Review: Thunderbird innovates, but Web mail wins

Jan 18, 2012 By ANICK JESDANUN , AP Technology Writer
This screen shot provided by Mozilla, shows a new version of Mozilla’s Thunderbird Web email. (AP Photo/Mozilla)

The last time I relied on email software for personal messaging, George W. Bush was starting his second term, Pluto was still a planet and the Motorola Razr was America's most popular mobile phone.

I embraced Web email a year after Google's came along in 2004. Until then, Web email had been inferior to stand-alone desktop programs. Gmail's revolutionary approach to email prompted to innovate. As a result, Web email now surpasses desktop software in many ways, particularly as people want their digital lives to travel with them as they connect from multiple devices and locations.

So I was skeptical when a new version of Mozilla's Thunderbird came along. I had all but abandoned it years ago. I was surprised to see how much had changed and improved when I gave Thunderbird a fresh look.

Although it took me a while to get used to, I'm a big fan of Gmail's way of grouping related messages into conversations. Before, you could group related messages into threads, an approach Thunderbird still uses. But messages you receive end up in one folder, and your replies are in another. With Gmail's conversations, it's all together in one stream, arranged chronologically regardless of who wrote what.

I've found that I can stay on top of communications more easily with Gmail's approach, because I can see at a glance which messages I still need to read and reply to. The old way seems cluttered and awkward.

I can also dispose of entire conversations I'm bored with more quickly - with a single click of the trash icon. Deleting messages one by one seems so last century.

Thunderbird doesn't support conversations, but it offers many other features that make it better than Web . Made by the same organization behind the popular , Thunderbird makes checking email almost as simple as surfing the Web.

One of my favorite features is the use of tabs. When you click to read a message, it opens in a new tab, just as new Web pages do in a . I can have several messages open at once and easily switch from one to another. I can copy juicy gossip from one message and paste it in another, for instance. Sure, you can open Gmail in a new browser tab, but that gets you the inbox, not the message you just opened.

And when you close Thunderbird, it remembers the messages you have open, so that you can continue where you left off the next time. Again, your starting point with Gmail is the inbox, whether you like it or not.

Thunderbird also has more options than Gmail for searching old messages. With Gmail, I'm largely limited to searching by keywords and a few attributes, such as whether the message has an attachment and what appears in the subject line. Even those options are hard to find - I didn't discover them until I went looking for them for this review.

With Thunderbird, I can narrow my search more easily. I can specify that all messages coming from Bob Smith be excluded rather than included, for instance. I can also have results sorted by relevance; with Gmail, search results come back with the most recent messages on top.

Thunderbird also does away with one of the most annoying aspects of desktop software - configuring the email account by entering the names of your service provider's servers for sending and receiving email. Thunderbird has information for the major providers built-in. All you have to do is enter your email address, and the software figures out the rest.

But Thunderbird falls short in a few ways.

One of Gmail's major innovations was to ditch folders in favor of labels. An e-mail from Dad about an upcoming football game might be properly filed away under "family," "sports" or "events." With folders, you had to choose one or create multiple copies of the message. With labels, you can choose them all. Thunderbird has a system for tagging messages with multiple attributes, but it is clunky and won't always move with you when you access the account from another computer.

I also wish Thunderbird would use tabs for composing messages and not just reading them. To write messages, you have to open a new window, which clutters your computer desktop.

That's one way innovation spurred by Gmail kicks in.

Yahoo's Web mail service offers tabs just like Thunderbird, and it works with messages you compose, too. That feature came in 2005, a year after Gmail's debut.

While I'm at it, Microsoft's Hotmail has a few neat features I recently discovered. There's a folder that's automatically created containing any message with a photo attachment or a link to an online photo album. There's a similar one for messages containing tracking numbers for FedEx and other shipping companies - a convenient way to automatically organize your online shopping receipts.

With so many advantages, Web mail wins for day-to-day use.

Nonetheless, I can see Thunderbird being useful when I travel and don't have continuous access to the Internet. Having allows me to read and write messages offline; replies get sent the next time I connect. A few months ago, I wrote about Gmail's offline effort and some kinks it still needed to work out. Thunderbird is more reliable for now.

Thunderbird is also good for those times when you need to find some tidbit of information buried in a message from 2007. Searching through Gmail returns too many that you'd have to sort through.

I'll keep Thunderbird on my laptop for when I need it, but I won't need to run it routinely.

