Inadequate safeguards against misuse of coerced information: study

Jun 21, 2012

Individual rights may be coming second to a notion of 'collective security' as agencies ramp up their use of information obtained through coercive means, a University of Melbourne study has warned.

Some and integrity authorities have coercive powers to compel a person to provide evidence or produce documents.
 
The report, ‘Has accountability kept up with the use of coercive powers information?’ analyses three cases:

  • The matter of Mohammed Haneef, an Indian national wrongly accused by Australian authorities of providing support to a terrorist organization in 2007.
  • The Victorian Office of Police Integrity’s handling of a 2011 complaint by the then Police Chief Commissioner, Simon Overland, against his deputy, Sir Ken Jones.
  • A 2011/12 Commission of Inquiry into the New South Wales Crime Commission.
“These case studies highlight some of the recent deficiencies in effective accountability,” lead researcher Chris Bonnici said.
 
“In some instances individual rights weren’t given due regard, as authorities sought to achieve ‘collective security’.”
 
The report also highlights the inability of judges to properly test the veracity of information obtained through coercive means when it is used as ‘intelligence’.
 
It argues strong policies and procedures are necessary to minimize the risk of the illegal or inaccurate use of coercive powers information and to provide an adequate foundation for oversight and review.
 
“In many instances, accountability has not kept up with significant changes in the use of information from coercive powers by law enforcement agencies,” the report reads.
 
The report doesn’t propose a specific model to address the identified shortcomings, but recommends a “multi-faceted and inter-related” accountability regime with “routine, independent and properly informed oversight”.
 
“If for the use of coercive powers information does not adapt to these changes then there is a continuing risk to ,” Mr Bonnici said.

Explore further: Apartment dwellers more likely to fear crime in their neighbourhood but feel safer at home than those in detached homes

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Lefties more likely to look before they leap

Feb 08, 2012

(Medical Xpress) -- New research from the University of Abertay Dundee has found evidence that left-handed people may be better decision makers than their right-handed counterparts.

Scientists find new Australian frog

Jul 26, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- A new miniature frog species or ‘toadlet’ has been discovered in the resource-rich Pilbara region of Western Australia, an area previously thought to support very few of the amphibians.

Recommended for you

Awarded a Pell Grant? Better double-check

16 hours ago

(AP)—Potentially tens of thousands of students awarded a Pell Grant or other need-based federal aid for the coming school year could find it taken away because of a mistake in filling out the form.

Perthites wanted for study on the Aussie lingo

Jul 23, 2014

We all know that Australians speak English differently from the way it's spoken in the UK or the US, and many of us are aware that Perth people have a slightly different version of the language from, say, Melbournians - but ...

User comments : 0