Hong Kong freezes $42 mln in Megaupload raids

Jan 21, 2012
A TV screen grab shows Megaupload founder Kim Dotcom, also known as Kim Schmitz, at a court in New Zealand on January 20. HK Customs officers have raided offices and luxury hotel suites as part of an FBI Internet piracy investigation into Megaupload.com.

Hong Kong Customs officers have raided offices, domestic premises and luxury hotel suites as part of a worldwide FBI Internet piracy investigation into file-sharing site Megaupload.com.

One hundred officers took part in the raids Friday which seized a large amount of digital evidence and uncovered about HK$330 million ($42 million) in suspected crime proceeds, Customs said.

"The assets have been frozen in accordance with related ordinances. The operation is ongoing," it said in a statement.

Officers raided hotel suites costing HK$100,000 a day equipped with high-speed servers and large television screens which were suspected to be connected to the case.

Megaupload's website was shut down Thursday by US authorities who accuse it of one of the largest cases of copyright theft ever.

founder Kim Dotcom, also known as Kim Schmitz, is being held in New Zealand following a police raid there.

The 37-year-old German citizen, who has New Zealand and Hong Kong residency, was denied bail with three other men on Friday when they appeared in an district court.

New Zealand police seized luxury cars worth NZ$6.0 million ($4.8 million), including a 1959 pink Cadillac and a Rolls Royce Phantom, in a raid on Dotcom's Auckland mansion.

The and FBI have indicted a total of seven people who they said were "responsible for massive worldwide online piracy of numerous types of copyrighted works, through Megaupload.com and other related sites".

The Megaupload.com homepage, pictured here on January 20. Megaupload's website was shut down Thursday by US authorities who accuse it of one of the largest cases of copyright theft ever.

The accused generated more than $175 million in criminal proceeds and caused more than $500 million in harm to copyright owners by offering pirated copies of movies, TV programmes and other content, according to a statement.

The Hong Kong Customs said it had been conducting a joint investigation with the FBI targeting the criminal activities of the syndicate since the end of 2010.

Megaupload itself is registered as a in Hong Kong, with an office in Wanchai district.

The dramatic raids came amid a fierce debate in the United States over a proposed bill before Congress aimed at cracking down on online piracy.

Critics say the new law would hand US authorities unprecedented powers that could impinge on the freedom of the Internet, and on Wednesday dozens of websites led by Wikipedia went dark in a rare protest.

In face of the criticism, US Senator Majority Leader Harry Reid Friday agreed to delay next week's vote on the bill to allow more time for talks.

"We made good progress through the discussions we've held in recent days, and I am optimistic that we can reach a compromise in the coming weeks," he said.

The European Union's top Internet official Neelie Kroes also criticised the planned US legislation, writing on Twitter that: "Internet regulation must be effective, proportionate & preserve benefits of open net."

"Speeding is illegal too: but you don't put speed bumps on the motorway," she added.

The prosecution of Megaupload meanwhile sparked a retaliatory cyber attack on the FBI and Justice Department websites.

The two government sites were up and running again early Friday after being shut down for several hours in the attack claimed by the "Anonymous" hacktivist group, which also briefly disabled music and recording industry websites.

Megaupload is popular with Hollywood celebrities and has been endorsed by music stars such as Kanye West.

Megaupload Ltd. and another company, Vestor Ltd., were indicted by a US grand jury and charged with racketeering conspiracy, copyright infringement and conspiring to commit money laundering.

Vestor's sole shareholder is Kim Dotcom. His six fellow accused come from Estonia, Germany, the Netherlands and Slovakia.

Explore further: Nokia turnaround since handset unit sale continues

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Treasure haul as N.Z. police raid Megaupload guru

Jan 20, 2012

New Zealand police on Friday seized a pink Cadillac and a sawn-off shotgun, and froze millions of dollars in cash, after a raid on the fortified mansion of an Internet guru accused of online piracy.

US shutdown of sharing site draws hacker retaliation

Jan 20, 2012

US authorities have shut down one of the largest file-sharing websites and charged seven people with copyright crimes, sparking a retaliatory cyber attack on the FBI and Justice Department websites. ...

NZ police raid file-sharing site founder's mansion

Jan 20, 2012

New Zealand police raided several homes and businesses linked to the founder of Megaupload.com, a giant file-sharing site shut down by U.S. authorities, on Friday and seized guns, millions of dollars, and ...