Explore further: Software provides a clear overview in long documents

More information: The most recent version of Thunderbird, released Dec. 20, is available for free at:
http://getthunderbird.com

2.5 /5 (13 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Thunderbird 2 Flies Ahead, Racing Web Mail

Apr 20, 2007

The new version of Thunderbird, the free, open-source mail client from the organization behind the Firefox Web browser, is a nicely polished application that makes it easy to sort, view and generally manage your daily e-mail ...

Web-based e-mail features come to desktop software

Nov 11, 2009

(AP) -- E-mail has taken a full circle. Over the years, Web-based e-mail services have gotten much better, sporting many features once available only with the e-mail programs that reside on the computer desktop.

Review: Offline Gmail app good for casual use

Oct 07, 2011

Google's new software for using Gmail without an Internet connection comes across as a throwback to an era when we weren't connected all the time and on all sorts of devices, from phones to iPads.

Thunderbird 1.0 vs. Outlook Express

Dec 08, 2004

Thunderbird 1.0 is Mozilla’s next generation e-mail client. Thunderbird makes emailing safer, faster, and easier than ever before with the industry’s best implementations of features such as intelligent spam filters, ...

Google adds automatic translation to Gmail

May 20, 2009

Google added automatic translation technology to Gmail on Tuesday, allowing users of its email service to translate messages in another language with a single mouse click.

Gmail tool catches misdirected messages

Oct 13, 2009

Google on Tuesday added an embarrassment-avoidance tool that catches misdirected Gmail messages before they are fired off by users of the free Web-based email service.

Recommended for you

Chinese smartphone makers win as market swells

5 hours ago

Chinese smartphone makers racked up big gains as the global market for Internet-linked handsets grew to record levels in the second quarter, International Data Corp said Tuesday.

Full appeals court upholds labels on meat packages

5 hours ago

(AP)—A federal appeals court has upheld new government rules that require labels on packaged steaks, ribs and other cuts of meat to say where the animals were born, raised and slaughtered.

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

KingDWS
5 / 5 (1) Jan 18, 2012
Interesting based on a comparison of a web browser, one email program and the gmail pages you come to the conclusion web mail is superior? I pop my gmail into a couple of programs depending on what o/s I'm using (windoze/linux). All will quite happily sort into conversations and so on. You should have done a wee bit more research on this one to get it right.
TheGunslinger
5 / 5 (1) Jan 18, 2012
It's obvious that the writer hasn't really bothered to perform an indepth review of Thunderbird. Yes, Thunderbird is thread based, but it allows you to set up individual dedicated folders for w/e you need to organize your messages and allow you to find them faster.

Secondly, in the settings or options, you can select where you want a reply to be stored: I routinely store my replies in the same folder as the initial message and other replies. And by indicating that I want replies stored in the same folder as the message, I don't have to hunt around to find my 'conversations' as the writer calls them. They are all in the same folder.

Obviously, the reviewer here doesn't bother to learn anything about features built into specific software before assuming (ASS-U-MING) he/she knows everything there is to generate an INFORMED opinion.

Get somebody to write this section who is willing to put some effort into learning about the features of specific software being reviewed.

IMHO,

TGS
gwrede
5 / 5 (1) Jan 19, 2012
Interesting. I regularly use Thunderbird to access my Gmail account.

The interface is more versatile and responsive, so that's what I use at home. On my road laptop I also use Thunderbird for Gmail, and also other work related accounts on other servers. My mobile phone has a built-in mail client, which is easier to use than Gmail on its web browser. But if I need to temporarily use Gmail from a random computer, then I use Gmail on the web browser.

I know it seems overkill to have this many different ways of using Gmail, but different circumstances really do dictate which to use.
Pkunk_
not rated yet Jan 20, 2012
One of Gmail's major innovations was to ditch folders in favor of labels. An e-mail from Dad about an upcoming football game might be properly filed away under "family," "sports" or "events." With folders, you had to choose one or create multiple copies of the message. With labels, you can choose them all. Thunderbird has a system for tagging messages with multiple attributes, but it is clunky and won't always move with you when you access the account from another computer.

Thunderbird does have support for IMAP tags , so if your accessing your company email you can tag messages like you label them in gmail.
Also , gmail's IMAP server is feature limited so you can use the full power of Thunderbird only with an IMAP server like dovecot.

One thing which no webmail has given me yet is the ability to view/read/reply multiple email accounts at the same time.. I have abt 10 emails to monitor and logging in and out in webmail to view each one is a huge pain.