Ant identification boosts blue butterflies

March 5, 2012 By Tamera Jones
Ant identification boosts blue butterflies
A Large Blue butterfly resting on bracken.

Scientists have developed a fast, cheap and reliable technique that vastly improves the chances of successfully reintroducing the endangered large blue butterfly to the UK.

The test can tell the difference between two ant species that look virtually identical to us, but which are far from it – at least from the rare butterfly's point of view.

One type of ant is essential for the large blue's survival, while the other spells almost certain death.

"The ants in question – two species of Myrmica red ants – look very similar and even trained ant taxonomists have trouble distinguishing between the two," says Rhian Guillem from the University of Sheffield, who led the study. "And there are only a handful of people who can do this in the UK."

But scientists are discovering that even if two look alike, the chemical compounds on their bodies can be very different. It's this difference that can be used to tell the two species of red ant apart.

"Myrmica sabuleti is the right ant, the one that's essential to the large blue's survival. It has a chemical called 5-methylpentacosane on its cuticle. The other ant, Myrmica scabrinodis has a different chemical, 3-methyltricosane," explains Guillem.

Social butterfly

The large blue butterfly has to have one of the insect world's strangest life cycles. It starts with an adult laying its eggs on thyme buds. Once the eggs have hatched, the caterpillars feed on the flowers for a couple of weeks before falling to the ground.

The next – and possibly oddest – stage is where the ants come in. The caterpillars both mimic the sound of M sabuleti queen ants and smell like ant larvae, which dupes worker ants into carrying them into their nests. Once inside the nest, the caterpillars devour the ant brood at the same time as being cleaned and looked after by their unsuspecting hosts.

"These exacting requirements weren't well understood 30 years ago, which led to the large blue going extinct in the British Isles in 1979," says Guillem.

But painstaking research in the early 80s by Jeremy Thomas, then from the Centre for Ecology & Hydrology led to the reintroduction of a Swedish population to the UK's Dartmoor National Park in 1983.

Twenty-five years on, large blues live in around 30 colonies around south west England. Two of the largest sites support between 4,000 and 5,000 adults – populations not seen in this country since the 1950s. These may now be possibly the largest concentrated populations in the world.

Despite this good news, UK large blue populations are still fragile. Not just that, but reintroductions aren't always successful.

"The problem is that the sites are small and spaced out, and there's always the risk of local extinctions, which means they have to keep being reintroduced," says Guillem.

"The conservation of this butterfly is important, because it's a priority species under the UK Biodiversity Action Plan. We've got to get the population stable to meet targets to reverse global species declines," she adds.

But the biggest challenge for the success of any reintroduction programme is making sure the right ant is there to support large blue butterfly caterpillars. Unfortunately both M sabuleti and M scabrinodis tend to live in the same habitats, which happen to be ideal for the butterfly.

"This means it's hard to be confident that a reintroduction will be successful if you just rely on the taxonomic differences between the red ants," adds Guillem.

She and colleagues from the universities of Sheffield and Keele realised they might be able to use their knowledge in the emerging field of chemo-taxonomy to solve the problem.

"Taxonomists have already exploited differences in chemical compounds on insects' cuticles to differentiate species that look alike," she says. But this is the first time the technique has used to help protect an endangered species.

Other large across Europe are also in serious decline, but Guillem says the new technique could help stop them from going extinct.

The study is published in Biological Conservation.

Explore further: Wood ant queen has no egg-laying monopoly

More information: R.M. Guillem, F.P. Drijfhout, S.J. Martin, Using chemo-taxonomy of host ants to help conserve the large blue butterfly, Biologial Conservation, published online 20 February 2012,

Related Stories

Wood ant queen has no egg-laying monopoly

June 28, 2007

The reproductive monopoly of the ant queen is not as strong as is often thought. Dr. Heikki Helanterä and Prof. Lotta Sundström, biologists working at the University of Helsinki, Finland, investigated worker ovary development ...

Smell-wars between butterflies and ants

January 3, 2008

Among humans, making yourself smell more alluring than you really are is a fairly harmless, socially accepted habit that maintains a complete perfume industry. However, it is a matter of life and death for caterpillars of ...

Nature and nurture help ant societies run smoothly

April 22, 2011

Picture an ant colony: up to a million ants, all looking identical, harmoniously going about their busy ant lives. But with so many ants around, how on Earth do they know who's friend and who's foe?

Recommended for you

A 100-million-year partnership on the brink of extinction

May 24, 2016

A relationship that has lasted for 100 million years is at serious risk of ending, due to the effects of environmental and climate change. A species of spiny crayfish native to Australia and the tiny flatworms that depend ...

Silencing cholera's social media

May 24, 2016

Bacteria use a form of "social media" communication called quorum sensing to monitor how many of their fellow species are in the neighborhood, allowing them to detect changes in density and respond with changes in collective ...

Evolution influenced by temporary microbes

May 24, 2016

Life on Earth often depends on symbiotic relationships between microbes and other forms of life. A new theory suggests that researchers should consider how symbiotic microbes can influence the evolution of life on Earth, ...

Great apes communicate cooperatively

May 24, 2016

Human language is a fundamentally cooperative enterprise, embodying fast-paced interactions. It has been suggested that it evolved as part of a larger adaptation of humans' unique forms of cooperation. In a cross-species ...

Rare evolutionary event detected in the lab

May 23, 2016

It took nearly a half trillion tries before researchers at The University of Texas at Austin witnessed a rare event and perhaps solved an evolutionary puzzle about how introns, non-coding sequences of DNA located within genes, ...

In changing oceans, cephalopods are booming

May 23, 2016

Humans have changed the world's oceans in ways that have been devastating to many marine species. But, according to new evidence, it appears that the change has so far been good for cephalopods, the group including octopuses, ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 06, 2012
This makes no sense.
The butterfly has become extinct due to the interaction with ants.
The fact that other populations are also threatened indicates that this particular species has poor survival prospects.
So why fight a losing battle.
If you overcome the problem ants what ripple effects might that have on other life forms.
This is a waste of time money and effort.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.