Recommended for you

Nokia turnaround since handset unit sale continues

1 hour ago

Nokia appears to have turned around its fortunes after the sale of its ailing cellphone unit to Microsoft, reporting a third-quarter net profit of 747 million euros ($950 million), from a loss of 91 million euros a year earlier. ...

Yahoo CEO defends strategy in face of criticism

1 hour ago

Signaling her reign has reached a pivotal juncture, Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer is trying to convince restless shareholders that the long-struggling Internet company is heading in the right direction.

Sk Hynix logs all-time high Q3 earnings

2 hours ago

SK Hynix, the world's second-largest memory chip maker, reported Thursday a record high quarterly net profit for the three months to September on strong sales and currency earnings.

User comments : 58

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Callippo
2.3 / 5 (6) Jan 21, 2012
Kim Dotcom is far from being an angel - but my question is, how is it possible, the German citizen can be prosecuted with USA FBI for company based in Hong Kong and Dotcom domain residing at in New Zealand? Only the leased servers in Virginia belong into USA jurisdiction - not his cars, bank accounts and other private property.
Callippo
2.3 / 5 (6) Jan 21, 2012
Another question is, who will indemnify the legal users of Megaupload for lost of their private data stored there. The laws cannot be enforced with violation of laws and the USA should stop to play the international gendarmes, or the people will identify with Arabians, Venezuelans and Russians, who perceive the USA in the same way. After all, the business model of MegaUpload is very similar to Google, which shares the books and videos and makes money from ads leading to its stores. The main difference is, the Google is American company, but the MegaUpload isn't.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.3 / 5 (37) Jan 21, 2012
What a Conservative Libertarian "friend" of mine told me a few years back is that in America it is proper and moral, for it to be illegal to do anything that reduces corporate profits.

Do you understand how it is possible now?

"Kim Dotcom is far from being an angel - but my question is, how is it possible, the German citizen can be prosecuted with USA FBI for company based in Hong Kong and Dotcom domain residing at in New Zealand?" - Callippo

Are the hosting companies that leased the servers being prosecuted? Is AT&T that distributed the data being prosecuted?

Sorry, those are American Companies and it is moral and proper that their profits not be reduced.

eric_in_chicago
3 / 5 (2) Jan 21, 2012
"it is proper and moral, for it to be illegal to do anything that reduces corporate profits."

Ahh, Italian style fascism in America. Did Mussolini really die, I wonder?

If THIS isn't a crime worth throwing someone in jail, what is?
http://upsidedown...-ecuador

kochevnik
1 / 5 (5) Jan 21, 2012
Never mind the WTC towers were "dustified" with a scalar weapon while the perps are still at large. Uncle Sammy got Megaupload. Now the Rothschild Film Funding company can feel safe again.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (37) Jan 22, 2012
KooooooooooK Tarrrrrrrrrrrrrd

""dustified" with a scalar weapon: - kochevnik
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (78) Jan 22, 2012
You anti-corporation, anti-profit, anti-capitalists, are not relevant to the real world.

There are laws that protect private property and copyrights, for a reason. Multiple countries are cooperating to defeat such lawlessness and anti-social behavior in this case, and others.

Stealing movies, music, software, and other copyrighted material without compensating the owners, is illegal in the real world, even in your moms basement. Your anti-capitalist, anti-American idealistic fantasy world, is profoundly immature and stupid.
ryggesogn2
2.3 / 5 (6) Jan 22, 2012
Your anti-capitalist, anti-American idealistic fantasy world, is profoundly immature and stupid.

And short sighted.
Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom points out the nations that are most prosperous defined and defend private property.
This is a key component of Canada's economic recovery.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (76) Jan 22, 2012
Did Russia make cars or electronics or for that matter any product worth a damn, that can compete on the global market? Answer, no. Nobody wants there crap. Their notions of value and profit were stupid and counter to progress.
ryggesogn2
2.1 / 5 (7) Jan 22, 2012
The only product the Russians made that was worth a damn is the AK-47. But its design was borrowed from the Germans.
The Russian rocket program, like the US's depended upon the German scientists captured in WWII.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (76) Jan 22, 2012
Ironic that VD has a problem with kockevnik's 911 truther statements, given his equally moronic & over the top "radical" anti-America, anti-corporation posts.
Czulu
not rated yet Jan 22, 2012
money talks and then prosecutes
Vendicar_Decarian
0.3 / 5 (37) Jan 22, 2012
Information can never be property since information is mutable and only exists in a form that is encrypted and encoded on arbitrary physical media.

