Chicago police cameras more effective when clustered, study says

May 15, 2012

( -- Chicago's network of police cameras is more effective at reducing crime in high-crime areas than in low-crime areas, according to a new study.

The report, co-authored by Rajiv Shah, University of Illinois at Chicago adjunct assistant professor of communication, suggests that blue-light cameras should be concentrated in high-crime areas rather than spread throughout a city.

This "hotspot" approach differs from the way cameras are used in many cities, says Shah, who studies legal and policy implications of .

"The idea championed by former mayor Richard Daley of placing a on every corner results in the vast majority of those cameras having little or no impact on reducing crime," he said.

Shah and co-author Jeremy Braithwaite, a doctoral student at the University of California-Irvine, analyzed two previous studies -- one by students at Northwestern University and the other by the Chicago Department -- that investigated the effectiveness of Chicago's surveillance network.

Their analysis indicates that the initial crime level of an area where a camera was placed had a significant effect on the camera's overall impact. Cameras in high-crime areas were associated with large reductions in crimes, while medium- to low-crime areas experienced minimal change.

"Diffusing a large number of cameras throughout a city does not appear to be effective in reducing crime," Shah said. "Instead, the targeted use of a smaller number of cameras in high-crime areas is much more effective."

The researchers offer three possible explanations for the findings:
-High-crime areas are likely to have increased police presence and additional strategies at work.
-Cameras in high-crime areas are more likely to be monitored at all times.
-The apparent drop in crime in high-crime areas could be partly due to "regression to the mean" -- a statistical effect in which first measurements are extreme and the second measurement tends to be closer to the average.

The researchers describe the impact of surveillance in high-crime areas as the "catalyst effect" of cameras.

"The act of placing cameras in high-crime areas pushes the police to focus their efforts in these areas, thus reducing crime," Shah said.

Further research with experimental controls will be needed to separate out the effects of other policing efforts and to isolate the catalyst effect of cameras, Shah said. Technological advances may also help measure the benefit that cameras provide.

"Cameras have limitations," Shah said. "They are only as good as their technology and the person watching the camera."

The full report, "Spread Too Thin: Analyzing the Effectiveness of the Chicago Camera Network on Crime," appears in the forthcoming issue of Police Practice and Research: An International Journal.

Explore further: Education Dept awards $75M in innovation grants

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Chicago's high-tech cameras spark privacy fears

Feb 08, 2011

A vast network of high-tech surveillance cameras that allows Chicago police to zoom in on a crime in progress and track suspects across the city is raising privacy concerns.

Targeted policing has knock-on benefits

Sep 08, 2011

With the police service undergoing budget reductions, and calls for more officers on the streets, a new study offers some reassuring conclusions. Researchers at UCL's Department of Security and Crime Science found no evidence ...

SW China mega-city building huge security system

Mar 08, 2011

The mega-city of Chongqing in southwest China plans to build a $2.6 billion security system that will be one of the world's largest with 500,000 surveillance cameras, state media have said.

Recommended for you

Research band at Karolinska tuck Dylan gems into papers

22 hours ago

( —A 17-year old bet among scientists at the Karolinska Institute has been a wager that whoever wrote the most articles with Dylan quotes before they retired would get a free lunch. Results included ...

A simulation game to help people prep for court

Sep 25, 2014

Preparing for court and appearing before a judge can be a daunting experience, particularly for people who are representing themselves because they can't afford a lawyer or simply don't know all the ropes ...

When finding 'nothing' means something

Sep 25, 2014

Scientists usually communicate their latest findings by publishing results as scientific papers in journals that are almost always accessible online (albeit often at a price), ensuring fast sharing of latest ...

User comments : 0