Voice-detection feature on new iPhone could shake up industry

Oct 05, 2011 By Troy Wolverton

The new Apple iPhone 4S that was unveiled Tuesday includes a faster chip and more powerful camera than its predecessor, but overall is underwhelming except for one potentially revolutionary new feature: Siri voice-recognition technology.

Siri acts like a virtual secretary. It can take dictation, check your calendar and schedule appointments, read text messages aloud, check stock quotes and even find a great nearby restaurant.

Because the feature is a fundamental component of the iPhone 4S, you don't have to launch a particular app to use Siri. Instead, you just press down on the device's home button. And you can talk to it just as you would to a human, using simple language rather than arcane commands.

Voice recognition has been a staple of science fiction for decades and has been in development for almost as long. In recent years, it's been built into devices ranging from toy dolls to desktop computers. And Apple first started building it into iPhones with the 3GS released two years ago.

What is new - and revolutionary - about Siri is just how mature the technology has become. We're finally at a stage where interacting with a computing device primarily with your voice is a real possibility. That Apple is touting that capability as the key new feature of its flagship device is a good indication to me that it's finally about to go mainstream.

I've long been a big proponent of "natural" interfaces for computers and like devices. It's easier and more intuitive to tap on a screen, wave your hand or say a command than it is punch a button or type something in.

Nintendo's helped lead the charge on , the ability to interact with a computing device by moving a controller - or yourself - in a particular way. That ability is now built into each of the major and is included in nearly all smartphones and many other .

Apple's original iPhone sparked the adoption of computing - the ability to interact with a computing device with just your finger on a screen - without needing a stylus or physical keypad. Before the iPhone, it would have been almost unthinkable to make a phone that didn't have a physical keypad. Today, most smartphones and nearly all tablets are solely touch-based.

The Siri technology could also become a new industry standard. We may soon expect to be able to simply talk to a computing device for our information or communication needs, rather than having to tap, type or click.

Voice interaction has some huge potential advantages over standard methods. It decreases or eliminates your need to look at a screen. That has obvious benefits not only for people who are visually impaired but also for everybody else when they're driving, walking, exercising or just can't focus on a display. People distracted from driving by text messages or fumbling with their music player have increasingly become a danger.

In recent years, we've seen an explosion of apps for smartphones. But the more apps there are, the more difficult it can be to find them. Voice interaction helps clear the clutter by more directly addressing consumers' needs. Instead of having to remember and find the stock quote app and then typing in the ticker symbol for "Apple," you can get Apple's latest stock price by just asking for it.

And for many people, it's going to be a lot easier to compose a text or e-mail message with their voice than typing it with a virtual keyboard.

To be sure, much of what Apple showed Tuesday has been demonstrated before. Siri itself previously existed as a downloadable app in Apple's App Store - although Apple removed it and disabled existing copies Tuesday - and did many of the same things that are now a part of the 4S. But most of those features were not as robust as the built-in Siri.

Still, it's possible that the Siri feature could disappoint in real-world use, rather than in flashy onstage demos. I've not tested out the new feature yet, but voice-recognition technologies have a spotty history. They've often had a tough time dealing with ambient noise, fast speech or thick accents. I've tested out and quickly abandoned several voice-recognition technologies because they were too inaccurate and frustrating to use.

But I'm betting Siri will be different. Apple's obviously convinced. And the company has been known to spark a technology revolution or two.

Explore further: No fumbling, just tap, say Moto X tattoo all-stars (w/ Video)

More information: Troy Wolverton is a technology columnist for the San Jose Mercury News.

3.6 /5 (5 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Apple unveils faster, more powerful iPhone 4S

Oct 04, 2011

The most closely kept secret about the iPhone 5? There isn't one - yet. Apple unveiled a faster, more powerful version of its sleek iPhone on Tuesday and named it the 4S. It includes a futuristic, voice-activated ...

Apple expected to unveil new iPhone Tuesday

Oct 03, 2011

Apple fans are amped. The computer and gadget maker is expected to announce a new, more powerful version of its wildly popular smartphone this week - more than a year after it unveiled the iPhone 4.

Recommended for you

Xbox One update is big on friends, Blu-ray 3D support

Jul 21, 2014

An Xbox One August update is arriving for early-access users. Microsoft said, "We're looking forward to hearing feedback on features before we roll them out to all Xbox One consoles next month and beyond." ...

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

rivera151
5 / 5 (4) Oct 05, 2011
Ah, the voice recognition era is finally here, 1.5 years after I've had all of this on my Android handset.
Voleure
1 / 5 (2) Oct 05, 2011
Same here, voice is a great feature! I have been using it for the past year on my android as well. Dials, looks up people/places/facts and it does the majority of my text entry. Android built the voice into their standard keyboard pop-up last year so its universal to all apps not just messaging. Glad to see Apple has it now too. You will enjoy it!
John_balls
not rated yet Oct 05, 2011
Ah, the voice recognition era is finally here, 1.5 years after I've had all of this on my Android handset.


Exactly!!!!

But I had mine for 2 years.

Bottom line is that this phone offers nothing that is not already on the market and without 4g internet speed.

Apple 4gs without 4g speed = fail.
Temple
5 / 5 (2) Oct 05, 2011
It would be fair to point out that Apple has had Voice Control and dictation abilities (albeit non-universal) on it's phones since the debut of the iPhone 4.

The difference with this new product is the ability to use much more natural language, something that neither Apple, nor Android has done before.

Personally, I think this new introduction is going to change things for one simple reason:

No longer will voice control be merely a checkbox (as it has in the past for all players). Rather now, the competing point will be *how naturally* we can speak to our devices, not just *can* we.

With the big players now competing on this point, we will see much greater advances. And that is good for all of us, regardless of what devices we use.
Graeme
not rated yet Oct 05, 2011
Since the Siri app was around before, Apple should have just announced that voice recognition is withdrawn from the iPhone4. But wait to see how good the new functionality is.
plasticpower
5 / 5 (2) Oct 06, 2011
@Temple, exactly. Right now on all other phones you can say "dial XXXX" or "play songs by XXXX" or you can dictate a text. But you can't ask your phone naturally to "set alarm clock to 7 am for tomorrow morning" and have it do that. Neither can you ask it by voice to compile a quick calendar entry without going through a bunch of pre-programmed say-confirm steps. Nor can you press one button and send a text message to your friend Joe entirely by voice. Apple tends to release things late, but better than others.