"There are laws that protect private property and copyrights, for a reason." - NumenTard

The concept of information as property is illegitimate, and only appeals to the corrupt, and the Fascist. Those who claim to be Libertarians and Randites come immediately to mind.

"Multiple countries are cooperating to defeat such lawlessness and anti-social behavior in this case, and others." - NoumenTard

Just as multiple countries fought in support of German ideals in WWII.

You know... Just like George Bush's grandfather and Conservative American bankers supported the NAZI's.

"Stealing movies, music, software, and other copyrighted material without compensating the owners, is illegal in the real world" - NoumenTard

It is, but then piracy isn't theft and never has been.
Piracy is the duplication of information.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
""radical" anti-America, anti-corporation posts." - NoumenTard

"Extremism in the defense of Liberty is no vice." - Libertarian Credo

Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
Meanwhile here on planet Reality, the bankrupt American state can't launch a man into space, and is relying on the Russians to carry them there.

"The only product the Russians made that was worth a damn is the AK-47." - RyggTard
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
"Did Russia make cars or electronics or for that matter any product worth a damn, that can compete on the global market?" - NoumenTard

Poor NumenTard. He is a victim of his own nation's trade restrictions that have made it illegal for him to purchase Russian products in America.

Is it still illegal for "Free" Americans to travel to Cuba Tard boy?
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
When it comes from the Heritage Foundation you know it's a corporate lie. That is what the Heritage foundation is for. It is paid by corporations to spread pro-corporate dis-information.

"Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic" - RyggTard

Next....
foolspoo
1 / 5 (3) Jan 22, 2012
vendicardecarian...

It is, but then piracy isn't theft and never has been.
Piracy is the duplication of information.


for all your "INTELLECT" and extremely boldly stated opinions as facts you might consider backing these up with a source or several. and from your logic I could say ,if you ever could come up with enough words that we would want to read, you wouldn't consider a book that you had authored to be your personal property. intellectual property. what is different about a digital book of code that we are currently using to have these amazing conversations. If the creator, or author chooses to renounce their rights to this information that is their choice. but it should be their choice, not yours, whether the lazy can gain from the ideas of others.
foolspoo
1 / 5 (3) Jan 22, 2012
everyone on this earth is more naive to more ideas than they could comprehend. enough with your arrogance big dog
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
Your reading preferences are not my concern. But you are of course entirely welcome to copy any or all of what I post for your own purposes. I request that you source me as their origin, but that is a request, not a legal requirement.

"if you ever could come up with enough words that we would want to read, you wouldn't consider a book that you had authored to be your personal property. intellectual property." - FoolsPoo

They creator of information has no claim to any aspect of that information once they have made it public. But they have every right to it if they keep it to themselves.

"If the creator, or author chooses to renounce their rights to this information that is their choice" - FoolsPoo

I am open to restrictions on using publicly sourced information for profit since Capitalist exchanges of money are easily monitored and regulated, and because Capitalism must be controlled for the benefit of society.

However, corporations are not people, and I grant people cart-blanch
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 22, 2012
@VD,

Intellectual property does not equate to being merely "information", as that term is used in the general sense.

Intellectual property is a product no different than any other, and IS protected by copyright laws.

These are facts.

The only people wishing to reduce IP to no more value than a random string of bytes, are those wishing to steal it for free.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 22, 2012
"Did Russia make cars or electronics or for that matter any product worth a damn, that can compete on the global market?" - NoumenTard

Poor NumenTard. He is a victim of his own nation's trade restrictions that have made it illegal for him to purchase Russian products in America.

Is it still illegal for "Free" Americans to travel to Cuba Tard boy?


That is beside the point and you know it. Russia has not made anything worth wanting. They have zero products that are desired on the global market. That is the point.
kochevnik
2.3 / 5 (3) Jan 22, 2012
Did Russia make cars or electronics or for that matter any product worth a damn, that can compete on the global market? Answer, no. Nobody wants there crap. Their notions of value and profit were stupid and counter to progress.

