Is the Greek haircut a snip too far for investors?

Apr 19, 2012

Research from the University of Reading suggests that the recent bail-out for Greece could lead to decades of legal actions as disgruntled investors sue for compensation.

Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy may think the Greek problem is solved for now but Dr Ioannis Glinavos, from the School of Law, believes legal advisers will be grappling with the issues raised by the country's debt restructuring well into the 2020s.

The and insisted on a debt swap as part of the latest of 130bn Euros to Greece. This so-called ‘haircut' saw some investors lose around 70% of their investment on Greek government bonds and those who were forced to accept the deal are demanding the full value of their investment.

Around 90% of creditors agreed to the debt swap - this was enough support to make it binding on all bondholders, whether they agreed or not.

In his new paper, Investors vs. Greece, The Greek Haircut and Investor Arbitration Under BIT's, Dr. Glinavos says the key issue is whether a reduction in the face value of a sovereign bond is an exercise of legitimate state powers, or a form of expropriation that gives rise to a claim for compensation under international law. Expropriation is the compulsory seizure or surrender of private property for the state's purposes, with little or no compensation to the owner.

The Greek situation has much in common with that of Argentina which defaulted in 2001. A significant portion of its bondholders went to court to win compensation. After a decade of wrangling, tribunals have ruled that investors can sue for compensation under investment treaties Argentina had signed.

Dr. Glinavos said: "The Argentine precedent demonstrates that there are always some ‘holdouts' during a restructuring -disgruntled investors who refuse to negotiate and demand the full value of their investment, even in desperate situations for the countries involved.

"The events in Greece since 2010 will occupy policy makers and market participants for the foreseeable future. They will also occupy courts and arbitral tribunals in multiple jurisdictions. In the same way that Argentina‘s default led to legal actions that are still to reach a conclusion, legal advisers will be grappling with the issues raised by Greece's workout well into the 2020s.

"The message for investors seeking to sue for their losses is that they have a long and hard road ahead of them, but the very fact that a road exists is reason for optimism that a possibility of recouping some of their losses survives. Whether should pursue this lengthy legal battle is another question. When there is money to be made, someone somewhere will always consider options, regardless of the damage such action may cause to the country concerned and its prospects for recovery."

Explore further: Highly connected CEOs more likely to broker mergers and acquisitions that harm firms

More information: Glinavos, Ioannis, Investors vs. Greece: The Greek 'Haircut' and Investor Arbitration Under BIT's (April 05, 2012). Available at SSRN: ssrn.com/abstract=2021137

Provided by University of Reading

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Greek teen arrested over ministry cyber attack

Feb 20, 2012

Greek police said Monday they had arrested an 18-year-old suspected of hacking into the justice ministry's website earlier this month, an attack claimed on behalf of online hackers group Anonymous.

3 Questions: David Singer on the Greek Euro-tragedy

Jun 22, 2011

The economic and fiscal woes of Greece remain at the center of European politics. In recent months, a variety of economists and commentators have asked if Greece should consider the unprecedented move of leaving ...

Greece 'to export solar power to Germany'

Aug 28, 2011

Wracked by debt but blessed with abundant sunshine, Greece plans to develop some 20,000 hectares of solar power parks in a bid to export renewable energy to Germany, a report said on Saturday.

Complexity of financial services industry

Jan 04, 2008

The financial services industry is complex and financial service professionals are becoming less distinguishable and more inter-related, according to a new RAND Corporation report issued today.

Recommended for you

Migrant employment on the rise

23 hours ago

Skilled migrants are enjoying better jobs and higher levels of employment thanks to a shift in policy, according to a new study by the Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research at the University ...

Three hours of life per euro

Oct 15, 2014

Public spending appears to have contributed substantially to the fact that life expectancy in eastern Germany has not only increased, but is now almost equivalent to life expectancy in the west. While the possible connection ...

User comments : 0