Study finds some children born in the year of the dragon have an advantage

Jan 23, 2012 By James Greif

As Chinese New Year approaches, Many East-Asian families hope that their children will be born in this Year of the Dragon because of the belief that the child will be smarter and more prosperous than children born during the other 11 Chinese Zodiac years. A study by two George Mason University economics professors, Noel D. Johnson and John V.C. Nye, suggests there may be some truth to the superstition, but the reasons have little to do with luck.

Published in the Journal of & Organization in January 2011, the study finds Asian immigrants to the United States born in the 1976 Year of the Dragon are more educated than comparable immigrants from non-dragon years. Asian-American “dragon babies” born in 1976 have on average 0.34 years more education than Asians born in non-dragon years. When only comparing Asian immigrant dragon babies to Asian immigrants born in other years, the advantage increases to about half a year of education. In contrast, no advantage is noticeable for children in the general U.S. population born in a Year of the Dragon.

The authors also found that this benefit may have more to do with the parents than sheer luck. Children born in the 1988 or 2000 dragon years have mothers who are more educated, wealthier and older than non-Asian mothers of dragon-year babies. The differences are especially strong for mothers with only one child, according to the study. The educational advantage of “dragon children” is likely due to the care and planning of the parents, rather than the year they were born, the authors suggest.

“Belief in the superiority of dragon-year children is self-fulfilling,” says John Nye, professor of economics. “The demographic characteristics associated with parents who are more willing and able to adjust their birthing strategies are correlated with greater investment in their children.”

“When these investments pay off, the educational success of the dragon children lends support to the , reinforcing the belief of another generation of parents to plan to have children in the Year of the Dragon,” says Noel Johnson, assistant professor of economics.  “This is an excellent illustration of how, seemingly irrational beliefs, can often be explained using the tools of economics once one looks a little closer.”

To compile the study, the authors used U.S. Census data from 2000 and Current Population Surveys of the U.S.  Bureau of the Census and the Bureau of Labor Statistics from 2000, 2002, 2004, 2006 and 2008. The researchers plan to investigate further results of the “dragon baby” advantage as new census data emerges.

In the past few "dragon years," Asian leaders have cautioned citizens on creating a baby boom for fear of the strain it would put on public resources. This year, however, Taiwan's President Ma Ying-jeou and Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong have both called for a "dragon baby boom" to help ease population shortages in their respective countries.

The authors found no population spike in dragon years before 1976 and, even after 1976, there is no evidence for a dragon year fertility spike in the People’s Republic of China, likely due to government restrictions on the number of children a family can have.

The authors note that in the United States there is unlikely to be any overall population boom in the 2012 Year of the Dragon since the majority of the population does not believe in the superstition.

Explore further: Gender quotas work in 'tight' cultures, says new paper

Provided by George Mason University

2.2 /5 (6 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

'Dragon's blood' quenches stomach ulcer bacteria

Nov 12, 2007

“Dragon’s blood” may sound like an exotic ingredient in a witch’s brew or magic potion. But researchers in China are reporting that the material — which is actually a bright red plant sap used for ...

Robotic dragon, an unlikely teacher

Oct 21, 2011

David DeSteno, an associate professor of psychology at Northeastern, and researchers from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and Harvard University, are examining how social robots can aid preschoolers ...

Komodo dragon has 'pussycat' bite but plenty of punch

Oct 21, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- The world’s largest lizard – the Komodo Dragon – has an astonishingly weak bite, but a new study has revealed that the key to its killing power is a lethal combination of poison, ...

Recommended for you

Smarter ads for smartphones: When they do and don't work

Jul 15, 2014

Brands spent $8.4 billion on mobile advertising in 2013, and that number is expected to quadruple to $36 billion by 2017, according to eMarketer. But do mobile display ads—those tiny banner ads that pop ...

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

tadchem
5 / 5 (3) Jan 23, 2012
"because of the belief that the child will be smarter and more prosperous than children born during the other 11 Chinese Zodiac years. "
Talk about your self-fulfilling prophesies!
If the parents believe that, they will treat the child differently in ways which will reinforce that belief.
gmurphy
5 / 5 (2) Jan 23, 2012
@tadchem, totally agree, the most telling sign is that there's no such variation amongst the non-Asian communities. Amazing really, what effect such delusions can have.
Temple
not rated yet Jan 23, 2012
This reminds me of the purported behaviour/personality types of the astrological signs.

I'd love to see a study on how the time of year you are born can affect your personality. There are plenty of down to earth variations which could very certainly have a similar effect on anybody born at the same time. Things like:

Being born near Christmas. Your first memory of Christmas on average being a year later for a January baby than a December baby.

Having a birthday in August, when school is out and many people are on vacation, can mean less attention on one's birthdays.

Being born just before or just after the school-year cutoff will mean that you will generally either be the oldest/largest or youngest/smallest in your grade for your formative years.

When personal milestone events occur could have similar behavioural trends on people born near the same time.

I'd love to see if there could be real explanations for some of the astrological sign personality trends that can often exhibit
kochevnik
1 / 5 (1) Jan 23, 2012
@tadchem, totally agree, the most telling sign is that there's no such variation amongst the non-Asian communities. Amazing really, what effect such delusions can have.
Hardly. As a dragon my best years by far are in the year of the dragon, and the numbers back that up. Besides, George Mason University is an incubator for libertarian shills.
Graeme
5 / 5 (1) Jan 23, 2012
Well some of the delusion that education is worthwhile pays off as the Asian immigrants are two scale graduations better than the non Asians in educational achievement.
gmurphy
not rated yet Jan 25, 2012
@Graeme, you've certainly got a point there, I personally believe that 99.9% of people only achieve a tiny fraction of their true potential, primarily because they don't believe they can do any better: 'He who feared he would not succeed sat still' (old Latin saying)