Unions continue to take a beating in post-recession climate, study shows

September 5, 2011

The Great Recession and ensuing job crisis continue to take a toll on union membership, according to UCLA's annual report on organized labor.

From July 1, 2010, to June 30, 2011, unionization rates remained essentially flat in Los Angeles but fell close to a percentage point in California and tumbled to historic lows nationwide, researchers from the university's Institute for Research on Labor and Employment (IRLE) found.

"The trend is bad for unions, it's bad for workers and, because it's a reflection of a jobless recovery, it's bad for the country," said Chris Tilly, director of the IRLE and a professor of at UCLA's Luskin School of Public Affairs.

"The State of the Unions in 2011: A Profile of Union Membership in Los Angeles, California and the Nation," publishes on Labor Day, Sept. 5.

The report is based on an analysis of the U.S. Current Population Survey, conducted by the U.S. and the U.S. . The IRLE report tracks year-to-year changes in unionization for the nation, California and the Los Angeles metropolitan area, including Santa Ana, Riverside, Long Beach, Thousand Oaks, Ventura, San Bernardino, Oxnard and Ontario.

The proportion of the workforce that is unionized in the Los Angeles metro area now stands at 16.4 percent, down from 16.5 percent last year, a drop that did not prove to be statistically significant. Even with its lackluster 2010󈝷 showing, the Los Angeles metro area accounts for nearly half of the union members in California, which has the highest number of union members of any state in the nation.

"Los Angeles–area unions are much more active in organizing new members than the average union nationwide, and they have been able to win a high level of political support, which helps them gain and retain members even in difficult times," Tilly said.

California, however, did not fare as well. Statewide unionization rates fell from 17.6 percent in 2009󈝶 to 16.9 percent in 2010󈝷 as the year's job growth managed to make only a small dent against the job losses California has experienced in the past four-and-a-half years.

"The 220,000 or so jobs recovered in California in 2011 were simply not enough to overcome the effects of the 1.3 million jobs that were lost in the state from the start of the recession in December of 2007 through September of 2010, when California reported its lowest number of jobs since the economic downturn," said Lauren Appelbaum, the report's lead author and research director of the IRLE.

Yet even with the significant drop, California's 2010󈝷 unionization rate did not fall below the state's average for the prior decade, which also was 16.9 percent.

But for the nation, the hit taken by unions had no upside in 2010󈝷. At 11.8 percent, the proportion of American workers who belong to unions is the lowest it has been since current reporting procedures began in 1983 and probably before that as well, the researchers said.

"At no time since the Great Depression has the country experienced such a low level of union participation by its workers," Appelbaum said.

As with last year, losses in 2010󈝷 came primarily in the private sector, the researchers found. This was particularly the case at the California state level, where private sector unionization rates dropped from 9.7 percent in 2009󈝶 to 8.9 percent in 2010󈝷.

"The industries that were first hit by the recession were industries that were not highly unionized, such as real estate, residential construction and financial institutions," Appelbaum said. "As the recession continued, job losses spread to other industries, including those with higher unionization rates. Technically we're in a recovery now, but employment is still lagging, and most of the new jobs are not unionized."

The Fresno metro area was especially hard hit. There, private sector unionization plummeted from 11.1 percent in 2009󈝶 to 5.6 percent in 2010󈝷, the researchers found.

The recession has also caught up with workers in non-residential construction, who are more likely to be unionized than their counterparts in residential construction. Immediately following the crash of 2008, employment in non-residential construction did not evaporate as quickly as it did in residential construction, thanks in part to federal economic stimulus dollars. But over the past year, membership in the unionized construction industry fell across the board. This was especially the case in California, where these unionization rates fell from 6.1 percent in 2009󈝶 to 5.0 percent in 2010󈝷.

"The stimulus package went into infrastructure. That, to some extent, was propping up non-residential construction, and that prop is pretty much spent now," Tilly said. "But the economy hasn't picked up enough yet for people to say, 'Let's build a new mall or a new office building.'"

The losses in unionized construction jobs, which are more often held by men than women, undoubtedly helped fuel the continuing drop in male unionization rates observed by the IRLE team. Between 2009󈝶 and 2010󈝷, male unionization decreased locally, statewide and across the nation, although the local drop did not prove to be statistically significant. Unlike last year, however, the drop did not appear to be due to rising unemployment among men.

"Initially, the drop in male unionization following the recession was due to the 'mancession.' Now, the jobs that are coming back increasingly are being filled by men, but the jobs aren't unionized, so that makes the percentage of men who are unionized smaller in the entire work force," Appelbaum explained.

Either way, though, the long-term gender gap in unionization rates in Los Angeles and California continued to widen as female workers joined unions — or retained their union memberships — more frequently than their male counterparts. Across the nation, where a smaller proportion of women than men are unionized, the drop in male unionization rates had a different impact — the gender gap shrunk.

The only other industry that saw a drop in unionization across the board — at the local, state and national levels — over the past year was wholesale and retail trade, a finding that did not surprise Appelbaum.

"Nobody has any money to buy anything, so of course these jobs suffer," she said.

Two other industries took a beating, although not to the same extent. While unionization rates in manufacturing and hospitality held steady at the national level, they experienced a decline locally and across the state. Manufacturing took the steepest fall.

