Google Drive: Watch out, cloud computing in U.S. like 'Wild West'

Apr 26, 2012 By Michelle Maltais

With the advent of Google Drive, we talk about cloud computing as if the bits and bytes of our lives are stored somewhere up in the air, but, really, the "clouds" are very terrestrial. What's more up in the air are the laws that govern who can access your stuff and how.

Originally a way for geeks to explain to the rest of us the notion of remote servers storing and serving up content, can be defined several different ways, depending on whom you ask. In some ways, even email is a form of cloud computing. (It really lives on a server somewhere out there and is served up wherever we desire.)

"The problem that cloud computing has, more generally, is that (the real world) assumes that rights are based geographically," Mark Radcliffe, senior partner at law firm DLA Piper, said in an interview with the newspaper. "That assumption is not realistic in the cloud."

Why? Who knows where the servers really sit? They may be in the United States, governed by American laws. Or they may be across the pond in Europe, where there are rather stringent . Regardless of where the company is based, the location of the determine in some large part who can legally gain access to the content on them and how.

"The U.S. is more like the Wild West," Radcliffe said. "It's very heterogeneous," with laws at the federal, state and sometimes the municipal level.

One concern some have expressed online and out loud is how could gain access to your digital life stored in a cloud.

With a computer in your home, you'd have to be served a warrant for legal access to your . But with remote storage, you may not know whether a subpoena or warrant has been served on the cloud .

"Law enforcement can subpoena the service, but it depends on their contractual obligation," Radcliffe said. In other words, what they spell out in their terms of service. Always remember, that's a contract that you agree to by using the service.

Most terms of service include a clause stating the provider would give up your information if required by law, with no mention of whether it would inform you. Interestingly enough, Dropbox's Terms of Service says something a little different.

It reads: "To be clear, aside from the rare exceptions we identify in our Privacy Policy, no matter how the Services change, we won't share your content with others, including law enforcement, for any purpose unless you direct us to."

The Dropbox privacy policy section on compliance with laws and law enforcement does say the company may disclose information it collects when there is a "good faith belief that disclosure is reasonably necessary to (a) comply with a law, regulation or compulsory legal request; (b) protect the safety of any person from death or serious bodily injury; (c) prevent fraud or abuse of Dropbox or its users; or (d) protect Dropbox's property rights."

But it further states that if you encrypt your stuff before storing it there, the company can't undo that. Something to keep in mind.

So, the obligation varies by company and the rules vary by jurisdiction. That's a lot of variation to process.

"The direction I think is most likely is an agreed-upon code of conduct," Radcliffe said. "We're urging that right now (and are) working with a number of companies right now to see if we can do that."

Jeff Fowler, a partner at law firm O'Melveney & Myers, told the newspaper, "We in the law business are always chasing these technological developments." Until the law catches up, he advised, a consumer really needs to be a good self-advocate, keeping track of terms of service and privacy policies.

"There is no easy way to wrap your arms around a cloud," Fowler said. "The name is quite fitting. It will require a lot of creative thinking over the next few years."

Explore further: Britain threatens Internet 'trolls' with two years in jail

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Cloud computing: The good, the bad, and the ugly

Nov 24, 2010

A survey of 31 Cloud computing contracts from 27 different providers has found that many include clauses that could have a significant impact, often negative, on the rights and interests of customers.

Google might launch Drive for cloud storage soon

Feb 12, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- Google's next big move, according to the Wall Street Journal, is a cloud storage service called Drive. Hardly first to the plate, Google is simply catching up to introducing its cloud reposi ...

Oracle buys 'cloud' service firm RightNow

Oct 24, 2011

Enterprise software giant Oracle said Monday it had struck a deal to buy RightNow Technologies, which helps companies manage their cloud computing activities, for $1.5 billion.

Is personal data safe at firms?

Jun 22, 2009

Making rules can be just as difficult as complying with them. Dutch researcher Marieke Thijssen investigated how well the Personal Data Protection Act (Dutch acronym Wbp) is harmonised with other rules that firms must comply ...

Recommended for you

Facebook unfriends federal drug agency

Oct 17, 2014

(AP)—Facebook wants assurances from the Drug Enforcement Administration that it's not operating any more fake profile pages as part of ongoing investigations.

Obama unveils new measures to stem identity theft

Oct 17, 2014

US President Barack Obama on Friday ordered "pin and chip" security measures for government payment systems, aiming to stem the proliferation of credit card fraud and identity theft.

User comments : 0