China's urbanization unlikely to lead to fast growth of middle class: UW geographer

Feb 29, 2012

The number of people living in China's cities, which last year for the first time surpassed 50 percent of the national population, is considered a boon for the consumer goods market. That is based on the assumption that there will be more families with more disposable income when poor farmers from China's countryside move to cities and become middle-class industrial and office workers.

But the assumption overlooks a policy from the era of Chinese leader Mao Zedong that restricts the upward mobility of its rural citizens, says a University of Washington geographer.

This calls into question China's strength in the global market and its ability to overtake the United States as a global superpower, according to Kam Wing Chan, a UW professor of geography.

His findings are published in the current issue of the journal Eurasian Geography and Economics.

Studying China's population statistics, Chan found that unlike many , where urbanization has generally progressed hand-in-hand with growth of middle-class urban dwellers, China's increasing number of urbanites is largely due to higher concentrations of impoverished laborers who move from the countryside to cities for employment. These laborers usually end up in low-paid factory and service jobs. With little , they have limited prospects of moving up to the middle class.

The workers who move from the countryside to cities are also confined by a residency system, established in 1958, that created a two-tier, rural-urban divide that remains largely unchanged today, Chan said.

The system, called "hukou," designated an urban class eligible for and a second-rank rural, peasant class, ineligible for basic social benefits largely found in the city. Forbidden to go to cities during Mao's era, rural hukou holders were restricted to the countryside to grow food for urban workers.

Now rural workers can move to cities to work, but they cannot claim urban social benefits, including unemployment and retirement benefits, Chan said. Many employment and education opportunities are off limits to them and their family. Since hukou status is hereditary, children of rural hukou holders living in cities are not supposed to go to urban public schools. In a limited number of cities in which they are permitted in public schools, they have to pay much higher tuition fees.

Analyzing population statistics from China's National Bureau of Statistics and the Ministry of Public Security, Chan found that about 460 million people had urban hukou status in 2010, while the entire population of Chinese city-dwellers was 666 million. The difference – 206 million, or about two-thirds of the total U.S. population – is made up mostly of rural migrants, people with rural hukou status but who live and work in cities.

This is what "supplies China with a huge, almost inexhaustible, pool of super-exploitable labor," wrote Chan.

He also found that a significant number of new additions to the urban hukou population, people who have succeeded in changing their designation, actually have only nominal urban hukou status. In other words, they received urban status but with limited or no urban benefits.

Between those lacking any urban designation and those with only nominal status, significantly more than 206 million people are living in Chinese cities without access to basic urban social benefits.

Chan said that the consequences of this social engineering under the hukou system is a greater income gap between rich and poor, and little growth of a middle class from rural hukou holders moving to cities.

"These migrant workers and their children have slim chances of improving their circumstances through education or getting higher-paid jobs under the current system," he said.

Explore further: Tax benefits for housing not as outsized as previously thought, study says

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Grandparents key to China's expansion

Oct 26, 2006

Rural China's elders care for grandchildren after parents migrate to urban centers and now a U.S. study finds that is a key factor in China's expansion.

Ecological impact of African cities

Dec 02, 2008

African cities are growing faster than anywhere else in the world. This is having a major impact, but few ecologists are studying the urban environment and effect of cities on rural areas. One of the most important ecological ...

Lack of sick leave creates tough choices for rural workers

Jul 11, 2011

Rural workers have less access to sick leave, forcing them to choose between caring for themselves or family members, and losing pay or perhaps even their jobs when faced with an illness, according to new research from the ...

Recommended for you

The tyranny of realism in energy planning

21 hours ago

A report exploring the political economy of energy planning under democracy and the Integrated Energy Planning (IEP) process due to conclude this year was launched by the British High Commission, Project ...

Organising is the key to efficient purchasing

Aug 19, 2014

A well-functioning purchasing organisation is a powerful tool for companies. Chalmers researcher Ingrid Hessel shows in her thesis that internal purchasing operations affects and is affected by relationships ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

bredmond
not rated yet Feb 29, 2012
this is too narrowly focused. there are other factors too. for example, many of the children of these workers are in universities getting college educations. i teach a lot of such people. whenever i ask them what they are going to do after they graduate, about four out of five say: go to graduate school. Those people will be the middle class. Why even assume workers will be the middle class? in any case, many workers i have encountered really do a committed job to find any way they can make money. they buy and then rent out apartments, they invest in the stock market, both husband and wife work, and sometimes own multiple stores.