Study finds 'cool' gas may form and strengthen sunspots

Jan 31, 2012
The ray-trace diagram depicts the optical layout of the Facility Infrared Spectropolarimeter (FIRS) built by the University of Hawaii at Manoa and installed at the National Solar Observatory’s Dunn Solar Telescope at Sunspot, NM. The inset at top left is a frame from a “data cube” movie built by imaging through four slits at once. Credit: H. Lin, University of Hawaii at Manoa

Hydrogen molecules may act as a kind of energy sink that strengthens the magnetic grip that causes sunspots, according to scientists from Hawaii and New Mexico using a new infrared instrument on an old telescope.

"We think that molecular hydrogen plays an important role in the formation and evolution of sunspots," said Dr. Sarah Jaeggli, a recent University of Hawaii at Manoa graduate whose doctoral research formed a key element of the new findings. She conducted the research with Drs. Haosheng Lin, also from the University of Hawaii at Manoa, and Han Uitenbroek of the National Solar Observatory (NSO) in Sunspot, New Mexico. Jaeggli now is a postdoctoral researcher in the solar group at Montana State University. The team's results will be published in the February 1 issue of the .

They used the new Facility Infrared Spectropolarimeter (FIRS) at the Dunn at Sunspot, New Mexico, and the older Horizontal Spectrograph. Although built in 1969, the Dunn is now equipped with advanced that correct for much of atmospheric blurring.

The team analyzed seven active regions on the Sun, one in 2001 and six during December 2010 to December 2011 as 23 faded away. The full sunspot sample has 56 observations of 23 different active regions.

Sunspots appear to come and go in approximate 11-year cycles. They are brighter than an arc-welder's torch, but appear black because the surrounding is so much brighter. Galileo and his contemporaries discovered sunspots in 1610. George Ellery Hale discovered magnetism in spots in 1908, and scientists soon determined that intense magnetism suppresses the normal convective motions present throughout the solar photosphere and forms "cool" spots."

During the initial stage of sunspot emergence and cooling, the formation of H2 may trigger a temporary “runaway” magnetic field intensification. The magnetic field prevents the flow of energy from inside the sun to the outside, and the sunspot cools as the energy shines into space. They form hydrogen molecules that take half the volume of the atoms, thus dropping pressure and concentrating the magnetic field, and so on. Credit: Adapted from Jaeggli, 2011; sunspot image by F. Woeger et al., NSO/AURA/NSF

But the details remain a mystery. Among the clues solar physicists have observed is a direct relationship between the spot's inner temperature and its . But at very low temperatures, the field strength makes a sharp rise.

"This result is puzzling," noted Jaeggli and her colleagues. "It implies some undiscovered mechanism inside the spot."

One suspect is hydrogen atoms combining into hydrogen molecules (H2). The Sun is about 90 percent hydrogen atoms (plus 10 percent helium and 0.13 percent everything else). Most of the hydrogen is ionized atoms since the average surface temperature is an inferno-like 5780K (9944 deg. F). Yet it is a "cool star" since astronomers can detect heavy-element molecules in the solar spectrum. In 1997 they even found water, as traces of super-heated steam, inside spots.

This suggests that a spot's cool umbra, the "black" shadow at center, might let hydrogen molecules combine in surface layers. As early as 1986, the late Professor Per E. Maltby and colleagues at the University of Oslo predicted that the gas in the umbra could be as much as 5 percent hydrogen molecules.

The NOAA 11131 sunspot region (Dec. 6, 2010) was the most intense spot measured in this study, but far from the largest the Sun can produce. The first graph (A) shows how OH starts to appear in the penumbra and continues to rise as the magnetic field strength rises. Because OH forms at a lower temperature than H2, its presence implies the quantity of hydrogen molecules that could be present (B). The two bottom images show the strength of the magnetic field (C) and the contrast between the interior of the spot and the surrounding photosphere (D). Credit: Adapted from Jaeggli et al. 2012

Such a shift would cause a major change in sunspot dynamics. A basic law of physics is that gas particles exert the same pressure whether they are atoms or molecules. A hydrogen molecule will provide half the pressure of the two atoms it used to be. And bonds between atoms oscillate and rotate, thus storing energy without raising the temperature. This is why water absorbs a lot of heat before boiling.

"The formation of a large fraction of molecules may have important effects on the thermodynamic properties of the solar atmosphere and the physics of sunspots," said Jaeggli.

But direct measurement of hydrogen molecules in spots is beyond our grasp for now, so the team measured a stand-in, the hydroxyl radical made of one atom each of hydrogen and oxygen (OH). About 1 percent of the mass of the Sun is oxygen. OH dissociates, or breaks into atoms, at a slightly lower temperature than H2, meaning H2 can also form in regions where OH is present. By coincidence, one of its infrared spectral lines is 1565.2nm, almost the same as the 1565nm line of iron, used for measuring magnetism in a spot and one of the lines FIRS is designed to observe. These are twice the wavelength of the deepest red, 770nm, the human eye can see.

