# How far is far enough?

##### Jan 17, 2012

people welcome developments in principle, so long as they are "not in my backyard." But just how big is a backyard? The answer depends on a number of factors and Guenther Schauberger of the University of Veterinary Medicine, has now developed a mathematical model to calculate appropriate distances from residential areas for livestock building to be sited. The model is published in the journal Atmospheric Environment.

Heavy industry and livestock farming have two features in common: both are widely regarded as essential but both produce smells that inconvenience or discomfort people living nearby. When considering where new industrial plants or are to be built – or whether a particular plot of land would be suitable for housing – it is important to ensure that people do not live too close to the source of smell.

In practice, regulatory authorities enforce a minimum separation between residential areas and sources of unpleasant smells. This distance must take a variety of factors into account, including the amount of "smelly gas" that is emitted, the effect of the smell in question and the wind and weather conditions. Together with colleagues from Germany, Günther Schauberger of the Department of Biomedical Sciences at the University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna has combined these parameters into a single that essentially defines a "no go" area around livestock farms. The model is deliberately conservative, i.e. separation distances are overestimated rather than underestimated to ensure that people are not unnecessarily disturbed by smells from the farms.

The model is applicable to all sources of odours so could greatly simplify the currently bewildering array of guidelines and regulations. In Germany, for example, there are presently separate guidelines for pig farms, poultry farms and cattle farms (this latter still in its 1994 draft version!) These could now all be combined into a single regulation. In addition, the model is also applicable to other types of odours, e.g. those resulting from industrial plants, presently covered by even more guidelines.

And the model has another significant advantage. As Schauberger notes, 'The nice thing about it is that a quick calculation can be carried out on the back of an envelope.' Such "quick and dirty" calculations generally lead to an overestimation of the required separation but nevertheless provide a useful first indication. If the results cause problems for farmers, e.g. in cases when the available space for a new livestock building is limited, it is possible to calculate the distance much more precisely, considering wind speed and direction and the stability of the atmospheric conditions.

The results may never fully eliminate nimbyism. But they have a genuine potential to ensure that planning decisions – and any objections to them – are based on scientific criteria and can be debated in a constructive manner.

Explore further: China asks pilots to master low-visibility landing

Provided by University of Veterinary Medicine -- Vienna

## Related Stories

#### Environmental health risks of livestock farming

Sep 27, 2011

Emissions from livestock farms cause asthma and COPD patients living nearby to experience more exacerbations, according to research presented today at the European Respiratory Society's Annual Congress in Amsterdam.

#### Growing up on livestock farm linked to increased risk of blood cancers

Jul 28, 2011

Growing up on a livestock farm seems to be linked to an increased risk of developing blood cancers as an adult, indicates research published online in Occupational and Environmental Medicine.

#### Healthy piglets? Not with sulfonamides

Dec 05, 2011

Recent work from the University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna confirms that sulfonamides can be used to control coccidiosis in piglets, although not without considerable effort and expense. In contrast, the drug toltrazuril ...

#### MRSA thrives even without antibiotics

Nov 07, 2011

The MRSA bacterium, which is resistant to antibiotics, has spread rapidly in the past few years on pig farms. Extensive use of antibiotics is thought to help it spread, but reducing the use of antibiotics is not enough to ...

#### Researchers study harmful particulates

Feb 26, 2007

Reducing barnyard emissions is one way to help reduce the harmful effects of tiny atmospheric air particles that can cause severe asthma in children, and lung cancer and heart attacks in some adults.

#### Large avian flu outbreaks more likely to involve duck meat industry, experts find

Oct 24, 2007

Scientists at the University of Liverpool have found that 73% of avian flu outbreaks in the UK would not spread beyond the initial infected farm, but larger outbreaks are more likely to involve the duck meat industry.

## Recommended for you

#### Mild 2013 cuts Arctic a break, warming woes remain

1 hour ago

The rapid melting in the Arctic eased up this year. But the government says global warming is still dramatically altering the top of the world, reducing the number of reindeer and shrinking snow and ice, while increasing ...

#### Study: Cover crops use water, but benefit soil health

4 hours ago

A continuing study of cover crops in the Rolling Plains has determined that yes, they do use water, but that doesn't necessarily translate into reduced cash crop performance, according to a Texas A&M AgriLife ...

#### Where water is limited, researchers determine how much water is enough

5 hours ago

Today, December 12, JoVE, the Journal of Visualized Experiments, has published an environmental research technique that could turn the age-old task of watering crops into an exact science.

#### China asks pilots to master low-visibility landing (Update)

9 hours ago

Chinese aviation authorities will soon require captains of domestic flights into Beijing to master low-visibility landings to combat chronic flight delays that have been worsened by heavy smog.

#### Scientists map food security and self-provision of major cities

12 hours ago

Wealthy capital cities vary greatly in their dependence on the global food market. The Australian capital Canberra produces the majority of its most common food in its regional hinterland, while Tokyo primarily ...

#### Study demonstrates that indigenous hunting with fire helps sustain Brazil's savannas

21 hours ago

Indigenous use of fire for hunting is an unlikely contributor to long-term carbon emissions, but it is an effective environmental management and recovery tool against agribusiness deforestation, a new study ...

## More news stories

#### Geologists report that risks of big earthquakes may be underestimated

(Phys.org) —Several geologists from around the world are presenting a case for missing or underreported earthquakes at this year's American Geophysical Union Fall meeting being held in San Francisco. They ...

#### Mild 2013 cuts Arctic a break, warming woes remain (Update)

The rapid melting in the Arctic eased up this year. But the government says global warming is still dramatically altering the top of the world, reducing the number of reindeer and shrinking snow and ice, ...

#### Mild 2013 cuts Arctic a break, warming woes remain

The rapid melting in the Arctic eased up this year. But the government says global warming is still dramatically altering the top of the world, reducing the number of reindeer and shrinking snow and ice, while increasing ...

#### What the past tells us about modern sea-level rise

Researchers from the University of Southampton and the Australian National University report that sea-level rise since the industrial revolution has been fast by natural standards and – at current rates – may reach 80cm ...

#### Global map to predict giant earthquakes

A team of international researchers, led by Monash University's Associate Professor Wouter Schellart, have developed a new global map of subduction zones, illustrating which ones are predicted to be capable of generating ...

#### Using air transportation data to predict pandemics

Computational work conducted at Northwestern University has led to a new mathematical theory for understanding the global spread of epidemics. The resulting insights could not only help identify an outbreak's origin but could ...

#### Sponges squeezed off oldest branch of animal tree

Sponges are getting squeezed out of a distinctive role in evolution. A new study says they don't represent the oldest branch of the animal family tree after all.

#### Low-power tunneling transistor for high-performance devices at low voltage

A new type of transistor that could make possible fast and low-power computing devices for energy-constrained applications such as smart sensor networks, implantable medical electronics and ultra-mobile computing ...

#### Keeping the lights on: Mechanical engineer finds a way to predict cascading power outages

A method of assessing the stability of large-scale power grids in real time could bring the world closer to its goal of producing and utilizing a smart grid. The algorithmic approach, developed by UC Santa ...

#### Yahoo Mail trouble hits fourth day

An outage at Yahoo Mail hit its fourth day on Thursday, prompting thousands of furious users to ratchet up their criticism on social media.