Plaintiffs face greater obstacles in discrimination suits, study shows

May 23, 2012

(Phys.org) -- University at Buffalo Sociology Professors Ellen Berrey, PhD, and Steve G. Hoffman, PhD, have co-authored a study that shows plaintiffs' limited resources and tumultuous experiences in employment discrimination lawsuits lead them to see this litigation as profoundly unfair.

The study shows that both defendants and plaintiffs question the fundamental fairness of employment discrimination litigation. But employer-defendants tend to have more resources to manage litigation challenges better than those bringing charges.

"We wanted to hear, from actual people involved in employment discrimination lawsuits, what litigation was like for them," says Berrey, assistant professor of sociology at UB and a faculty affiliate of the American Bar Foundation (ABF). "There was one point that nearly everyone agreed on: that litigation is unfair.

"Beyond that, their experiences couldn't have been more different. For plaintiffs, litigation is expensive and can bring real personal hardships. Many end up divorced, depressed, even bankrupt. Employers do not like litigation either, but they usually have the resources and expertise to keep these cases under control."

The study, "Situated Justice: A Contextual Analysis of Fairness and in Employment Discrimination Litigation," published in Law and Society Review, is based on a national random sample of employment civil rights cases and 100 interviews with plaintiffs, defendants, and lawyers who were involved in discrimination suits. Law and Society Review is considered the most-prestigious law and social science journal in the U.S.

Co-authored with Laura Beth Nielsen, a from the Northwestern University and a research professor for the ABF, the study identifies stark differences in how plaintiffs and employer-defendants experience employment discrimination litigation and assess the fairness of law.

Plaintiffs and defendants, according to the study, agree that the legal process is unfair, but find unfairness only in what is to their particular disadvantage. While plaintiffs begin the process optimistically, the study finds, they face significant obstacles in properly defending their claims. Contrary to their expectations, they rarely get a final ruling based on the substantive merits of a case.

These experiences cause them to view the process as unfairly biased in favor of defendant-employers. Yet, employer-defendants find unfairness in the fact that an employee has the power to initiate what they consider a "meritless" suit against the company to which they are required to respond.

The conclusions in "Situated Justice" are amplified by the innovative use of embedded audio in the online version of the published article. Twenty-two audio interviews with the actual plaintiffs and defendants in the cases studied, whose identities have been disguised, can be accessed by viewing the on-line article.

"Online media are an exciting new venue for social scientists," Berrey says. "They enable us to see and hear our evidence in different ways, which actually can strengthen our arguments. And they provide a great platform for sharing research-based insights.

By visiting the American Bar Foundation project website Civil Rights in their Own Voices or viewing the article online, available through 2012, people can listen plaintiffs and defendants discussing the unfairness of employment discrimination litigation.

"You can literally 'hear' our argument in their voices," Berrey says.

"We have a fundamental problem with the legal system," says Hoffman. "The primary way that the law deals with discrimination at work -- litigation -- is considered unfair by both parties, and winning in litigation requires considerable financial and legal resources."

Explore further: Study identifies why re-educating torturers may not work

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Overcoming the fear of hiring employees

Jun 15, 2007

The Civil Rights Act of 1991 (CRA-91) held great promise for protecting workers from discrimination in the workplace. Unfortunately, like many good ideas, CRA-91 had an unintended consequence for employers: ...

The constitutionality of health care reform

Feb 15, 2011

President Obama’s health care reform legislation has been the subject of lively political and legal debate. Many lawsuits have been filed to prevent the implementation of the legislation. These lawsuits claim that ...

Court OKs immunity for telecoms in wiretap case

Dec 30, 2011

A federal appeals court has ruled as constitutional a law giving telecommunications companies legal immunity for helping the government with its email and telephone eavesdropping program.

Olympians sue Samsung over Facebook app

Apr 27, 2012

Eighteen US Olympians including swimming greats Mark Spitz and Janet Evans are suing Samsung Corporation, saying its US Olympic Genome Project Facebook app misuses their names and images.

Recommended for you

Study identifies why re-educating torturers may not work

3 hours ago

Many human rights educators assume – incorrectly, as it turns out – that police and military officers in India who support the torture of suspects do so because they are either immoral or ignorant. This ...

Research helps raise awareness of human trafficking

3 hours ago

Human trafficking –– or the control, ownership and sale of another human being for monetary gain –– was a common occurrence centuries ago, but many believe it doesn't exist in this day and age and not in this country.

Researchers explore future of 'postdigital' textbook

4 hours ago

An interdisciplinary team at Arizona State University has been awarded a grant from the National Science Foundation's Cyberlearning and Future Learning Technologies program to conduct research on the future ...

Revealing political partisanship a bad idea on resumes

22 hours ago

Displaced political aides looking for a new, nonpartisan job in the wake of the midterm power shuffle may fare better if they tone down any political references on their resumes, finds a new study from Duke University.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

StCyrlyMe2
not rated yet May 23, 2012
Trust me it can an has been done Took me 10yrs to resolve my case but it happened!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.