Actually we did. My Lada car was also sold in England and Europe. Many nations appreciate the benefits of our value-priced arms. Many of the Soviet machines still work while the Western crap needs replacement. The locks, toilet, steel door, washing machine, coffee grinder, furniture, skyscraper, roads, trains, subway, power, music, literature, theater etc. are all Russian made. Of course we don't have an army of starving slaves ready to die making cheap crap for merchantilists to peddle in Topika, Kansas like China does.
kochevnik
1 / 5 (2) Jan 22, 2012
@Noumenon That is beside the point and you know it. Russia has not made anything worth wanting. They have zero products that are desired on the global market. That is the point.
If by "Russia" you mean "conservatives" then yes, you are correct. Russia doesn't need to do exports we have enough work for the century developing our own great country. The largest in the world. And you really need to take less of whatever you're taking...
@Noumenon Intellectual property does not equate to being merely "information", as that term is used in the general sense.
The laws of physics are against you on this point, as well.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
"Intellectual property does not equate to being merely "information", as that term is used in the general sense." - NumenTard

Actually it does, since by definition, intellectual property is information.

"Intellectual property is a product no different than any other" - NumenTard

Wow, that is funny. You think you have found a way to encode french toast onto a flash drive, and a method of making exact copies of any object instantly and without depriving the owner of the object of his rights of posession.

You need to put that tin foil cap back on NumenTard. Those moon beams are frying what is left of your inferior brain.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.3 / 5 (37) Jan 22, 2012
"The only people wishing to reduce IP to no more value than a random string of bytes" - NumenTard

Since all of what you claim is "IP" can be converted to a string of bytes, you are doing nothing but jabbering incoherent, pointless, nonsense.

Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
And that is why America is purchasing space launch services from the Russians.

"Russia has not made anything worth wanting. They have zero products that are desired on the global market." NumenTard
Vendicar_Decarian
0.3 / 5 (37) Jan 22, 2012
"The locks, toilet, steel door, washing machine, coffee grinder, furniture, skyscraper, roads, trains, subway, power, music, literature, theater etc. are all Russian made." Koche

Not all American products are crap that falls apart. Just the majority of them. They are designed to fall apart and force consumers to purchase new products.

It's the Capitalist way.

Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 22, 2012
As I said in the other thread, "Copyrights and patents exist for a reason. Ideas have value. The soviets equated value of a manufactured product in its labour and costs of production. Everyone knows the soviets are morons wrt free market,.. as the value of a product is NOT in it's labour and cost of production,.. it is in what people are willing to pay for it.".

So, it is as irrelevant if the product is merely a special arrangement of bytes, as it is irrelevant that another is merely a special arrangement of glass and metal. Both involve an idea in it's creation, and both have value ultimately determined by the market.

I'm stating how the existing laws ARE wrt copyrights, while you are stating how you wish them to be.

Unfortunately for you the west is a free capitalistic society and "value" is defined accordingly and other nations must accept this if they want to do business with the west.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 22, 2012
The Lada is a Fiat design.
kaasinees
0.1 / 5 (22) Jan 22, 2012
The Lada is a Fiat design.

You cant even use google how are we goign to take you serious.
Vendicar_Decarian
0 / 5 (35) Jan 22, 2012
"You cant even use google.." - Kass

RyggTard can use google of course. What you are seeing is the fact that Libertarians are invariably perpetual liars.

Whenever their ideology is challenged. Libertarians lie as a standard response.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 22, 2012
The Lada is a Fiat design.

You cant even use google how are we goign to take you serious.

"Fiat models were the basis of early Ladas who were intended as a people's car form their inception. "
http://www.autoev...history/
Vendicar_Decarian
not rated yet Jan 22, 2012
"As I said in the other thread" - NumenTard

You can repeat your stupidity as many times as you like, but it will remain stupidity.

"Unfortunately for you the west is a free capitalistic society and "value" is defined accordingly and other nations must accept this if they want to do business with the west." - NeumenTard

It is true that the United States has done it's best to coerce other nations to accept it's laws in their country. But now that the world sees how corrupt the failed American state has become as a result of those laws, that era is over, and the errors will be corrected.

America is no longer relevant on the world stage.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 22, 2012
"Innovation, which is the transfer of a scientific discovery (new product or process) into production, has long been a problem for the Soviet Union. Despite a strong scientific base, the country has had a mixed record of innovation. "
http://www.countr...814.html
Vendicar_Decarian
not rated yet Jan 22, 2012
From RyggTard's own link.

"Lada, as it is commonly thought, is not an auto producer but a trademark belonging to Russian manufacturer Autovoz'

RyggTard regularly posts links that contradict his own claims.

This isn't the first time.

