Vegetarian cutlet

Mar 06, 2012
The ingredients in this cutlet are 100 percent vegetable. Credit: Fraunhofer IVV

It looks like a cutlet, it's juicy and fibrous like a cutlet, and it even chews with the consistency of a real cutlet -- but the ingredients are 100 percent vegetable. Researchers are using a new method to prepare a meat substitute that not only tastes good, but is also environmentally sustainable.

Meat production is complicated, costly and not eco-friendly: fatted have to consume five to eight kilos of grain just to generate one of . It would be simpler and more sustainable if one were to make cutlets out of seed – without the detour through the animal's body. Impossible? Not entirely: there are plants that are suitable for the production of meat substitute products. Researchers in the EU-project "LikeMeat" have studied what they are, and how they can be incorporated into a product that tastes and looks like meat. "Studies have shown that many Europeans are ready to give up meat, but there have only been a handful of alternatives until now," explains Florian Wild. The researcher at the Fraunhofer Institute for Process Engineering and Packaging IVV in Freising is spearheading the project. "Our goal is to develop a vegetable surrogate for meat that is both juicy and fibrous, but that also has a pleasant flavor. The product should have a long shelf life, it should not be more expensive than meat, and be suitable for vegetarians and allergy sufferers."

In addition to the scientists at IVV, experts from the University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna (BOKU) are also participating in the development, as are consumer researchers from the University of Wageningen, in the Netherlands, and eleven small to medium-sized corporations that manufacture or do business in food or food ingredients. The team roster also includes two Austrian and one Dutch company that have hitherto only processed meat, as well as an organic food producer from Spain. "As a group, we are seeking to engineer a simple production chain in which pure vegetable raw materials are used to produce a meat substitute that corresponds to consumer preferences," as Wild summarizes it. The ingredients originate from the land: Wheat and peas, lupins and soya are all suited for production, explains Wild: "We are intentionally not tying ourselves down to one type of plant because many people get an allergic reaction to the one or other substance. In the process, we have developed a variety of recipes. They are the basis for a product spectrum that offers a broad selection to people who suffer food intolerance or allergies."

But how do you turn a field crop into meat? "The processing technology was the biggest challenge," recalls the project manager. The previously conventional methods of mixing plant proteins with a little water, and heating them under high pressure, proved to be useless: With this hot extrusion process, the mass is heated up under high pressure. At the moment when it pushes through the die, the temperature drops dramatically, steam is released and the mass foams up. That is certainly the desired effect when making peanut flips. But not in the production of meat substitutes. Wild and his colleagues use a new process specially developed for meat substitutes: The main ingredients – water and plant proteins – are brought to a boil and slowly cooled down. Since no sudden release of pressure takes place, no steam blows out of the paste. As the temperature sinks, the protein molecules start to form chains. This gives rise to a fibrous structure that is quite similar to that of meat.

The prototype of the new vegetarian cutlet factory is currently located in the IVV laboratory. The system is no larger than two table tennis tables. On request, it can produce one endless piece of meat approximately 1-cm thick that can be shaped as desired, for example into little morsels for diced or thinly-sliced meats, or entire cutlets. The research team is currently able to produce 60 to 70 kilos of the meat substitute per hour – or 300 to 500 kilos per day. "Consistency and texture are already superb," Wild assures. There is still a little work to do on the flavor. By the end of the project term, in one year, the meat substitute from the land should be every bit as good as a genuine cutlet, and it should come directly from the machine, ready-to-eat. The experts will present their new product at the Anuga FoodTec trade fair from March 27 through March 30 in Cologne.

Explore further: Smart labels detect contaminated meat before it hits shelves

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Eating low-fat, thanks to lupin proteins

Jan 03, 2011

Food should be delicious, healthy and sustainably produced. Researchers are working on new methods to use as many parts of plants as possible for nutrition. In the future, vegetable ingredients could replace ...

Mankind benefits from eating less meat

Apr 06, 2006

If people were to eat more vegetable proteins instead of animal proteins, this would result in multiple – and much-needed – benefits. Such a 'protein transition' will positively affect sustainable energy production, sustainable ...

