UA study analyzes Israeli/Palestinian conflict news photos

Oct 17, 2011
This is an example of a war journalism frame. In this image, Palestinians carry the body of one of the relatives of Hamas Interior Minister Saeed Seyyam during his funeral in Gaza City on Jan. 16, 2009.

Journalism faculty member Shahira Fahmy analyzed photos with differing points of view over the Gaza War.

Since 1948 and the establishment of the state of Israel, media coverage of the Arab/Israeli has been a matter of extreme sensitivity and attention, not just for those who have been directly involved with it, but also to international news media and media academics around the globe.

In a study published in the recent issue of The , Shahira Fahmy, an associate professor in the University of Arizona School of Journalism, examined the photographic coverage of the Gaza War (2008-09) and the extent to which images of the conflict were portrayed as war vs. peace journalism in the three leading Western newswires (AP, Reuters, and Getty/AFP).

A peace journalism image is one that highlights peace initiatives and tones down differences by promoting . A war journalism image is one that highlights differences between opposing parties, urging violence as means to a resolution.

Based on this classification of images, Fahmy and Rico Neumann, an master's graduate from the UA department of communication, analyzed photographs to examine how the visual coverage of a Middle Eastern conflict is represented. Specifically, the researchers examined the extent to which newswire photos of the Gaza War varied in terms of war vs. peace journalism.

In analyzing the coverage, they found that nearly one in three children/adolescents in the images were depicted as wounded or dead – almost exclusively in the images in Gaza. As commonly known, the Gaza War quickly became the subject of controversy because of its high death toll among children in the Gaza Strip. On the Israeli side, only a few visuals exposed injured or dead adults, and no children lost their lives.

"Overall we found that the pool of photos including children outnumbered the pool of images featuring adults. We also found that negative emotions dominated these images and perhaps resulted in further demoralization of Palestinian citizens. In contrast, signs of hope and optimism were more common for images of Israelis," Fahmy said.    

The researchers also found that the three leading Western newswire services combined (AP, Reuters, and Getty/AFP) provided more war journalism images than peace journalism images. Examples included more images of dead and wounded civilians and damaged infrastructure. In addition, their findings suggested all three newswire services provided a variety of visuals to communicate a comprehensive coverage of the conflict.

As Fahmy explained, "This variety of visuals that we observed put great emphasis on the role of editors in providing a better understanding of wars and conflicts to their readers. In other words, the selection to run specific from the pool of available photographs covering the conflict was important in how the audiences visually experienced the conflict in Gaza."

Fahmy is a leading scholar in examining how journalists portray and terrorism, particularly through visuals. She teaches research methods, media and terrorism and other courses in the UA School of Journalism.

Explore further: Team researches the relationship between religion and educational attainment

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Has new media desensitized consumers to graphic images?

Jun 13, 2011

Because younger news consumers are exposed to graphic images online and through other new media, concerns journalists have about presenting highly graphic images of war to readers/viewers may be unfounded, finds a new University ...

Recommended for you

Young people overly optimistic about finances

Jan 23, 2015

A new survey of young New Zealanders by the Westpac-Massey Fin-Ed Centre shows that many believe their financial situation will improve in the coming year and their money management skills require no improvement.

How charter school foes are failing

Jan 22, 2015

As charter schools continue to expand, new research indicates liberal opponents are failing to make effective arguments aimed at curbing the education reform movement.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Oct 17, 2011
As commonly known, the Gaza War quickly became the subject of controversy because of its high death toll among children in the Gaza Strip. On the Israeli side, only a few visuals exposed injured or dead adults, and no children lost their lives.

Perhaps this is because in the last five years many Palestinians have lost their lives including children whereas no Israeli children have lost their lives and therefore there were plenty of opportunities to photograph dead and wounded Palestinians but none on the Israeli side.

The situation was very different a decade ago when there were several suicide bombs on busses and in other occupied settings where many Israelis were killed or wounded. Images, at least those we saw locally (Australia), were of dead and injured Israelis.

The authors of the study seem to have chosen a particular moment in history where balanced reporting would show dead Palestinians rather than dead Israelis.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.