty/University of Chicago

The common ancestor of all jawed vertebrates on Earth resembled a shark, according to a new analysis of the braincase of a 290-million-year-old fossil fish that has long puzzled paleontologists.

New research on Acanthodes bronni, a fish from the Paleozoic era, sheds light on the of the earliest and offers a new glimpse of the last common ancestor before the split between the earliest sharks and the first bony fishes — the lineage that would eventually include human beings.

"Unexpectedly, Acanthodes turns out to be the best view we have of conditions in the last common ancestor of bony fishes and sharks," said Michael Coates, PhD, professor of organismal biology and anatomy at the University of Chicago and senior author of the study published in Nature. "Our work is telling us that the earliest bony fishes looked pretty much like sharks, and not vice versa. What we might think of as shark space is, in fact, general modern jawed vertebrate space."

The group gnathostomes, meaning "jaw-mouths," includes tens of thousands of living vertebrate species, ranging from fish and sharks to birds, reptiles, mammals and humans. Cartilaginous fish, which today include sharks, rays, and ratfish, diverged from the bony fishes more than 420 million years ago. But little is known about what the last common ancestor of humans, manta rays and great white sharks looked like.

Coates and colleagues Samuel Davis and John Finarelli found answers to this mystery in an unexpected place: the acanthodians, extinct fishes that generally left behind only tiny scales and elaborate suites of fin spines. But armed with new data on what the earliest sharks and bony fishes looked like, Coates and colleagues re-examined fossils of Acanthodes bronni, the best-preserved acanthodian species.

Davis created highly detailed latex molds of specimens revealing the inside and outside of the skull, providing a valuable new data set for assessing cranial and jaw anatomy as well as the organizations of sensory, circulatory and respiratory systems in the species.

These are various latex molds taken from the fossil of Acanthodes bronni. Credit: Megan Doherty/University of Chicago

"We want to explore braincases if possible, because they are exceptionally rich sources of anatomical information," Coates said. "They're much better than scales, teeth or fin spines, which, on their own, tend to deliver a confusing signal of evolutionary relationships."

The analysis of the sample combined with recent CT scans of skulls from early sharks and bony fishes led the researchers to a surprising reassessment of what Acanthodes bronni tells us about the history of jawed vertebrates.

"For the first time, we could look inside the head of Acanthodes, and describe it within this whole new context," Coates said. "The more we looked at it, the more similarities we found with sharks."

However, analysis of the evolutionary relationships of Acanthodes bronni — even with these new data added — still connected this species to early bony fishes. Meanwhile, some acanthodian species turned out to be primitive sharks, while others were relatives of the of sharks and bony fishes.

This result explains some of the longstanding confusion about the placement of acanthodians in vertebrate history. But additional analyses went a step further. Using more than 100 morphological characters, the researchers quantified the mutual resemblance among the earliest jawed fishes. Acanthodians as a whole, including the earliest members of humans' own deep evolutionary past, appear to cluster with ancient sharks.

"The common ancestors of all jawed vertebrates today organized their heads in a way that resembled sharks," said Finarelli, PhD, Lecturer in Vertebrate Biology at University College Dublin. "Given what we now know about the interrelatedness of early fishes, these results tell us that while retained these features, bony fishes moved away from such conditions."

Furthermore, the analysis demonstrated that all of these early members of the modern gnathostomes are clearly separated from what now appear to be the most primitive vertebrates with jaws: a collection of armored fishes called placoderms.

"There appears to be a fundamental distinction between the placoderms and all other vertebrates with jaws," Finarelli said.

This new revision of the lineage of early jawed vertebrates will allow paleontologists to dig into deeper mysteries, including how the body plan of these ancient species transformed over the transition from jawless to jawed fishes.

"It helps to answer the basic question of what's primitive about a shark." Coates said. "And, at last, we're getting a better handle on primitive conditions for jawed vertebrates as a whole."

"This study is an example of the power of phylogenetics combined with the comparative morphology of living and fossil organisms," said Maureen Kearney, program director in National Science Foundation's Division of Environmental Biology, which co-funded the research. "It shows us important evolutionary transitions in the history of life, providing a new window into the sequence of evolutionary changes during early vertebrate evolution."