Typical Libertarian Retard.
Vendicar_Decarian
not rated yet Jan 22, 2012
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
"In 1966, Fiat helped USSR state industries build a new car factory (AvtoVAZ) on the Volga river. A planned city called Tolyatti (named after Palmiro Togliatti, former Italian Communist Party Secretary) was developed around the factory, which started producing a "people's car" similar to the Volkswagen Beetle and Citroën 2CV of Germany and France. The new Soviet car, called the Lada, was a more spacious offering, in four-door saloon and five-door estate variants. Fiat installed British machine tools supplied by Herbert-BSA[64] of Birmingham for the manufacture of many Lada parts."
Wiki
Vendicar_Decarian
not rated yet Jan 23, 2012
"Fiat helped" - RyggTard

Originally the lying Libertarian claimed that the LADA was a Fiat Design.

His own references don't even support his own fraudulent claims.

How Libertarian of him.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
Like all communists countries, USSR, China, etc can only copy what others have created.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.1 / 5 (35) Jan 23, 2012
The Tokamak configuration that is currently the best design for a nuclear fusion reactor is a Russian Design.

The rockets that Russia is currently using to carry Americans into orbit is of Russian design.

The Periodic Table was created by a Russian.

Chromatography was invented in Russia.

Synthetic Rubber was invented in Russia.

The pocket phone was invented in Russia.

The transistor flip flop was invented in Russia.

Radiosonde was invented in Russia.

The PV solar cell was invented in Russia.

The Fast Neutron Reactor was invented in Russia.

The LED and the AC Transformer were invented in Russia.

Street lights and colored printing was invented in Russia.

Air ionizers were invented in Russia.

Blood banks were invented in Russia.

The MRI was invented in Russia.

THe list is endless.

kaasinees
0 / 5 (21) Jan 23, 2012
Like all communists countries, USSR, China, etc can only copy what others have created.

How much did the USA copy from europe and asia?
kochevnik
1 / 5 (1) Jan 23, 2012
As I said in the other thread, "Copyrights and patents exist for a reason. Ideas have value. The soviets equated value of a manufactured product in its labour and costs of production. Everyone knows the soviets are morons wrt free market,.. as the value of a product is NOT in it's labour and cost of production,.. it is in what people are willing to pay for it.".
So many are willing to pay $0. That's your free market at work, Noumenon. So why are you so angry about the will of the free market? After all, you genius intellect on the topic should be able to iron out incongruities like that. Please answer because we eastern morons are clueless about this paradox and need enlightenment.
The Lada is a Fiat design.
No, it's Henry Ford's design.
kochevnik
1 / 5 (2) Jan 23, 2012
The Tokamak configuration that is currently the best design for a nuclear fusion reactor is a Russian Design.
Tesla invented radio, AC current and half the modern conveniences used every day. Serbian genius undermined by decadent robber barons. Microsoft bought a large complex near Stalin's cottage to tap Russian programming talent which has made much of the code over the past fifteen years. I don't think Russian is any Mecca but we did benefit from free, world-class education courtesy of the Soviet system equal to any in the hard sciences.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 23, 2012
As I said in the other thread, "Copyrights and patents exist for a reason. Ideas have value. The soviets equated value of a manufactured product in its labour and costs of production. Everyone knows the soviets are morons wrt free market,.. as the value of a product is NOT in it's labour and cost of production,.. it is in what people are willing to pay for it.".
So many are willing to pay $0. That's your free market at work, Noumenon. So why are you so angry about the will of the free market? After all, you genius intellect on the topic should be able to iron out incongruities like that. Please answer because we eastern morons are clueless about this paradox and need enlightenment


Criminals are always willing to pay zero, which is why there are laws. My point wrt Russia having no products on the world market due to their past history in not understanding the nature of value and market is spot on.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 23, 2012
The criminal in the above story, "Kim Dotcon" is a mega rich guy, PROFITING off of other peoples property.

Copyrighted material is not "free information". Your idealism in desiring this to be the case shouldn't be confused with the existing laws.

America is anything but a failed state nor corrupt. Even during economic setbacks, it is still a leading nation. Again, another plain fact of reality.

Corruption is lawlessness, i.e. abusing copyright laws, and intellectual corruption is just saying anything no matter how mindless and over the top, i.e. "WTC buildings were demolished by the gov", "America and capitalism failed".
kaasinees
0 / 5 (21) Jan 23, 2012
Copyrighted material is not "free information". Your idealism in desiring this to be the case shouldn't be confused with the existing laws.


All information is free.

"Everything that can be invented has been invented."-- Charles Duell, Commissioner of US Patent Office, 1899 ;-)
kaasinees
0 / 5 (21) Jan 23, 2012
The criminal in the above story, "Kim Dotcon" is a mega rich guy, PROFITING off of other peoples property.