The only across-the-board increase came in an area where even financially pinched consumers are hard-pressed to cut back: health care and social services. The growth was especially strong locally, where it rose from 11.6 percent in 2009󈝶 to 14.2 percent in 2010󈝷. Public administration also saw an increase, but only in Los Angeles and California. Across the nation, these were flat.

As in the past, continues to carry significant benefits, the researchers found. Unionized workers earned more per hour, on average, than their non-union counterparts in Los Angeles ($5.10 more), California ($4.20 more) and the U.S. ($4.40 more). With job growth anemic and inevitable hurdles to organizing at newly formed companies, the researchers are pessimistic that more workers will enjoy these benefits any time soon.

"The way the economy recovery is unfolding, I think next year's figures will be worse," Tilly said.

Explore further: U.S. union rates up substantially in 2008 for first time since 1970s, study shows

Related Stories

Study: Teachers' unions don't provide more pay

October 20, 2009

Teachers' unions have little impact on a school district's allocation of money, including teacher pay and spending per student, according to a study published this month in the Journal of Labor Economics.

Right-to-work laws endanger workers

April 8, 2011

Right-to-work laws not only hurt labor unions financially, they also may jeopardize worker safety, says a University of Michigan researcher.

Recommended for you

Ancient Egyptians used metal in wooden ships

August 31, 2016

A piece of wood recovered at a dig near the Great Pyramid of Giza shows for the first time that ancient Egyptians used metal in their boats, archaeologists said Wednesday.

Reconstructing the sixth century plague from a victim

August 30, 2016

Before the infamous Black Death, the first great plague epidemic was the Justinian plague, which, over the course of two centuries, wiped out up to an estimated 50 million (15 percent) of the world's population throughout ...

New species of pterosaur discovered in Patagonia

August 30, 2016

Scientists today announced the discovery of a new species of pterosaur from the Patagonia region of South America. The cranial remains were in an excellent state of preservation and belonged to a new species of pterosaur ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.4 / 5 (5) Sep 05, 2011
Post-recession? JA Ja ja And from Kalifornistan no less! Just yesterday a headline ran bemoaning the lowest EMPLOYMENT rate in California - ever!

UCLA joins the LSM in whistling past the graveyard.
2.8 / 5 (9) Sep 05, 2011
It is good that unionization is declining nationally in the private sector. Now, if we can just shake unions loose from their stranglehold on government jobs ...
2 / 5 (4) Sep 05, 2011
1.8 / 5 (5) Sep 05, 2011
Unions are soooo civil and willing to compromise:
"The tea party is a bunch of d**k-sucking corporate butt-lickers who want to crush the working people of this country."
1.8 / 5 (5) Sep 05, 2011
Labor Union Becomes Laughing Stock
Union hires non-union workers for minimum wage to protest against Wal-Mart.
3 / 5 (4) Sep 05, 2011
"The tea party is a bunch of d**k-sucking corporate butt-lickers who want to crush the working people of this country." - RyggTard

For once RyggTard is 100% correct.
2.5 / 5 (8) Sep 05, 2011
Socialists always resort to gutter language to cover the fact that their arguments fail.
2.6 / 5 (5) Sep 05, 2011
But for the nation, the hit taken by unions had no upside in 2010.

Sure there was! The unions took a hit! By definition, that's an upside for the nation!

"The trend is bad for unions, it's bad for workers and, because it's a reflection of a jobless recovery, it's bad for the country," said Chris Tilly...

Sadly, Chris Tilly has it all backwards (in this political sob story strangely posted on this science site)... What's bad for unions is GOOD for the country.
2.6 / 5 (5) Sep 06, 2011
"Quinn to Lay off Thousands


A decision made by Gov. Pat Quinn may leave thousands of state workers without a job by the end of the week.

The cuts are coming in the face of a budget deficit that doesn't leave enough money to pay the workers, the governor says. Quinn also plans to close a prison, juvenile detention center and homes for the mentally ill.

If no cuts are made, several agencies will run out of money by spring, Quinn says.

"We can't spend money we don't have," Quinn said Tuesday.

The state's largest government employee union, AFSCME, promises to sue if the layoffs are made, much like they did over blocked pay raises.

Source: http://www.nbcchi...XCGSPjxx

So unions expect the unelected courts to force legislators to raise taxes to keep the state union workers employed even though it will drive away the wealth creating taxpayers.

'Liberalism' is a mental disorder.
2.6 / 5 (5) Sep 06, 2011
I agree with RyggTard. It is essential to impoverish even more Americans in order to provide the maximum benefits to American Corporations and the wealthy.

Keeping wags artificially high compared to their African counterparts is just bad for Corporate America because it forces them to offshore their businesses to those nations.
3 / 5 (2) Sep 08, 2011
I agree with RyggTard. It is essential to impoverish even more Americans in order to provide the maximum benefits to American Corporations and the wealthy.

Keeping wags artificially high compared to their African counterparts is just bad for Corporate America because it forces them to offshore their businesses to those nations.

Unions, esspecially for public workers, are as corrupt and self-centered as they come. The union is there to self-perpetuate. I wonder what the advancement rate is for a worker OUT of the union to a position into management or above? The union is not interested in worker advancement, it's interested in worker stagnation.

Also, are you telling me that public worker unions need to siphon profits from a ... government? Unions sucked the american auto industry dry and then got an infusion from union symphathisers in Washington... or is that not how the story went?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.