Like monkeys, pigeons can put numbers in order

Dec 22, 2011
Pigeon participating in Dr Scarf's research. Photo by William van der Vliet

(PhysOrg.com) -- Pigeons are on par with primates in their numerical abilities, according to new University of Otago research appearing in the leading international journal Science.

The Department of Psychology researchers showed that pigeons can compare pairs of images picturing up to nine objects and order them by the lower to higher number with a success rate above chance.

Study lead author Dr Damian Scarf says that up until now, only humans and primates were thought to share the ability to use abstract numerical rules in this way.

“Our research not only shows that pigeons are also members of this exclusive club, but, somewhat surprisingly, their performance is on a par with that of monkeys.”

The researchers initially trained the pigeons by presenting them with 35 sets of three images, each with one, two, or three objects of different sizes, colours and shapes.

They were rewarded with wheat when they pecked the images in the correct ascending sequence.

Next, the researchers sought to test if the pigeons could take what they had learnt from ordering the three images and apply it to images with higher numbers of objects than they had seen before. The pigeons were presented with pairs of images with between one and nine objects and tested on their ability to respond to them in ascending order.

As well as performing above chance in these tests, the pigeons also demonstrated a ‘distance effect’ comparable to that found in landmark US research in 1998 involving rhesus monkeys performing similar tasks. The greater the distance between the numbers in the pairs, the faster and more accurate the pigeons were, Dr Scarf says.

“While this is obviously a long way away from how humans can count, it shows that an animal with a brain structured quite differently to ours is still able to perform complex mental tasks of which only humans were once thought capable. Our findings add to a growing body of evidence that are among a number of avian species exhibiting impressive mental abilities that really do give the lie to the old ‘bird brain’ insult,” he says.

The next phase of Dr Scarf’s pigeon research includes investigating the neural underpinnings of their numerical abilities by recording their brain cell activity when they undertake numerical tasks.

He also plans to test kea, which have been claimed to have some of the intelligence of a six-year-old child. He is currently setting up a project that will utilise the two keas and other parrot species housed at the Dunedin Botanic Garden aviary.

Explore further: A step into the unmown creates a 'win-win' for wildlife and humans

More information: “Pigeons on par with primates in numerical competence,” by Damian Scarf, Harlene Hayne, Michael Colombo. 23 December 2011, Vol 334, Science DOI: 10.1126/science.1213357

Related Stories

Pigeons never forget a face

Jul 03, 2011

New research has shown that feral, untrained pigeons can recognise individual people and are not fooled by a change of clothes.

A bird's eye view of art

Jun 30, 2009

Pigeons could be art critics yet, according to a new study which shows that like humans, pigeons can be trained to tell the difference between 'good' and 'bad' paintings. According to Professor Shigeru Watanabe from Keio ...

Pigeons have eye for paintings: Japan study

Jun 25, 2009

Pigeons may sometimes appear to randomly target city sculptures with their droppings, but according to a new Japanese study they also have the potential to become discerning art critics.

Birds use right nostril to navigate

Feb 03, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Pigeons rely mainly on their olfactory sense when they navigate. Young pigeons learn to recognize environmental odours carried by the winds into the loft and to use these odours to find their ...

Recommended for you

Dogs can be pessimists too

14 hours ago

Dogs generally seem to be cheerful, happy-go-lucky characters, so you might expect that most would have an optimistic outlook on life.

Transparent larvae hide opaque eyes behind reflections

Sep 17, 2014

Becoming invisible is probably the ultimate form of camouflage: you don't just blend in, the background shows through you. And this strategy is not as uncommon as you might think. Kathryn Feller, from the University of Maryland ...

Peacock's train is not such a drag

Sep 17, 2014

The magnificent plumage of the peacock may not be quite the sacrifice to love that it appears to be, University of Leeds researchers have discovered.

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Tausch
1 / 5 (1) Dec 22, 2011
What abstract behaviorism projection onto other life is universal to all life?
MrVibrating
3 / 5 (2) Dec 22, 2011
Can't help wondering if their ability to judge quantities would also be affected by tilt, like us..

http://medicalxpr...eft.html

..and likewise for the monkeys..

I do love pigeons tho, can watch them all day. You get to see some interesting behaviors. It's a pity so many folks are so prejudiced against them. They're actually Portuguese Rock Doves, IIRC, and only here cos our buildings replicate their habitat.

Some years ago you'd regularly encounter them using the District Line between Ealing Broadway and Ealing Common stations - New Scientist mentioned it but the consensus from ornithologists was that these were chance occurences, or they'd wandered onto the carriage looking for food... but i saw them myself multiple times, and remain convinced they knew exactly what they were doing...
Isaacsname
5 / 5 (1) Dec 22, 2011
I bet they have fun trying to work with Kea's, those things are so smart it's almost intimidating.
Telekinetic
1 / 5 (1) Dec 22, 2011
@ Isaacsname:

I think you'd like this-
http://www.huffin...365.html
Isaacsname
not rated yet Dec 23, 2011
@ Isaacsname:

I think you'd like this-
http://www.huffin...365.html


I saw that the other day. Looked like a field trip for the youngin's :D
antialias_physorg
3 / 5 (2) Dec 23, 2011
Our research not only shows that pigeons are also members of this exclusive club,

Is this really surprising? I would suspect that any animal that has a brain uses it for the same purpose: pattern recognition and information abstraction.

A brain is a very efficientr foliter that condenses many bits of stimuli into the few relevant bits (responses to those stimuli). Anything that helps make this task easier (like abstraction) is what the brain is perfectly suited for.

One of these abstractions is most certainly to distinguish objects from one another. No use learning what "one seed2 look like, then learning what "two seeds" look like...then "three seeds"....etc, etc.

Much easier to learn what one seed looks like and then learn the concept of aggregatons of seeds.

Naturally it is favorable to choose more seeds over less. So a concept of numbering/ordering is smoething I'd expect to develop very early on.