Siri's abortion info flap: Blame it on Beta, says Apple

Dec 01, 2011 by Nancy Owano weblog

Siri is the intelligent iPhone personal assistant smart enough to give you an answer just by asking—unless your question is where to find the closest abortion clinic. In a fast and furious go-round this week, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), abortion rights supporters, bloggers, and Apple itself traded notes about Siri’s inability to provide an answer to questions about where to go for birth control and abortion.

Jenna Wortham in The New York Times brought this odd blank on the part of Siri to attention on Tuesday.

“Try asking it to find a local abortion clinic, and the software turns up a puzzling blank — even in areas that clearly have such clinics,” she said. When Siri was asked to find an abortion clinic in New York City, Siri replied, Sorry, I couldn’t find any abortion clinics.”

Megan Carpentier, the executive editor of The Raw Story, found that Siri users in the Washington, D.C., area were directed to antiabortion centers in Virginia and Pennsylvania instead of at a nearby Planned Parenthood. “Ask Google the same question, and you’ll get ads for no less than seven metro-area abortion clinics, two CPCs and a nationwide abortion referral service,” she wrote.

“Apple's Latest iPhone Has No Problem Pointing Users to Viagra, But Comes Up Blank on Birth Control, Abortion,” headlined a bothered ACLU on its blog “Blog of Rights,” and asked all of its readers to send a template-provided email message to Apple to voice concern. “Send a message to Apple: Fix Siri.”

The text message read “I urge you to correct this glitch, so Siri provides the same service to women seeking information about vital reproductive health care services as to users seeking Viagra, burgers, and other services.”

What also annoyed the ACLU is that, when Siri did provide replies for abortion queries, Siri directed questioners to pregnancy crisis centers. “These centers often bill themselves as resources for abortion care, but do not provide or refer for abortion and are notorious for providing false and misleading information about abortion to women,” said the ACLU.

To be fair to Apple, Siri’s co founder, Norman Winarsky--Siri was bought by Apple last year—pointed out that the inability of Siri to answer these kinds of question may be due to the third-third-party Web services that Siri uses, rather than a deliberate policy decision by Apple to withhold abortion clinic information.

Since the Web services provide local business information, he said, it may be possible Apple was not aware of all the results that come up.

Fundamentally, Apple’s response has been Blame it on Beta.

In response to The New York Times flag about Siri being clueless, Apple said Siri’s cluelessness was not intentional. Natalie Kerris, spokesperson for Apple, said, “These are not intentional omissions meant to offend anyone. It simply means that as we bring Siri from beta to a final product, we find places where we can do better, and we will in the coming weeks.”

Meantime, Nancy Keenan, president of NARAL Pro-Choice America Foundation, sent a letter to the CEO of Apple, Tim Cook, expressing concern about Siri: “It is disappointing to read that a tool like Siri is missing the mark when it comes to providing information about such personal health issues as abortion care and contraception.”

Explore further: 3D TV may be the victim of negative preconceptions

More information: www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/11/29… tead-of-an-abortion/
www.prochoiceamerica.org/media… pr11302011_siri.html
bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11… nswers-are-a-glitch/
secure.aclu.org/site/SPageServ… 11130_apple_abortion

Related Stories

Siri gives iPhone 4S sass

Oct 13, 2011

The robotic assistant built into Apple's latest iPhone might win your heart, but she won't marry you.

Apple's tongue-tied Siri faces 'Singlish' rival

Oct 28, 2011

Singapore's SingTel has developed an application to rival the voice-activated Siri on the iPhone 4S that is sure to go down well in the island state -- because it can understand "Singlish".

iSchool prof predicts the future of search user interfaces

Nov 07, 2011

School of Information professor Marti Hearst predicts the future of online search interfaces in an article in this month’s edition of the Communications of the ACM. “The future of user interfaces will involv ...

Recommended for you

3D TV may be the victim of negative preconceptions

4 hours ago

An academic from Newcastle University, UK, has led a lab-based research, involving 433 viewers of ages from 4 to 82 years, in which participants were asked to watch Toy Story in either 2D or 3D (S3D) and report on their viewing ...

Microsoft unveils Xbox in China as it faces probe

18 hours ago

Microsoft on Wednesday unveiled its Xbox game console in China, the first to enter the market after an official ban 14 years ago, even as it faces a Chinese government probe over business practices.

A smart wristband for nocturnal cyclists

Jul 29, 2014

Five EPFL PhD students have developed a wristband that flashes when the rider reaches out to indicate a turn. Their invention was recognized at a European competition.

Lenovo's smart glasses prototype has battery at neck

Jul 28, 2014

China's PC giant Lenovo last week offered a peek at its Google Glass-competing smart glass prototype, further details of which are to be announced in October. Lenovo's glasses prototype is not an extreme ...

Sapphire talk enlivens guesswork over iPhone 6

Jul 27, 2014

Sapphire screens for the next iPhone? Sapphire is second only to diamond in hardness scratch-proof properties, used in making LEDs, missiles sensors, and on screens for luxury-tier phones. Last year, the ...

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Temple
5 / 5 (1) Dec 02, 2011
It's hard for a computing algorithm to find businesses that are related to a word if they don't use that word in any of their naming or online descriptions.

As has been reported, you won't find the text "abortion" in the name or description of any businesses that provide related information or services, rather they use euphemisms instead.
Noumenon
4.4 / 5 (53) Dec 02, 2011
The computers are rightly programmed not to turn on humans.
FrankHerbert
1.3 / 5 (55) Dec 02, 2011
LOL, I actually thought that was funny Noumenon...

Until I realized you were serious.
Noumenon
4.5 / 5 (52) Dec 03, 2011
You tend to presume alot.
ZZMike
3 / 5 (2) Dec 04, 2011
So Siri is the only way in Earth to find anything?
CHollman82
1.5 / 5 (10) Dec 04, 2011
So Siri is the only way in Earth to find anything?


Apple fanboys tend to be that way, yes... if it doesn't haven't an i* in front of it they don't want to associate with it. They can shove their iShit straight up their iAss as far as I am concerned.

(actually I like the iPhone, but my Evo is comparable, and I don't like apple as a company)