Explore further: Rescued 'abandoned' penguin chicks survival similar to colony rates

More information: The study, "Acanthodes and shark-like conditions in the last common ancestor of modern gnathostomes," will be published on June 14 by Nature (pp 247-250).

Related Stories

New piece in the jigsaw puzzle of human origins

Jan 15, 2009

In an article in today's Nature, Uppsala researcher Martin Brazeau describes the skull and jaws of a fish that lived about 410 million years ago. The study may give important clues to the origin of jawed vertebrates, and th ...

Vertebrate jaw design locked 400 million years ago

Jul 06, 2011

More than 99 per cent of modern vertebrates (animals with a backbone, including humans) have jaws, yet 420 million years ago, jawless, toothless armour-plated fishes dominated the seas, lakes, and rivers. ...

Chinese report important fish fossil find

May 05, 2006

Chinese researchers say a newly discovered fish species that lived more than 400 million years ago may represent a bridge between two vertebrate lineages.

Fresh fossil evidence of eye forerunner uncovered

Dec 12, 2007

Ancient armoured fish fossils from Australia present some of the first definite fossil evidence of a forerunner to the human eye, a scientist from The Australian National University says.

Swedish researcher finds missing piece of fossil puzzle

Jul 13, 2009

The mode of reproduction seen in modern sharks is nearly 400 million years old. That is the conclusion drawn by Professor Per Erik Ahlberg, Uppsala University, from his discovery of a so-called "clasper" in a primitive fossil ...

Recommended for you

Secret wing colours attract female fruit flies

15 hours ago

Bright colours appear on a fruit fly's transparent wings against a dark background as a result of light refraction. Researchers from Lund University in Sweden have now demonstrated that females choose a mate ...

Pigeons and people play the odds when rewards are higher

17 hours ago

(Phys.org) —If you were weighing the risks, would you choose to receive a guaranteed $100, or take a 50/50 chance of winning either $200 or nothing? Researchers at the University of Alberta have shown that ...

User comments : 7

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

perrycomo
1.8 / 5 (12) Jun 13, 2012
I am not surprised that sharks have something in common with homo sapiens . When we look at human history and even nowadays we've had a lot of shark like behavior on land .
verkle
1.2 / 5 (21) Jun 13, 2012
But where are all of the evolving species in between the ones found? (hint: there aren't any!)

It really mind-boggling that some scientists continue to hang on to the theory of evolution.

Deesky
4.6 / 5 (9) Jun 13, 2012
But where are all of the evolving species in between the ones found? (hint: there aren't any!)

It really mind-boggling that some scientists continue to hang on to the theory of evolution.

The species Godofthegapigus seem to be immune to the forces of evolution and is thus destined to die out. Nature at work.

CardacianNeverid
5 / 5 (7) Jun 14, 2012
I am not surprised that sharks have something in common with homo sapiens... -perrycomo

Compare an early human embryo with that of a fish - they look near identical, as do other species.
gmurphy
3 / 5 (2) Jun 14, 2012
phylogeny recapitulates ontogeny!
vidyunmaya
1 / 5 (10) Jun 14, 2012
Sub: Frame set- limiting perception
Biological frame set of Mind needs - Evolution to catch-up with Creation. The creative attributes of Nature are outlined in philosophy- Searching Minds : Guiding Spirit
Invited Talks
1. HUMAN BEING -ENVIRONMENT AND SPACE THE ESSENCE OF COSMOLOGY VEDAS INTERLINKS by DR VIDYARDHINANDURI
4th intl Vedic Science Conference,life Sciences &technology-Ancient india-Dec 2011-National Institute of Vedic Sciences[nIVS] Bangalore-[Mulbagal,563131, India]
2. SPIRIT OF ENLIGHTENMENT:IN-FUSION- SEARCH UNITY FOR PEACE by Vidyardhi Nanduri
Spiritual World Conference 2012, Organized by Indian Foundation for Vedic Science [IFVS], India and Associated Institutions,Bahadurgarh,Delhi,14-16 March, 2012
Anda
not rated yet Jun 14, 2012
"mammals and humans" ... Funny

like humans and hopely near extinction creationists.