EU court rules against web filters to block file sharing

Nov 24, 2011
Internet service providers cannot be forced to install filters aimed at preventing people from illegally downloading music and other files, the EU's top court ruled.

Internet service providers cannot be forced to install filters aimed at preventing people from illegally downloading music and other files, the EU's top court ruled Thursday.

The decision by the European Union Court of Justice is a defeat for backers of web filters, including artists and the enterainment industry, who are fighting to protect their work from circulating freely on the Internet.

The judges ruled that a national court cannot impose an injunction ordering an Internet provider to install a filtering system for all electronic communications, saying it is too expensive for the company and could infringe on people's fundamental rights.

The case arose from a dispute in Belgium pitting web provider Scarlet Extended SA against SABAM, a Belgian management company responsible for authorising the use of music of authors, composers and editors.

SABAM complained in 2004 that Scarlet's customers were using peer-to-peer networks, which allow people to share files online, to download works from its catalogue without authorisation and without paying royalties.

A Belgian court then ordered Scarlet to make it impossible for its customers to send or receive any electronic files containing SABAM music.

But the EU court ruled that such filters require the monitoring of all electronic comunications, which is incompatible with the Union's E-Commerce rules.

An injuction would "result in a serious infringement of Scarlet's freedom to conduct its business as it would require Scarlet to install a complicated, costly, permanent computer system at its own expense," the court said.

"The filtering system would also be liable to infringe the fundamental rights of its customers, namely their right to protection of their personal data and their right to receive or impart information," it added.

The International Federation of the Phonographic Industry, which represents the record industry worldwide, said that despite the rejection, the ruling only affected one system to protect copyrighted material online in Europe.

"In this particular case, the court rejected the content filtering measure presented by the Belgian court as too broad," said IFPI chief executive Frances Moore.

"However, this does not affect the forms of ISP cooperation that IFPI advocates including graduated response and the blocking of rogue websites, which are already being implemented in countries across Europe," he said.

The European Internet Services Providers Association, which represents 1,800 ISPs across Europe, welcomed the ruling, saying it would have "serious implications" for content blocking systems imposed in other EU states.

"Considering the major contribution that the Internet industry can make to the economic recovery, it was indeed not the time to put the innovation of the Internet at risk," said association president Malcolm Hutty.

Explore further: Facebook 'newspaper' spells trouble for media

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

German court orders wireless passwords for all

May 12, 2010

(AP) -- Germany's top criminal court ruled Wednesday that Internet users need to secure their private wireless connections by password to prevent unauthorized people from using their Web access to illegally download data.

Court rules against Microsoft in China font case

Nov 17, 2009

A Chinese court has ruled Microsoft Corp. infringed a Chinese company's intellectual property rights by including certain fonts in its operating systems, the companies confirmed Tuesday.

Recommended for you

Spotify prompts industry debates on streaming

7 hours ago

From board rooms in Japan to songwriter's rooms in Nashville, a debate is brewing in music industry circles about the financial and creative value of streaming music, even as its popularity and impact skyrocket.

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dogbert
5 / 5 (4) Nov 24, 2011
Excellent!

Service providers should not be forced into being police or made into tools to control activities of their clients.
shwhjw
5 / 5 (3) Nov 24, 2011
Excellent!

Service providers should not be forced into being police or made into tools to control activities of their clients.


Hear hear!
hb_
5 / 5 (1) Nov 24, 2011
Couldn't agree more!
antialias_physorg
5 / 5 (1) Nov 24, 2011
It's on occasions like these that I'm really glad that the EU got together.
Vendicar_Decarian
1 / 5 (1) Nov 24, 2011
This is good news for Europe.

And yet American Libertarians and Conservatives are demanding that U.S. carriers be allowed or even forced to filter content.

Clearly they are more interested in corporate profits than Liberty.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.