TVs getting 'smarter' but maybe not better

Jan 20, 2012 By Troy Wolverton

If last week's Consumer Electronics Show is any indication, the next major computing device to enter consumers' homes will be a "smart" television - whether viewers like it or not.

The new TVs will let users play "Angry Birds," instantly view photos taken by multiple people and shared online, or try on virtual clothes without needing a game console or a set-top box. And they'll allow users to change the channel or search for TV shows by waving at the screen or using their voice.

While television manufacturers have been hawking smart or Internet-connected televisions at CES for the past three years, those capabilities are now making their way into mainstream sets. The most advanced of those TVs are starting to gain features previously found only on computing devices, including powerful , full operating systems and sophisticated input mechanisms that go far beyond the standard remote controls.

Lenovo showed off a new at CES that has specs you'd expect to find in the latest smartphones, including the newest version of Google's Android operating system and a . LG unveiled televisions running the latest version of Google , which is a variation of . And Samsung displayed televisions that include a camera-based sensor similar to the Kinect device for Microsoft's .

Nuance Communications, the company that provides the capability underlying the Siri technology in Apple's 4S, demonstrated TVs that allow users to search for comedies, say, by simply saying that.

Meanwhile, Bodymetrics, a London-based startup, showed off how consumers could use a Kinect-like device to turn their living room into a virtual dressing room. Users see a representation of themselves on their TV that moves in sync with them. They can select different clothes and see instantly how they fit and look.

But consumer demand for smart TV is uncertain. Early versions of TV devices have been around since late 2010, but have seen disappointing sales. And while many televisions sold in the past year or two can be connected to the Internet, many never are.

Many consumers may want to watch Netflix on their big screen, but whether anyone other than tech geeks will want to use them to surf the Web, check their Twitter feed or use smartphone-like apps is far from clear.

The flurry of innovation is driven less by consumer demand than by the declining sales and profits of television manufacturers. They hope adding new features will shore up prices and spur sales of new sets. With 3-D technology having failed to generate much interest, they now hope smart TVs will save them.

Manufacturers also feel pressure from a company that wasn't at CES - Apple. The company has reportedly been working on a smart TV for years and is widely expected to release it by the end of next year. Apple's late co-founder Steve Jobs told biographer Walt Isaacson that Apple had developed a revolutionary but simple interface for the device.

In the past decade, Apple's iPod, iPhone and iPad have upended the music player, mobile phone and computer businesses. Many traditional TV makers seem to be trying to avoid the same fate.

But while just about everyone seems to agree that TVs are going to get smarter, there's no consensus at all on just what that means. Manufacturers, service providers, software makers and analysts disagree on fundamental issues, such as how consumers will interact with smart TVs and what they will do with them. They also disagree on technical standards.

For example, smart TVs come with a wide range of controllers. Depending on the set and the manufacturer, users may be able to talk to it, wave their hands at it, use a motion-sensing , use their smartphone as a virtual remote control, or use a full-size or scaled-down keyboard. As a result, the way you control the TV in your living room may be different from how you control the one in your bedroom.

Similarly, the interface and operating system can differ from one smart TV to another, even among sets from one manufacturer. So even if both of your televisions are made by LG, say, you may not be able to run the same applications on both.

The geek in me finds this kind of experimentation exciting. But as a consumer I'm worried that without some kind of standardization, there's going to be a lot of confusion and frustration.

And smart or not, that's the last thing you want from the boob tube.

Explore further: Gift Guide: Strong photo, video gear options

More information: Troy Wolverton is a technology columnist for the San Jose Mercury News.

3.8 /5 (4 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Apple's TV presence is strong at CES, though it's not there

Jan 10, 2012

At the Consumer Electronics Show, models walked around with large, lightweight flat-screen televisions showing vivid nature scenes, executives waved next-generation "magic" remote controls and audiences were treated to demonstrations ...

Samsung holds final talks on Google TV venture

Nov 22, 2011

Samsung Electronics is holding final talks with Google about launching a television using the US search giant's software platform next year, an executive of the South Korean company said Tuesday.