Survey: Meat eaters want no hormones

May 11, 2006

U.S. residents eat meat an average of 4.2 times a week, and most want assurances it was raised humanely and without antibiotics, a new survey found.

PETA offers $1 million for fake meat

Apr 22, 2008

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, the animal rights group based in Virginia, is offering a $1 million prize for meat produced in a laboratory.

Recommended for you

Free pores for molecule transport

17 hours ago

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) can take up gases similar to a sponge that soaks up liquids. Hence, these highly porous materials are suited for storing hydrogen or greenhouse gases. However, loading of many ...

User comments : 12

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Eikka
not rated yet Mar 06, 2012
If I understood correctly, this process produces "meat" that is already cooked?

Which is great, if all you ever want to eat is cutlets.
gwrede
not rated yet Mar 06, 2012
Fake meat for the masses. Reminds me of the origin of margarine. I see the day when only the rich get to eat genuine meat. I wonder what 50 years of eating this stuff does to your health.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.3 / 5 (36) Mar 06, 2012
I have some "chicken fingers" and "chicken cutlets" made with a similar or identical process in my refrigerator right now.

They make a nearly perfect substitute for the real thing. The texture is spot on. At least for a chicken replacement.
gmurphy
5 / 5 (1) Mar 07, 2012
@gwrede, compared to 50 years of eating burgers and hot-dogs?, I think I could take my chances with reduced vegetable matter.
Eikka
not rated yet Mar 07, 2012
@gwrede, compared to 50 years of eating burgers and hot-dogs?, I think I could take my chances with reduced vegetable matter.


The difference is, that you don't have to eat at McD every day.

I would eat fake meat though, if they can make substitute raw meat that I could cut, marinade, season and cook any way I like it. Think about what happens to food culture if the only meat you can buy is pre-processed into cutlets and nuggets.
Vendicar_Decarian
0 / 5 (35) Mar 07, 2012
I think the process right now is best suited for breaded cutlets and the like because the surface of the extruded product does not resemble smooth muscle. It does cut well though, and has a texture indistinguishable from chicken IMO.

The process is reasonably new. I read about it first, about 4-5 years ago.

It will only improve.
Tausch
1 / 5 (1) Mar 09, 2012
Onward. Participating researchers...take heed. The perfect feedback here. Win over critics with more than ready-to-go nuggets and cutlets.

Simply present more preparation/manipulation possibilities at the fair.
Kudos to all.
Tausch
1 / 5 (1) Mar 10, 2012
Addendum.
Alternative to meat loaf is malt loaf. Not quite OT - on topic.

The purest of beers - dictated by decree and law over 1200 years:
German Beers - upon request gluten free without taste change for those in need.
bg1
not rated yet Mar 10, 2012
How dies the amino acid profile of this "meat" protein compare with real meat? I bet it lacks sulfur amino acids, just all other plant proteins.
antialias_physorg
not rated yet Mar 12, 2012
There is still a little work to do on the flavor.

Reminds me a lot of the 'bean cakes' you can buy in Asia shops. They already have the correct fibery nature (and a very meatlike color) but the flavor is basically non-existent.

I see the day when only the rich get to eat genuine meat.

Even today the masses can buy/use margerine. But meat products will likely become more expensive (and hopefully higher quality) - which will mean less meat consumed per person per day. Seeing that we're already consuming way too much meat a little reduction can only be a good thing.

But I'd prefer the sythetic meat grown from animal stem cells to this (about which there was a report on phyorg not long ago). Meat may not be as efficient to make, but there are nutrients in there that plants don't supply (in adequate amounts).
Vendicar_Decarian
not rated yet Mar 12, 2012
This stuff is just heat extruded Soy Protein. It is a new process that produces a more realistic meat like texture.

"How dies the amino acid profile of this "meat" protein compare with real meat?" - Bq1
Eventide
not rated yet Mar 12, 2012
Will there be all 20 essential amino acids or do we need to mix and match different fake meats like we already do with rice and beans? I hope they supplement it with vitamins and have stringent quality control so that we don't have the melamine contamination scare from China a while back.