Google's Schmidt warns regulators against killing innovation

Feb 28, 2012
Google CEO Eric Schmidt gives a press conference in Barcelona on the second day of the Mobile World Congress. Schmidt urged regulators to allow technology to develop its own solutions amid privacy concerns, warning that drawing up specific laws could stifle innovation.

Google chief Eric Schmidt on Tuesday urged regulators to allow technology to develop its own solutions amid privacy concerns, warning that drawing up specific laws could stifle innovation.

"If you have to regulate, try to regulate the outcome not the technology. If there's an outcome that you don't like, don't specify in law a technical solution because technology moves forward," he told regulators during a keynote address at the world's biggest mobile fair.

"There're so many new technologies that help protect privacy ... that you hope the privacy regulator will never restrict that," he said, pointing out that the "unintended cost of regulation is often the loss of innovation."

Google has come under pressure in several jurisdictions, including and France, over its new privacy policy which allows it to regroup data from several different services that were previously separate.

On Tuesday, France demanded that the postpone rolling out the policy due to come into effect Thursday as it appears to break European Union data protection rules.

While Schmidt did not refer to the specific issue, he pointed to Europe's "strong commitment to privacy" but said that "if you look at recent initiatives, they are well intentioned but harder to define."

The launched in January a bid to make companies including Internet giants such as Google or Facebook give people more control of their or face big fines.

The proposal championed by EU Justice Commissioner Viviane Reding would force all companies to get explicit consent from customers to collect their data, explain how it will be used, and allow users to totally erase their information.

Schmidt also made a strong call for the web to remain restricted.

He highlighted the role that the Internet had played in the Arab Spring, pointing out that "decisions that are being made by are in fact quite consequential."

"The fact that information is hard to block has implications for the Arab Spring. So there's a lot of reasons that have a political consequence, they don't have a political goal but a political consequence," he said.

"They tend to have a pro-democracy, pro-communication, pro-freedom of expression bias. It's one of the best exports out of our industry," he added.

Nevertheless, for all the calls of access freedoms, Schmidt admitted that there are limits.

Asked by an Iranian member of the audience if will stop blocking Android or Chrome downloads in his country, Schmidt said that the ban was due to US sanctions on Iran and that "we can't violate US law."

"I'm with you, but prison, it's like, there's no bandwidth!" he said.

Explore further: US regulator says Fiat Chrysler recall woes are widespread

Related Stories

S. Korea urges Google to improve privacy

Feb 28, 2012

South Korean regulators Tuesday voiced concerns over Google's controversial plan to merge user data from YouTube, Gmail, Google+ and other services in individual comprehensive profiles.

EU probes new Google privacy policy

Feb 03, 2012

The European Union's data protection authorities have asked Google to delay the rollout of its new privacy policy until they have verified that it doesn't break the bloc's data protection laws.

French regulator warns of Google privacy policy

Feb 28, 2012

Google's new privacy policy appears to violate the European Union's data protection rules, France's regulator said Tuesday, just two days before the new guidelines are set to come into force.

Recommended for you

Barnes & Noble names Sears Canada CEO for retail business

2 hours ago

Barnes & Noble, which is splitting into two companies next month, named Sears Canada CEO Ronald Boire to lead its retail operations and said company CEO Michael Huseby will become executive chairman its educational wing.

Hewlett-Packard moves forward with plan to split in two

17 hours ago

Hewlett-Packard is moving forward with plans to split into two companies, filing paperwork to create a new entity that will sell commercial technology, while a separate spinoff will sell personal computers and printers.

Global pharma firms grilled about tax in Australia

Jul 01, 2015

The world's top pharmaceutical companies Wednesday told an Australian parliamentary hearing they were compliant with local and international laws, despite claims they are charging higher prices to minimise tax.

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2 / 5 (4) Feb 28, 2012
is this a joke?

it's the rise of mega monopolies that use government regulation to stifle innovation by putting up cost structures and regulatory hurdles for small companies and individual inventors that INNOVATE , not google.

please. eric schmidt, there is a reason the dynamic duo came back to oust you from managing their company you corporate tool.
1 / 5 (1) Feb 28, 2012

Schmidt must be using the Friedman & Rand's New Capitalist Dictionary definition of "innovation".

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.