First using the older HSG in 2001, and then with the more advanced FIRS in 2009-2010, the team measured magnetic fields across sunspots, and the OH intensity inside spots. From that, they calculated the H2 concentrations.

"We found evidence that significant quantities of form in sunspots that are able to maintain magnetic fields stronger than 2,500 Gauss," said Jaeggli. By comparison, Earth's magnetic field, which turns a compass needle, is about one-half Gauss. The team estimated a hydrogen molecule quantity of a few percent.

Jaeggli added that its presence leads to a temporary "runaway" intensification of the magnetic field. Magnetic flux emerges from the interior and suppresses convection at the surface, trapping cool gas that has radiated its energy into space. then forms, reducing the volume. This is more transparent than atomic , so more energy radiates into space, cooling the gas further. Hot gases around the emerging flux compress the cooler region and intensify the magnetic field.

Eventually it levels out, partly from energy radiating in from the surrounding gas. Otherwise, the spot would grow without bounds. As the weakens, the H2 and OH molecules heat up and dissociate back to atoms, compressing the remaining cool regions and keeping the spot from collapsing.

The team says that simulations are needed to test their observations. They also note that most of the active regions observed are of modest field strength. They expect that Cycle 24, which is now ramping up, will provide stronger active regions for a test of their hypothesis.

Explore further: Spectacular supernova's mysteries revealed

More information: Jaeggli, S. A.; Lin, H.; Uitenbroek, H. 2012. On Molecular Hydrogen Formation and the Magnetohydrostatic Equilibrium of Sunspots. The Astrophysical Journal, Feb. 1, 2012. 745 133 doi:10.1088/0004-637X/745/2/133 or arXiv:1110.0575v2

Provided by University of Hawaii at Manoa

5 /5 (1 vote)

Related Stories

Sunspots could soon disappear for decades: study

Sep 15, 2010

( -- Sunspot formation is triggered by a magnetic field, which scientists say is steadily declining. They predict that by 2016 there may be no remaining sunspots, and the sun may stay spotless ...

Are Sunspots Disappearing?

Sep 03, 2009

The sun is in the pits of the deepest solar minimum in nearly a century. Weeks and sometimes whole months go by without even a single tiny sunspot. The quiet has dragged out for more than two years, prompting ...

Rotating sunspots spin up a super solar flare

Apr 21, 2011

( -- The largest solar flare recorded in nearly five years was triggered by interactions between five rotating sunspots. Researchers at the University of Central Lancashire studied observations ...

Watching the birth of a sunspot

Apr 20, 2011

( -- Researchers at the University of Central Lancashire have monitored the birth of a sunspot over a period of eight hours using observations from NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO). Dr. ...

Explaining the mystery of the missing sunspots

Apr 05, 2011

Sunspots have been observed for about four centuries, since they were first reported by Galileo. Appearing in roughly eleven-year cycles of activity, sunspots are regions of strong and complex magnetic fields ...

Recommended for you

Spectacular supernova's mysteries revealed

7 hours ago

( —New research by a team of UK and European-based astronomers is helping to solve the mystery of what caused a spectacular supernova in a galaxy 11 million light years away, seen earlier this ...

Supernova seen in two lights

8 hours ago

( —The destructive results of a mighty supernova explosion reveal themselves in a delicate blend of infrared and X-ray light, as seen in this image from NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope and Chandra ...

Toothpaste fluorine formed in stars

Aug 21, 2014

The fluorine that is found in products such as toothpaste was likely formed billions of years ago in now dead stars of the same type as our sun. This has been shown by astronomers at Lund University in Sweden, ...

Swirling electrons in the whirlpool galaxy

Aug 20, 2014

The whirlpool galaxy Messier 51 (M51) is seen from a distance of approximately 30 million light years. This galaxy appears almost face-on and displays a beautiful system of spiral arms.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1.4 / 5 (5) Jan 31, 2012
Re: "But the details remain a mystery. Among the clues solar physicists have observed is a direct relationship between the spot's inner temperature and its magnetic field strength. But at very low temperatures, the field strength makes a sharp rise."

We now see evidence that even the heliopause -- and its unexpected structures -- are affected by the interstellar magnetic field. Let's hope that, among the many ideas which are discussed behind the scenes, that stellar theorists are also considering the possibility that the Sun is fundamentally an electrical phenomenon. After all, Wal Thornhill has made very poignant arguments on this point in his book, "The Electric Universe". The solar wind's failure to appreciably decelerate even as it passes the Earth's orbit points strongly to the existence of an E-field centered at the Sun. Solar physicists who take a closer look at the Crooke's tube will find all sorts of familiar features.