Study cracks a secret of methanol production

May 24, 2012 by Glennda Chui
This image, made with a high-resolution transmission electron microscope, shows atoms on the surface of an industrial catalyst used in methanol production. A study by scientists from SLAC, Stanford and Germany reveals that the catalyst’s copper surface (dark blue) is folded into “steps” and decorated with particles of zinc oxide (turquoise). These defects increase its activity, while other defects in the copper nanoparticle stabilize this highly efficient configuration. Understanding the catalyst in all its complexity is a step toward improving the process for manufacturing methanol, an important industrial chemical that could become the basis for a clean energy economy. Credit: © Malte Behrens / Fritz Haber Institute of the MPG

( -- What’s the best way to make methanol? The question is more pressing than it sounds. Not only is methanol an important industrial chemical – some 50 million tons are used each year to make plastics and other products – but it could also become the basis of a clean energy economy that actually reduces global warming by turning a potent greenhouse gas, carbon dioxide, into fuel.

Now scientists from SLAC and Stanford have teamed with researchers in Germany to figure out a key part of the most common process for making methanol. This new understanding, reported last week in Science, is an important step toward improving the process and eventually realizing the goal of capturing carbon dioxide released by the burning of fossil fuels and turning it into something you can put in your gas tank.

The key ingredient is a – a substance that promotes chemical reactions without being consumed itself. Back in the 1960s, chemists tweaked particles of copper, zinc oxide and aluminum oxide into a sponge-like catalyst that is highly efficient at making methanol from syngas. This recipe has been used ever since, but why it worked was never completely understood.

“In order to know how it works, we need to know what the active site looks like” – the surface of the catalyst where chemicals are brought together and persuaded to react, said Felix Studt, a theoretical chemist at SLAC’s SUNCAT Center for Interface Science and Catalysis. “The problem with a lot of other studies is that they were on surfaces that were very far away from being a real catalyst, under real working conditions.”

He and two other SUNCAT theorists – Frank Abild-Pedersen and institute Director Jens K. Nørskov – have been studying theoretical models of methanol synthesis. They had identified the two most important factors in making a good catalyst: the presence of defects in the material and the presence of zinc or another oxygen-loving metal.

At the same time, researchers in Berlin found experimental evidence that the best catalysts had exactly those features. The groups teamed up to draw the first comprehensive picture of the catalyst’s active site.

Studying the actual industrial catalyst in all its complexity proved quite a challenge, said chemist Malte Behrens, leader of a research group at the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin that collaborated on the study. “But our feeling was that it was necessary to do that,” he said, “because all these little details, impurities and defects in the end turned out to be relevant.”

With scientists at Süd-Chemie AG, an important industrial producer of catalysts, the Berlin group made and tested five versions of the methanol catalyst. All were composed of the same chemical elements, but they varied slightly in the details of their preparation. This turned out to make a huge difference, Behrens said; the one made according to the traditional recipe worked very well, while others worked poorly or not at all.

Then the researchers in Germany examined these samples in several ways: with an electron microscope, by neutron scattering and with an X-ray beam at BESSY II, a synchrotron light source at the Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin for Materials and Energy. The X-ray studies were carried out in the presence of gases that are used to make methanol, and under conditions similar to those in the industrial process.

The result: the first experimental evidence that reflects the full complexity of the active part of the industrial catalyst. It revealed that the copper surface was folded into “steps” and decorated with particles of zinc oxide, and that this configuration was stabilized by other defects in the material.

“There are so many other things, such as copper particle size and oxidation state, that might have mattered or not,” Behrens said. “The theory helped us understand that these are really the necessary ingredients. In the end, the picture that developed from these results is comprehensive, because theory and experiments confirm each other.”

With this information in hand, the researchers are in a position to further tweak the recipe and perhaps find an efficient way to make methanol from the that’s produced by burning fossil fuels, turning a global warming source into a solution.

Importantly, methanol could be blended into fuel and distributed at existing gas pumps, with no need to build an entirely new fueling infrastructure.

For SUNCAT, the work on is just a beginning, Studt said. “The hope is that we can do this not only for this catalyst, but for other catalysts,” he said. “If you understand how it works, then you have a much different approach to optimizing it than through trial and error.”

Explore further: Metal particle generates new hope for H2 energy

Related Stories

Metal particle generates new hope for H2 energy

June 28, 2011

( -- Tiny metallic particles produced by University of Adelaide chemistry researchers are bringing new hope for the production of cheap, efficient and clean hydrogen energy.

Longer-lasting chemical catalysts

January 13, 2012

Metal-based chemical catalysts have excellent green chemistry credentials—in principle at least. In theory, catalysts are reusable because they drive chemical reactions without being consumed. In reality, however, recovering ...

Designing chemical catalysts: There's an app for that

January 20, 2012

A big reason for publishing scientific results is to inform others who can then use your data and conclusions to make additional discoveries, technologies or products. But what good are findings if they are, well, hard to ...

Defects make catalysts perfect

April 26, 2012

There is now one less mystery in chemical production plants. For many decades industry has been producing methanol on a large scale from a mixture of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide, as well as hydrogen. An international ...

Recommended for you

Study visualizes proteins involved in cancer cell metabolism

May 26, 2016

Scientists using a technology called cryo-EM (cryo-electron microscopy) have broken through a technological barrier in visualizing proteins with an approach that may have an impact on drug discovery and development. They ...

Light can 'heal' defects in some solar cells

May 24, 2016

A family of compounds known as perovskites, which can be made into thin films with many promising electronic and optical properties, has been a hot research topic in recent years. But although these materials could potentially ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.