Experts suggest steps to stop spread of resistant corn rootworms

April 23, 2012 by David Tenenbaum

( -- The discovery that more Western corn rootworms are resistant to the toxin contained in widely planted transgenic corn has sparked a warning that farmers must change tactics or lose a valuable management tool against a traditional corn pest.

In a March 5 letter to the Environmental Protection Agency, 22 working on rootworm suggested changes to prolong the utility of transgenic Bt corn. Committee chair Eileen Cullen, an extension specialist and associate professor of entomology at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, says a significant majority of Wisconsin farmers grow corn containing one or more Bt genes, which replace chemical insecticides.

Bt derives its name from , the that was the source of the gene for insect-killing protein.

"Although rootworms that resist Bt have been confirmed in Iowa, and suspected in Illinois, Minnesota and Nebraska, resistance has not been confirmed here. However, we have seen fields in Wisconsin with more rootworm feeding than you would expect with these hybrids," Cullen says, which suggests that resistance may be evolving here as well.

The Bt protein produced by transgenic corn kills corn rootworms, says Cullen. "But when broad acreages of corn contain the same active ingredient year after year, the stage is set for some insects in the population to adapt and become resistant to the toxin. That is apparently what's happening in Iowa."

Although three distinct Bt proteins are now encoded in transgenic corn for corn rootworm control, the first and most common protein, called Cry3Bb1, is the focus of current resistance concerns.

feeds on corn roots and can cause plants to collapse. Before transgenic corn was introduced about a decade ago, the insect was controlled with or by applying insecticide to the soil at corn planting.

Transgenic seeds are convenient because they allow the farmer to avoid buying and applying insecticide, and reducing the use of insecticides produces an environmental benefit.

Several techniques can be used to stop or slow insect resistance to transgenic corn, Cullen says. Farmers are required by the to plant "refuges" of corn that lack the Bt toxin, where non-resistant rootworms can pass on their susceptible genes to the rootworm population. Farmers may also rotate through transgenic seeds containing different Bt toxins.

In any case, it's vital to monitor fields to detect problems early, says Cullen, who is also a UW extension specialist in field and forage crop entomology. "Resistance can definitely develop that people don't notice if they are not aware of the potential problem."

Planting transgenic corn that produces multiple toxins can also fight resistance, but that technique is less effective if the insects already resist one of those toxins, Cullen says.

In a parallel situation, several weeds have evolved resistance to glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, a herbicide applied to millions of acres of corn and soybean.

In all cases, if only resistant organisms can survive and multiply, resistance becomes widespread. The threat of resistance among insect pests is one reason that organic farmers, who sometimes rely on Bacillus thuringiensis to kill insects, opposed the transgenic Bt crops.

As the threat of insect resistance grows, Cullen says, farmers and their advisors need to take the issue seriously, by planting the appropriate refuges and choosing seeds carefully based on knowledge of insect pest pressure on the farm.

If arises, Cullen suggests rotating to other Bt corn traits, or using conventional seeds and insecticides. This can be difficult because many top corn varieties are only sold as transgenics, and modern corn-planters often lack equipment for applying insecticide.

"Entomologists, biologists and farmers know that when you use one tactic for pest management, whether it's an insecticide or a Bt trait, insects can adapt," says Cullen. "The letter to EPA is an urgent reminder that an integrated approach will serve us best in the long term."

The letter to the EPA can be found here.

Explore further: UW-Madison entomologist helps farmers deal with tricky crop pest

Related Stories

New bacteria toxins against resistant insect pests

October 19, 2011

Toxins from Bacillus thuringiensis bacteria (Bt toxins) are used in organic and conventional farming to manage pest insects. Sprayed as pesticides or produced in genetically modified plants, Bt toxins, used in pest control ...

Recommended for you

Smarter brains are blood-thirsty brains

August 30, 2016

A University of Adelaide-led project has overturned the theory that the evolution of human intelligence was simply related to the size of the brain—but rather linked more closely to the supply of blood to the brain.

Herbicides can't stop invasive plants. Can bugs?

August 31, 2016

Over the past 35 years, state and federal agencies have spent millions of dollars and dumped untold quantities of herbicides into waterways trying to control the invasive water chestnut plant, but the intruder just keeps ...

Defend or grow? These plants do both

August 30, 2016

From natural ecosystems to farmers' fields, plants face a dilemma of energy use: outgrow and outcompete their neighbors for light, or defend themselves against insects and disease.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.