Google, Facebook fight Indian criminal case

January 16, 2012
Indian Muslims protest against Facebook in 2010 over caricatures of the Prophet Mohammed that appeared on the social networking site. Facebook and Google on Monday fought in the Delhi High Court to quash criminal charges that they are responsible for obscene online content and fomenting religious hatred

Google and Facebook on Monday fought in the Delhi High Court to quash criminal charges that they are responsible for obscene online content.

The companies, which are set to be joined in their action by Microsoft and Yahoo!, have filed petitions asking for a lower court case brought by a local journalist against 21 to be stayed.

On Friday, the Indian government gave its sanction for the firms to be tried for such as fomenting religious hatred and spreading social discord, offences that could land company directors in prison.

Lawyers acting for the search engine and social networking site told Delhi High Court Justice Suresh Kait that they were not responsible for material posted by users on their platforms.

"Search engines such as Google cannot control websites being searched by users," Google-India's lawyer Neraj Kishan Kaul told the packed court.

"(The) summons reflects a complete lack of understanding in how it works," Kaul told the judge, referring to a summons issued to the Internet companies by a lower criminal court on December 23.

Kaul also insisted that Internet companies could not be held responsible for filtering content.

"There are serious constitutional issues of ," the lawyer said.

Facebook India's lawyer Sidharth Luthra said evidence presented against the defendants by the complainant, 39-year-old journalist Vijay Rai, needed to be "tested" before it could be admitted at trial.

Rai has submitted a compact disc of evidence he says was taken from the Internet that risks causing religious strife.

"Unlike search engines, Facebook is a closed group and even as we trying to create a global community we try and respect local laws," Luthra told the judge, adding that has safeguards against abuse and obscenity.

and Facebook's lawyers told the court that they act to remove content deemed to contravene laws in the countries in which they operate.

The government's sanction to prosecute at the weekend represents an escalation of a recent tussle between social networks and government officials, in particular Communications Minister Kapil Sibal.

Sibal last month pledged a crackdown on "unacceptable" online content and urged the social networks to exert more control over the photos, videos and users' comments uploaded on their platforms.

The trial will resume on Thursday.

Explore further: Germany warns Facebook over face-recognition app

Related Stories

Germany warns Facebook over face-recognition app

October 21, 2011

Facebook has until November 7 to bring its facial recognition software into conformity with privacy laws in Germany and the European Union or face legal action, a government lawyer told AFP Friday.

India to ban 'offensive' Internet material

December 6, 2011

India on Tuesday vowed to ban offensive material from the Internet after Facebook, Google and other major firms told the government they were unable to screen content before it was posted.

India bid to censor Internet draws flak

December 9, 2011

Indian government efforts to block offensive material from the Internet have prompted a storm of online ridicule along with warnings of the risk to India's image as a bastion of free speech.

Local Indian court summons Google, Yahoo!: report

December 23, 2011

An Indian magistrates court has issued a summons to 21 internet sites, including Facebook, Google and Yahoo! to answer charges of circulating "obscene, lascivious content," a report said Friday.

India gov't agrees to prosecute Google, Facebook

January 13, 2012

India's government authorised on Friday the prosecution of 21 Internet firms including Facebook and Google in a case over obscene content posted online, two sources told AFP.

Recommended for you

US ends bulk collection of phone data

November 30, 2015

The US government has halted its controversial program to collect vast troves of information from Americans' phone calls, a move prompted by the revelations of former intelligence analyst Edward Snowden.

How can people safely take control from a self-driving car?

November 30, 2015

New cars that can steer and brake themselves risk lulling people in the driver's seat into a false sense of security—and even to sleep. One way to keep people alert may be providing distractions that are now illegal.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Jan 16, 2012
Who the fuck does India think they are trying to censor the internet? They can get fucked. Backwards neanderthal bullshit religious moral hygiene laws, it makes me sick.
not rated yet Jan 17, 2012
All they will succeed in doing is closing themselves off from the Internet, if you try to put company directors in jail you can bet the company will leave.
not rated yet Jan 17, 2012
The problem in India is its well and dandy to use your freedom of speech to bash any religion except Islam.

Once you start bashing Islam or even attempt to satire the "Prophet" , you are going to get blasted left and centre for being "unsecular".

The government has very strict rules since they know if you whip up the muslims they'll start blowing up stuff like in Nigeria.. So you know all this censorship it's for the "public good" or you'll have muslims running riot all over the country.

And the sad thing is .. they're right.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.