Televisions getting Siri-style personal assistants

Jan 10, 2012

Startup Vlingo on Tuesday said that it is giving televisions the kind of voice-controlled "virtual assistants" that have been a hit with the latest version of Apple's hot-selling iPhone.

Recommended for you

Ear-check via phone can ease path to diagnosis

Dec 18, 2014

Ear infections are common in babies and young children. That it is a frequent reason for young children's visit to doctors comes as no consolation for the parents of babies tugging at their ears and crying ...

Gift Guide: Home products come with connectivity

Dec 18, 2014

Do you really need an app to tell you to brush and floss? It seems every household appliance is getting some smarts these days, meaning some connection to a phone app and the broader Internet. But then what?

BlackBerry launches Classic in last-ditch effort

Dec 17, 2014

(AP)—BlackBerry is returning to its roots with a new phone that features a traditional keyboard at a time when rival Apple and Android phones—and most smartphone customers—have embraced touch screens.

Tag Heuer changes tune, now looking at smartwatches

Dec 16, 2014

Barely a few months after dismissing Apple's smartwatch, the new chief executive of luxury Swiss watchmaker Tag Heuer conceded Tuesday that such a hi-tech gadget might after all have a place in his firm's ...

User comments : 8

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Milou
3 / 5 (2) Jan 20, 2012
The best feature of any electronic device is the "off" button. They should get it by now: It is not that much about hardware as it is about programs. And TV programs sucks.... Now they are asking us to buy fancy TVs for the same programs. Like asking to buy silk to wipe our butts!
Argiod
1 / 5 (2) Jan 20, 2012
I just wonder how much circuitry has been devoted to covert observation of the viewer... in the name of researching the wants/needs of the viewer... and used for targeted advertising... It would be so easy to incorporate one of those tiny cameras like the ones in portable phones, to spy on people at home. All it would take is to hide it behind those dark plastic panels where the current photo sensors are that pick up the remote control signal. We'd never know they were there. And who, these days, can trace a circuit to see what it's really doing? Especially in devices that have security seals on them so you can't tamper with the circuits... Privacy? What privacy? Ve haff vays to keep an eye on you...
rwinners
not rated yet Jan 21, 2012
I'll bet that way more than half of the tv sets in the US are serviced by set top boxes, either cable or satellite. Until manufacturers get around this road block, the extra features will be worth little to most of us.
Bob_Kob
5 / 5 (3) Jan 21, 2012
It would be so easy to incorporate one of those tiny cameras like the ones in portable phones, to spy on people at home.


And it would be even easier for one person to discover this and bring the company to ruin.
Doug_Huffman
3 / 5 (2) Jan 22, 2012
The tube is a boob for the milk that it provides, and that is STILL the mothers' milk of stupidity. Watch TV and the mean free path of your empty cranial cavity increases.
Deathclock
3.7 / 5 (6) Jan 22, 2012
It would be so easy to incorporate one of those tiny cameras like the ones in portable phones, to spy on people at home. All it would take is to hide it behind those dark plastic panels where the current photo sensors are that pick up the remote control signal. We'd never know they were there. And who, these days, can trace a circuit to see what it's really doing? Especially in devices that have security seals on them so you can't tamper with the circuits... Privacy? What privacy? Ve haff vays to keep an eye on you...


Are you completely insane? If any company tried to hide a camera in their device to record you without your knowledge it would be discovered days after the product was released and the lawsuit would be filed within a week of that and then the company would be out of business shortly after.

You conspiracy theory nutjobs are waaay out of touch with reality.
Deathclock
3.7 / 5 (6) Jan 22, 2012
The tube is a boob for the milk that it provides, and that is STILL the mothers' milk of stupidity. Watch TV and the mean free path of your empty cranial cavity increases.


There are TONS of great educational shows and documentaries, not to mention news/weather/etc. If you watch trash that is your problem, but that is no reason to rant against a technology. The internet is the same, there are websites that are completely revolutionary in their ability to bring knowledge to the masses and then there are sites that are complete garbage that will actually damage your intellect, it is up to you to determine what content is good for you consume.
manfredrc
not rated yet Feb 14, 2012
View on TV: Same thing as anything else. Too much of it is bad for you.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.