Few Sparks: GM's underwhelming electric car program

Oct 18, 2011 By Jim Motavalli

For the first time since the late, lamented EV1 faded into oblivion in 2003, General Motors is back in the battery electric business, as it announces that it will roll out a plug-in version of the Spark minicar (it's also sold as the Beat on some markets) in the U.S. by 2013. Ho hum.

It's very hard to get excited about this announcement, because this is no make-or-break Volt program - GM is, instead, doing the bare minimum to get California credits, building an exceptionally cautious 2,000 cars on an entry-level program. If anyone buys 'em, great, but the company isn't risking much capital or prestige here. Obviously, the failure of the highly touted EV1 looms large.

The announcement on Wednesday was remarkably low-key. "The Spark EV offers customers living in urban areas who have predictable driving patterns or short commutes an all-electric option," said Jim Federico, a Chevrolet global vehicle chief engineer for EVs. If you meet those relatively narrow criteria, have we got a car for you.

Oddly enough, this CNBC story takes exactly the opposite tack from mine, claiming that the electric Spark is important because "it is further commitment to from a company that is not throwing i the towel on EVs," Phil LeBeau writes. Fair enough, but it's commitment of a fairly half-hearted type, and hardly a game-changing program like the Nissan Leaf. If that one doesn't work, Carlos Ghosn may have to find another line of work.

GM said it would incorporate information from the EV demonstration programs it has conducted in such exotic locales as Korea (the Cruze-based EV), India (the related Beat EV) and Shanghai (the Sail EV). The Spark's nanophosphate lithium-ion batteries will be from A123 Systems.

Ford seems more enthusiastic about its electric Focus program, but it too is making very conservative volume estimates. Chrysler isn't even trying - after announcing an electric version of the Fiat 500, it's said hardly anything about the car.

GM continues to see far more promise in plug-in hybrids than in battery electrics. The company has announced a luxury version of the Volt called the ELR, and it's toying with a crossover edition - shown in China as the MVP5. The Volt is the platform that keeps on giving; don't expect a similar GM family of battery cars, at least not yet.

According to Green Car Reports, the battery Spark isn't a 50-state car, as the Volt will by the end of the year. It will be targeted mostly at California, and possibly at the 13 states that follow its emission laws. Even without the ZEV laws, California would be the best market for an electric Chevy - it will probably have half or more of the EV volume in the early years.

If you're not familiar with the Spark, that's because it's currently sold only in Europe and Asia. It's coming to the U.S. as a gas car next year. The battery version will follow soon after, billed as a city car. That's an increasingly popular way of looking at EVs - as limited-range vehicles for in-city travel. The BMW i3 is known as the "megacity vehicle," and Toyota's 2012 Scion-based iQ electric (with just 50 miles per charge) is also for that market. Both Audi (the Urban Concept) and Volkswagen (Nils) showed city cars at the Frankfurt Motor Show.

My problem with the urban EV deal has to do with charging. Yes, sub-100-mile range suggests a bopping around the neighborhood, not taking a lot of range-robbing highway trips. But plugging in will actually be much easier in the suburbs, where people have garages. The city-based EV charging network is still under consideration, with companies just starting to wire parking garages and commercial lots. Forget about curbside parking in dense, high-rise cities like New York.

Don't get me wrong, it's good that GM is finally fielding another battery EV. But this is dipping a toe in the water, not jumping in with both feet.

Explore further: A platform to help consumers achieve sustainable energy consumption

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Tracker reveals how you will fare in EVs

Aug 24, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Drivers come in all shapes and personality sizes. Different heat and air conditioning needs. Different braking styles. Different climates. Different terrains. When it will come to buying an ...

China poised to be world leader in electric cars

Sep 05, 2011

Do you have an electric car-charging station in your neighborhood? In your garage? I didn't think so. They're still pretty scarce, but that situation is likely to be short-lived. By 2017, according to a new report from Pike ...

The electric cars most likely to succeed

Sep 06, 2011

The crystal ball is still cloudy on electric and plug-in hybrid cars. They're still being made in limited numbers, and delivered to very specific test markets. And half the really exciting ones aren't even here yet. Still, ...

Recommended for you

Image: Testing electric propulsion

Aug 20, 2014

On Aug. 19, National Aviation Day, a lot of people are reflecting on how far aviation has come in the last century. Could this be the future – a plane with many electric motors that can hover like a helicopter ...

Where's the real value in Tesla's patent pledge?

Aug 20, 2014

With the much-anticipated arrival next month of electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla's Model S to Australian shores, it's a good time to revisit Tesla's pledge to freely share patents. ...

New type of solar concentrator doesn't block the view

Aug 19, 2014

(Phys.org) —A team of researchers at Michigan State University has developed a new type of solar concentrator that when placed over a window creates solar energy while allowing people to actually see through ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

jerryd
not rated yet Oct 18, 2011
I think it's a good idea for GM as the spark has one very good thing going for it is it's light weight making the EV battery and drive smaller, more affordable.

Farming out the batteries and EV drive is another smart move.

The only dumb thing is waiting until 2113. But at least it's mostly built in the US. We need to bring the other car plants to the US too. Afterall we put up the money!!

The Volt is overpriced though actually cheaper than similar BMW's, etc.
sculptor
not rated yet Oct 22, 2011
"The only dumb thing is waiting until 2113."

I'm pretty sure A123 wouldn't have been ready for this deal any earlier...
unknownorgin
not rated yet Oct 23, 2011
If you had a family emergency and had to travel from seattle, WA. to San diego Calif. in a spark car today how would you do it in under 24 hours? The spark will be a second car because you still need to make long trips and a gas powered car or public tranportation is the only way because there is no infrastructure to support electric cars.
Callippo
not rated yet Oct 23, 2011
The total economic efficiency of electromobiles is poor, when the price of raw materials and price of oil is included. The conversion of gas into electricity is 40%, so that electromobiles are actually pretty dirty technology. Under situation, when most of electricity is produced with burning of oil and earth gas, it's still more effective and environmentally friendly to burn them in automobiles directly.

In addition, the introduction of cold fusion could virtualize the investments into research of batteries. GM was always a bit conservative company - but in this case such conservatism would save its profit.