Bovine TB testing under scrutiny

Oct 27, 2011
Bovine TB testing under scrutiny
Gareth Enticott

Planned changes to the way vets are allowed to conduct TB tests could have a dramatic impact on rural veterinary practices and fail to address quality control issues surrounding tests for bovine tuberculosis, University research has found.

The and Veterinary Laboratories Agency (AHVLA) recently announced their intention to require veterinary practices in England to competitively tender for TB tests in specific geographical areas. Proposals from the AHVLA suggest their preferred solution is for a groups of veterinary practices to work together to bid for testing contracts.

Research by Dr. Gareth Enticott funded by the Economic Social Research Council (ESRC) suggests that these plans will have a considerable impact on the provision of rural veterinary services and may not deliver expected financial or quality benefits.

Dr. Enticott, of the Center for Business Relationships, and Society, said: "Rural practices in some parts of the country have become hugely reliant on TB testing: it underwrites their ability to provide in . Practices that miss out on a contract are going to suffer".

The AHVLA’s preference is for a network of veterinary practices to work together. However, based on research in New Zealand, Dr. Enticott warns against this approach: "New Zealand contracted TB testing starting in 2003 but most of the contracts have gone to a state owned enterprise that had previously done all the testing. Veterinary practices have not had much of a look in, and business models that relied on a network of practices to deliver testing were judged too risky as they failed to deliver the required testing".

Dr. Enticott also suggests that the AHVLA will not deliver improvements in the quality of the testing because it ignores the reasons why poor quality testing exists. Dr. Enticott’s research suggests that the issues that concern AHVLA are related to the conflicts of interest in the way testing is organised and the lack of enforcement by Animal Health.

"If you are really concerned with quality control," says Dr. Enticott, "the best thing is to have independent testers. Having technicians rather than vets would also help address these problems. In the system advocated by AHVLA, however, the cost of monitoring these quality issues may cost more money than is saved through a competitive system."

Dr. Enticott’s work also finds that male vets are statistically more likely to find cattle infected with bovine TB (bTB) than female vets. Dr. Enticott says: "There is no clear reason to explain these differences. One explanation may be that female vets are often younger, newer to bTB testing and less experienced than male vets. This might mean that they are less likely to classify borderline cases as positive. Similarly, older (male) vets may be more likely to classify borderline cases as reactors because of their bTB testing experience or close relationships with farmers."

Dr. Enticott says the results have implications for future quality control methods: "The government has been concerned about the quality of bTB testing for some time. Countries like Ireland already use a system of performance indicators to audit testers. But these results show that method to be too simplistic and could lead to false comparisons between vets. A better way of dealing with quality control would be to reduce the conflict of interest that exists when vets farmers who are also their clients."

Explore further: Oregon food label measure headed for recount

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Incontinence sufferers have lower quality of life

Dec 16, 2006

[B]Debate continues over testing and treatment, balance may be needed[/B] An article published in The American Journal of Gastroenterology highlights the ongoing debate over whether testing is necessary prior to diagnosis and ...

Widespread stress among vets

Feb 25, 2009

Veterinarians frequently suffer psychosocial stress and demoralization associated with heavy workloads. Research published in BioMed Central's open access Journal of Occupational Medicine and Toxicology analyses the extent ...

Recommended for you

Oregon food label measure headed for recount

19 hours ago

Tallies of the last remaining ballots show an Oregon measure that would require labeling of genetically modified foods lost by only 809 votes and is headed for an automatic recount.

How photosynthesis changed the planet

Nov 20, 2014

Two and a half billion years ago, single-celled organisms called cyanobacteria harnessed sunlight to split water molecules, producing energy to power their cells and releasing oxygen into an atmosphere that ...

From dried cod to tissue sample preservation

Nov 19, 2014

Could human tissue samples be dried for storage, instead of being frozen? Researchers are looking at the salt cod industry for a potential tissue sample drying technology that could save money without sacrificing tissue quality.

Riding a food fad to an opportunity

Nov 18, 2014

Until a couple years ago, Shaun Paul's knowledge of chia was limited to the kitschy terracotta Chia Pet figurines. But recently, chia seeds, promoted as a nutritional powerhouse, have earned a growing consumer ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.