Jury deliberates in $1B lawsuit against Microsoft

December 15, 2011 By PAUL FOY , Associated Press
In this Nov. 21, 2011 photo, Bill Gates arrives to testify at the Frank E. Moss federal courthouse in Salt Lake City. Closing arguments are set Tuesday Dec. 13,2011 in a $1 billion federal antitrust lawsuit against Microsoft Corp. Novell Inc. claims the software giant duped it into working on a new version of the WordPerfect writing program only to withdraw support months before Microsoft's Windows 95 was released. Novell claims it was later forced to sell WordPerfect for a $1 billion loss. (AP Photo/Jim Urquhart,File)

(AP) -- Jurors deliberating Wednesday in a Utah company's $1 billion federal antitrust lawsuit against Microsoft Corp. appeared confused, sending at least five questions to the judge, one of which couldn't be answered.

Novell Inc. sued Microsoft in 2004, claiming the Redmond, Wash.-based technology giant duped it into developing a version of its WordPerfect writing program for Windows 95 only to pull the plug so Microsoft could gain market share with its own word program.

Jurors started deliberating at about 8:45 a.m. Wednesday and didn't go home until about 7:45 p.m., the Salt Lake Tribune reported. They'll resume their discussions Thursday.

During the day, the judge received notes from the panel seeking clarification on some of the technical testimony throughout the two-month trial.

One message so baffled U.S. J. Frederick Motz that he told to simply disregard their own question in deliberations.

Tensions were high among lawyers waiting for what could be an enormous verdict. Novell is seeking up to $1.3 billion from Microsoft.

If the jury rules against Novell, its attorneys will have little to show for a decade of effort.

Throughout the trial, Novell lawyers argued that because its office products worked on multiple operating systems, Microsoft's snub of WordPerfect for Windows 95 was an illegal effort to maintain its monopoly.

Microsoft countered that it had valid business reasons to deny WordPerfect a set of software tools that threatened to crash new Windows technology. They say Novell could have worked around the problem but moved too slow.

Microsoft says Novell's ensuing loss of market share was its own doing because the company didn't develop a compatible WordPerfect program until long after the Windows 95 rollout. WordPerfect once had nearly 50 percent of the market for word processing, but its share quickly plummeted to less than 10 percent as Microsoft's own Office programs took hold.

"Novell was late. It was always behind. It was playing catch-up," Microsoft attorney David Tulchin said during closing arguments Tuesday.

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates testified last month that he had no idea his decision to drop a tool for outside developers would sidetrack Novell. He denied Novell's claim that Microsoft intentionally deceived the company.

Gates also said Novell just couldn't deliver a compatible WordPerfect program in time for the rollout, and that Microsoft's own Word program was actually better. He said that by 1994, the Word writing program was ranked No. 1 in the market, above WordPerfect.

Novell argued that Gates ordered Microsoft engineers to reject WordPerfect as a Windows 95 application because he feared it was too good.

Novell's lawsuit is the last major private antitrust case to follow the settlement of a federal antitrust enforcement action against Microsoft more than eight years ago. The trial began in October in federal court in Salt Lake City.

Novell is now a wholly owned subsidiary of The Attachmate Group, the result of a merger that was completed earlier this year.

Explore further: Xbox One update plays up the 'game' part of console


Related Stories

Microsoft's new businesses shine, but PC software still sags

October 22, 2015

Microsoft may still be suffering from lagging sales of personal computers, but the tech giant has taken some cues from rivals like Apple and Google—and it's now seeing substantial growth in more promising lines of business ...

Sensel's pad can morph for artists, music makers, gamers

August 26, 2015

An item on Kickstarter called the Sensel Morph looks as if it is perking people up—a glance over at the funding numbers tells you their goal is $60,000 with 44 days to go. No sweat. Pledges so far have topped $100,000 and ...

Microsoft buys cloud computing security startup

September 8, 2015

Microsoft said Tuesday it bought an Israel-based cybersecurity startup specializing in defending programs and content in the cloud, as it expands offerings for the enterprise.

Smart home heating and cooling

August 28, 2015

Smart temperature-control devices—such as thermostats that learn and adjust to pre-programmed temperatures—are poised to increase comfort and save energy in homes.

Recommended for you

Nevada researchers trying to turn roadside weed into biofuel

November 26, 2015

Three decades ago, a University of Nevada researcher who obtained one of the first U.S. Energy Department grants to study the potential to turn plants into biofuels became convinced that a roadside weed—curly top gumweed—was ...

Glider pilots aim for the stratosphere

November 20, 2015

Talk about serendipity. Einar Enevoldson was strolling past a scientist's office in 1991 when he noticed a freshly printed image tacked to the wall. He was thunderstruck; it showed faint particles in the sky that proved something ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Dec 15, 2011
Word better? I guess so if your name is Bill Gates. WordPerfect had capabilities in the early 90s that Microsoft didn't develop for almost a decade. Word achieving #1 ranking is a little like a book making the NY Times best-seller list because the author and affiliates are buying and giving away copies.
not rated yet Dec 15, 2011
I know many WordPerfect users who hated using Word because it just wasn't as good as WordPerfect. Microsoft being proven to have been scum for a very long time. Bill, you were scum. Steve, you also were scum. Why don't you both follow Steve Jobs?...
1 / 5 (2) Dec 16, 2011
Well, that is exactly what the Wall Street Journal has been doing. Padding it's subscriber list by giving away essentially free copies of it's newspaper to Conservative Propaganda groups in foreign countries.

"Word achieving #1 ranking is a little like a book making the NY Times best-seller list because the author and affiliates are buying and giving away copies." - DsChlink
1 / 5 (2) Dec 16, 2011
The only question is... Was W95 a devious plot by MS to kill off Word Perfect?

Of course it was.

Windows 3.1 was vastly superior to W95 and all subsequent Microsoft operating systems.

1 / 5 (1) Dec 16, 2011
Even Basic is not owned by micrsoft, its bought from others, altered it to Q-basic, DOS-software makers screens made microsoft copy & apply cosmetics and name it as windows, now microsoft OS on hard disk bloated to many GB in size with no new features than win98, win98 is other companies drivers, software, 3rd party inclusions etc etc

dotnet framework is based on ADA software....

asp was based on php language.....

Mirosoft thinks and advertises as if they invented the CPU and other hardware...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.