No he profitted from allowing users to upload their content.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
The Tokamak configuration that is currently the best design for a nuclear fusion reactor is a Russian Design.
Tesla invented radio, AC current and half the modern conveniences used every day. Serbian genius undermined by decadent robber barons. Microsoft bought a large complex near Stalin's cottage to tap Russian programming talent which has made much of the code over the past fifteen years. I don't think Russian is any Mecca but we did benefit from free, world-class education courtesy of the Soviet system equal to any in the hard sciences.

Tesla sold his ideas to Westinghouse in the USA. Too bad he didn't learn how to manage money. He used his proceeds to live the high life.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 23, 2012
"The only people wishing to reduce IP to no more value than a random string of bytes" - NumenTard

Since all of what you claim is "IP" can be converted to a string of bytes, you are doing nothing but jabbering incoherent, pointless, nonsense.


I said RANDOM string of bytes, which is obviously different than a specially arranged string of bytes, which represents the IP and work of someone.

To equate the two, is not only false according to reason but is counter to existing law for copyrighted material.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
Why did Tesla have to move to the USA to develop his ideas?
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 23, 2012
Copyrighted material is not "free information". Your idealism in desiring this to be the case shouldn't be confused with the existing laws.


All information is free.

Not according to existing law. You can't distribute copyrighted material according to law. This means all information is not free. QED.
kaasinees
0 / 5 (21) Jan 23, 2012
Copyrighted material is not "free information". Your idealism in desiring this to be the case shouldn't be confused with the existing laws.


All information is free.

Not according to existing law. You can't distribute copyrighted material according to law. This means all information is not free. QED.

How many of your thoughts are unique?
How many inventions are based on previous inventions?
We take small steps, no thought belongs to a single man and definitly not a bussiness or corporation.
But some humans are too stupid to realize this.
Noumenon
3.6 / 5 (75) Jan 23, 2012
Copyrighted material is not "free information". Your idealism in desiring this to be the case shouldn't be confused with the existing laws.


All information is free.

Not according to existing law. You can't distribute copyrighted material according to law. This means all information is not free. QED.

How many of your thoughts are unique?
How many inventions are based on previous inventions?
We take small steps, no thought belongs to a single man and definitly not a bussiness or corporation.
But some humans are too stupid to realize this.


No one is copyrighting thoughts. They're copyrighting music, movies, books, and patenting ideas, all of which represent work and all of which may have value in the market, and all of which is private property. Even a third grader understands that the government must protect private property. What country are you from, that this concept escapes you?
kaasinees
0 / 5 (21) Jan 23, 2012
No one is copyrighting thoughts. They're copyrighting music, movies, books, and patenting ideas

*tactical facepalm*
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
Copyrighted material is not "free information". Your idealism in desiring this to be the case shouldn't be confused with the existing laws.


All information is free.

Not according to existing law. You can't distribute copyrighted material according to law. This means all information is not free. QED.

How many of your thoughts are unique?
How many inventions are based on previous inventions?
We take small steps, no thought belongs to a single man and definitly not a bussiness or corporation.
But some humans are too stupid to realize this.

Michael Mann at one time refused to release his hockey stick analysis code for proprietary reasons. He expected some sort of property rights for his work. All scientific work should then be open source, no journals and no attribution.
How would that impact scientific egos?
kaasinees
0 / 5 (21) Jan 23, 2012
Michael Mann at one time refused to release his hockey stick analysis code for proprietary reasons.

Of course he did, he was afraid some rich douchebag would claim it. Then let him prove it it is his idea, secondly let him find enough money to protect his idea. How many people are in the same situation that they have no money to patent/protect their ideas and are afraid some other rich douchebag will steal it? IP/Patents bull goes against nature of information and inhibits development/evolution of the human species, all because of greed.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
Michael Mann at one time refused to release his hockey stick analysis code for proprietary reasons.

Of course he did, he was afraid some rich douchebag would claim it. Then let him prove it it is his idea, secondly let him find enough money to protect his idea. How many people are in the same situation that they have no money to patent/protect their ideas and are afraid some other rich douchebag will steal it? IP/Patents bull goes against nature of information and inhibits development/evolution of the human species, all because of greed.

You are starting to get the hint that if ideas are not protected, those ideas won't be expressed and no one benefits. But that is the socialist way, equality of misery.

How could anyone make money on Mann's hockey stick algorithms? I suspect he was afraid of being caught falsifying data.