Scientists urge balance in the war on antimicrobial resistance

Jan 05, 2012

Scientists are urging policymakers to reconsider priorities in efforts to understand and control antimicrobial resistance. The new research, published today, was led by Royal Veterinary College Principal Professor Stuart Reid in his previous position at the University of Glasgow.

Antimicrobial resistance is when micro-organisms, including bacteria, viruses and parasites, are no longer killed by the drugs that have previously been effective. In the case of bacteria, there is increasing concern over the spread of resistance and the possibility of returning to the situation 100 years ago when many diseases affecting humans and were untreatable.

in humans is frequently attributed to veterinary use of antimicrobials, but the relative contribution to the problem from animals and humans is poorly understood at the . Despite this, proposals are under consideration by the to phase out the precautionary (or prophylactic) use of some antibiotics in animals in the hope that the rate of increase in the occurrence of antimicrobial resistance would be slowed. The plan has been opposed by the British Veterinary Association, which said that the ban would compromise animal health and welfare.

Dr Alison Mather, working with an interdisciplinary research team within the College of Medical, Veterinary and Life Sciences, exploited long-term of Salmonella Typhimurium DT104 from co-located humans and animals in Scotland, demonstrated how animal and DT104 populations differ significantly in several ways such as prevalence, linkage, time of emergence, and diversity. The findings, published in the , suggest that the local are unlikely to be the major source of resistance in humans, and questions policies that restrict the use of antimicrobials in local .

Professor Daniel Haydon, Director of the University of Glasgow's Institute of Biodiversity Animal Health and Comparative Medicine, said: "In our study, there were significantly more human-only types of resistance than we might have expected if the animal and human microbial communities were well-mixed, suggesting that the risk of resistances passing from animals to humans is lower than previous research has indicated.

"We also found that, in the majority of resistances which are common to both animals and humans, the resistances appeared first in humans. While it's inevitable that contact, direct or indirect, between animals and humans will lead to some transmission of disease and resistance in both directions, it appears unlikely that the animal population is the major source of resistance diversity for humans."

Professor Stuart Reid, the senior author of the work and now Principal at the Royal Veterinary College, London, added: "It remains true that the use of promotes resistance in microorganisms and of course we advocate prudent use in all species but our work does call into question the, at times, singular focus on veterinary usage.

"Whilst our study has focused on a single bacterial species, our findings do demonstrate that we must ensure that our local policies do not impact disproportionately on domestic livestock without considering imported foodstuffs and animals abroad, as well as the medical use of antibiotics. There is still much to be done if we are to understand the problem at the level of the global ecosystem."

The research was carried out by the University of Glasgow, in partnership with the Scottish Salmonella Shigella and Clostridium difficile Reference Laboratory at Stobhill Hospital; Health Protection Scotland; the Public Health Agency of Canada and the University of Guelph in Canada.

Explore further: Top Japan lab dismisses ground-breaking stem cell study

More information: The report, entitled "An ecological approach to assessing the epidemiology of antimicrobial resistance in animal and human populations", is available from tinyurl.com/dxr7prd

Provided by Royal Veterinary College

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Growing concern over drugs fed to animals

Sep 19, 2011

Drugs fed to animals to promote growth and prevent diseases may play a key role in the emergence of antibiotic resistant bacteria, microbiologists said Sunday.

Antibiotics in swine feed encourage gene exchange

Nov 28, 2011

A study to be published in the online journal mBio on November 29 shows that adding antibiotics to swine feed causes microorganisms in the guts of these animals to start sharing genes that could spread antibiotic resistance.

Newly discovered reservoir of antibiotic resistance genes

Oct 21, 2011

Waters polluted by the ordure of pigs, poultry, or cattle represent a reservoir of antibiotic resistance genes, both known and potentially novel. These resistance genes can be spread among different bacterial species by bacteriophage, ...

European league-tables for antibiotic resistance revealed

Jul 08, 2008

Tests of antibiotic resistance in cattle have revealed stark variation across thirteen European countries. The results, published today in BioMed Central’s open-access journal Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica, show that major ...

Recommended for you

Top Japan lab dismisses ground-breaking stem cell study

18 hours ago

Japan's top research institute on Friday hammered the final nail in the coffin of what was once billed as a ground-breaking stem cell study, dismissing it as flawed and saying the work could have been fabricated.

Research sheds light on what causes cells to divide

Dec 24, 2014

When a rapidly-growing cell divides into two smaller cells, what triggers the split? Is it the size the growing cell eventually reaches? Or is the real trigger the time period over which the cell keeps growing ...

Locking mechanism found for 'scissors' that cut DNA

Dec 24, 2014

Researchers at Johns Hopkins have discovered what keeps an enzyme from becoming overzealous in its clipping of DNA. Since controlled clipping is required for the production of specialized immune system proteins, ...

Scrapie could breach the species barrier

Dec 24, 2014

INRA scientists have shown for the first time that the pathogens responsible for scrapie in small ruminants (prions) have the potential to convert the human prion protein from a healthy state to a pathological ...

Extracting bioactive compounds from marine microalgae

Dec 24, 2014

Microalgae can produce high value health compounds like omega-3s , traditionally sourced from fish. With declining fish stocks, an alternative source is imperative. Published in the Pertanika Journal of Tr ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.