Twitter subpoenas a challenge to intellectual privacy

Feb 15, 2012 By Jessica Martin

The City of New York recently subpoenaed a Twitter account as part of an ongoing Occupy Wall Street criminal case. The Occupy protester named in the case is challenging the subpoena.

Privacy law expert Neil Richards, JD, professor of law at Washington University in St. Louis, says that it’s not surprising that law enforcement groups are interested in accessing the volume of records relating to our speech that social media platforms generate.

“By and large, this data should remain private, and online companies should keep the data confidential and not share it any more broadly than we as users and speakers want it to be shared,” Richards says.

“Records of our communications involve our intellectual privacy, and to allow the state to study our private thoughts and words is to allow monitoring of our civil liberties on an Orwellian scale.”

Richards says that U.S. law is somewhat protective of online communications, though the main line of defense comes not from the law but from the behavior of records holders like Google, , and Facebook.

He applauds companies like Twitter who resist handing broad swathes of intellectual data to the government. Mozilla and Google also have a good record of protecting the privacy and confidentiality of their users.

“In our digital world, the battles for civil liberties are increasingly being fought on the front lines of social media, and companies are our first line of defense against the kind of Big Brother-style surveillance our traditions reject,” Richards says.

“In the absence of stronger laws, the positions these companies take have a real impact on the practical state of our . I’m very glad that Twitter is siding with its users as citizens in these debates rather than the government.”

The full subpoena is available at www.scribd.com/doc/79940746/Su… na-on-destructuremal

Explore further: Erdogan passes law tightening Turkey's grip on Internet

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Twitter users seek privacy in WikiLeaks case

Feb 16, 2011

Lawyers for three Twitter users asked a US judge to overturn a court order directing the microblogging site to disclose clients' data to US authorities for a probe into WikiLeaks.

Internet firm fought court order in WikiLeaks case

Oct 10, 2011

A small California-based Internet provider is the second company to confirm it fought back against a court demanding a customer's account information as part of a criminal investigation into the release of documents by WikiLeaks.

Recommended for you

US threatened Yahoo with huge fine over surveillance

Sep 11, 2014

US authorities threatened to fine Yahoo $250,000 a day if it failed to comply with a secret surveillance program requiring it to hand over user data in the name of national security, court documents showed ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Rule of Wolves
5 / 5 (1) Feb 15, 2012
The subpoena is from the New York County District Attorney's Office, better known as the Manhattan DA's office. The hearing on the Motion to Quash will be on February 29th. I represent several of the protestors and none of their accounts subpoenaed according to the ADA handling these cases.