Researchers show elephants really do have a sixth toe

December 23, 2011 by Bob Yirka report
African Bush Elephant in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania. Taken by Oliver Wright, via Wikipedia.

( -- Sometimes it seems, nature finds it must resort to some trickery to respond appropriately to changing conditions. Take the elephant, for example. Way back in time, say fifty million years ago, the hulking beasts spent most of their time standing in water, much like hippos do today. But then, over the next ten million years or so, they moved out of the water and began foraging on land. The problem with this though, was that walking on land meant forcing the feet to take up a lot more of the load. Elephants are really heavy after all.

So, in response, according to John Hutchinson and his colleagues, as they write in their study published in Science, the big began walking on tiptoe, which for the largest of the group meant developing some means of extra support in the back of the foot. So, nature stepped up by causing one of the bones in the foot that normally are used in a supporting role, to evolve to form a sort of toe that works in effect, like a heel on a lady's shoe.

Hutchinson and his team explain that the reason this little bit of knowledge has been overlooked for so long is twofold. The first is because the bone starts out as and only grows into regular hardened bone after many years as an adult. The second reason is because the toe is encased in so much hard foot fat that it’s almost impossible to see how things actually work on a living animal. They point out that such was the thinking that the sixth toe was deemed to offer so little of value that museum workers routinely snipped it off and tossed it away when preparing elephant skeletons for exhibit.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Foot anatomy of an extant elephant (Elephas maximus). Video: John R. Hutchinson

Hutchinson has become an expert on elephant feet and as such is now a sort of go-to guy for zoos with with feet problems (which is apparently quite common); so much so that when captive elephants die in zoos the zookeepers quite often lop off the feet and send them to him for study. Because of this he now has what is likely the largest collection of frozen elephant feet in the world with some seventy specimens sitting in various freezers.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Evolution of manus anatomy in Proboscidea. Video: John R. Hutchinson

To find out what is really going on with elephant feet, Hutchinson and his team performed autopsies and did CT scans on them, some with weights added to mimic how they should behave under the natural weight of their original owner. In so doing, they discovered that as an animal ages over a several year period, the bone-like cartilage becomes harder and harder, until eventually becoming true bone. It’s at that point that the toe becomes useful as a means of assisting in helping the giant beast stand and walk.

What’s most interesting the team says, is that the sixth toe evolved from a sesamoid, a type of bone normally used to support other bones, rather than as a true sixth toe, in much the same way panda’s have evolved a thumb-like appendage to help them eat bamboo.

Explore further: Uncertain future for elephants of Thailand

More information: From Flat Foot to Fat Foot: Structure, Ontogeny, Function, and Evolution of Elephant “Sixth Toes” Science 23 December 2011:
Vol. 334 no. 6063 pp. 1699-1703. DOI: 10.1126/science.1211437

Several groups of tetrapods have expanded sesamoid (small, tendon-anchoring) bones into digit-like structures (“predigits”), such as pandas’ “thumbs.” Elephants similarly have expanded structures in the fat pads of their fore- and hindfeet, but for three centuries these have been overlooked as mere cartilaginous curiosities. We show that these are indeed massive sesamoids that employ a patchy mode of ossification of a massive cartilaginous precursor and that the predigits act functionally like digits. Further, we reveal clear osteological correlates of predigit joint articulation with the carpals/tarsals that are visible in fossils. Our survey shows that basal proboscideans were relatively “flat-footed” (plantigrade), whereas early elephantiforms evolved the more derived “tip-toed” (subunguligrade) morphology, including the predigits and fat pad, of extant elephants. Thus, elephants co-opted sesamoid bones into a role as false digits and used them for support as they changed their foot posture.

Related Stories

Elephant legs are much bendier than Shakespeare thought

August 22, 2008

Throughout history, elephants have been thought of as 'different'. Shakespeare, and even Aristotle, described them as walking on inflexible column-like legs. And this myth persists even today. Which made John Hutchinson from ...

Are high speed elephants running or walking?

February 12, 2010

Most animals don't think anything of breaking into a run: they switch effortlessly from walking to a high-speed bouncing run. But what about elephants? Their sheer size makes it impossible for them to bounce up in the air ...

Study shows elephants capable of insight

August 24, 2011

( -- Kandula, a seven year old Asian elephant living in Washington D.C.’s National Zoo, has proven that elephants are as smart as those that spend a lot of time around them have believed. In an experiment ...

Recommended for you

New gene map reveals cancer's Achilles heel

November 25, 2015

Scientists have mapped out the genes that keep our cells alive, creating a long-awaited foothold for understanding how our genome works and which genes are crucial in disease like cancer.

Insect DNA extracted, sequenced from black widow spider web

November 25, 2015

Scientists extracted DNA from spider webs to identify the web's spider architect and the prey that crossed it, according to this proof-of-concept study published November 25, 2015 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Charles ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (2) Dec 23, 2011
What? Why did they start walking on tiptoe? I don't get it.
1 / 5 (2) Dec 23, 2011
So they could perform in the Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus. Search for 'Ballet of Elephants' by Leda Schubert.
5 / 5 (1) Dec 23, 2011
What? Why did they start walking on tiptoe? I don't get it.

Most quadrupeds walk on their toes. It's only strange to us because we walk on our entire foot.

Just as runners run on their toes, so do animals, because the tension of the gastrocnemius (and soleus in some animals) makes running more efficient.
5 / 5 (1) Dec 26, 2011
aroc91 is at least partly right; in this research we chose not to give one definitive answer for the "Why?" question because such queries in evolutionary biology are difficult to answer.

But we can certainly address the consequences of such changes in terms of costs and benefits. One benefit is that making the limbs more vertical (including the toes) helps the limbs act more like a column, supporting weight with minimal muscular effort. Bigger animals tend to do this, at a cost of acceleration/maneuverability.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.