Could silicon be ideal in quantum computing?

September 16, 2011 by Miranda Marquit feature

( -- "Quantum computing could provide a way to significantly speed up the way we process certain algorithms," Malcolm Carroll tells "The primary issue, though, is that you need a well controlled two-level system." He also points out that problems exist in terms of noise in quantum computing. One of the essentials in some models of quantum computing is utilizing the "spin" of certain electrons. Controlling the spins in GaAs quantum dots has advanced to a fairly sophisticated point, but there is still the issue of noise.

One way to reduce the noise in a is to use silicon. “Silicon spins have long coherence times. The noise is reduced with silicon, and that is an advantage for this type of , since you want to maintain coherence for as long as possible. However, it’s been a challenge to isolate and manipulate silicon spins,” Carroll explains.

In order to find a way to isolate and control silicon spins, Carroll, a scientist at Sandia National Laboratories in Albuquerque, New Mexico, has been working with a team. One member of the team, Tzu-Ming Lu, has been helping with the idea of controlling the number of spins with a gate, rather than using doping methods. The work on this project is published in Applied Physices Letters: “Enhancement-mode buried strained silicon channel quantum dot with tunable lateral geometry.”

“Increasing the distance between the spins and defects is part of the benefit of this process,” Lu explains. “One of the ways to get spins is to use doping to provide . However, the defects are closer. Instead, we use a gate in an alternative enhancement mode approach.”

Lu’s alternative enhancement mode technique was demonstrated during his time as a graduate student at Princeton; it set a world record in mobility. However, the set up was too big to be used effectively for quantum computing. “What we’ve done is taken the large scale field effect transistor structure, and make it into a few-electron quantum dot,” Carroll says. “We squeeze it down for better control of single electrons in this system.”

The structure, rather than being a single quantum dot, is actually a double quantum dot. “The dots are placed next to each other, and this gate structure makes it easier to control the spins in the device,” Carroll explains.

But why the focus on silicon? Well, as Carroll mentions earlier, the coherence time is longer. There is less noise at low temperature when silicon is used. Caroll and Lu also point out that there is already a solid silicon infrastructure. “We already have silicon foundries that can build the device,” Lu says. “People are used to working with silicon, and so you have very clean environment for the electrons, further reducing unintended noise sources.”

Now that some control over these silicon has been demonstrated in a few-electron device, the team at Sandia is ready to move on to the next steps. “We aren’t sure that our device is small enough yet,” Carroll says. “Additionally, there was an instability in this particular device. We’ve worked through a new design, and we want to check to make sure that the stability issue is gone.”

“Progress is being made in this area, and we’re not the only ones,” Carroll continues. “Silicon is a promising approach to quantum computing because of the long coherence times. This materials approach to isolating and controlling spins is very promising and it could allow even more people to realize the benefits of using in quantum computing.”

Explore further: Creating a pure spin current in graphene

More information: T.M. Lu, N.C. Bishop, T. Pluym, J. Means, P.G. Kotula, J. Cedarberg, L.A. Tracy, J. Dominguez, M.P. Lilly and M.S. Carroll, “Enhancement-mode buried strained silicon quantum channel quantum dot with tunable lateral geometry,” Applied Physics Letters (2011). Available online:


Related Stories

Creating a pure spin current in graphene

February 7, 2011

( -- Graphene is a material that has the potential for a number of future applications. Scientists are interested in using graphene for quantum computing and also as a replacement for electronics. However, in ...

Could light and matter coupling lead to quantum computation?

October 11, 2010

( -- In science, one of the issues of great interest is that of quantum computing, and creating a way to make it possible on a scalable level. This could be achieved by taking advantage of the strong interaction ...

Reducing noise in quantum operation at room temperature

August 23, 2011

( -- "A quantum memory is a crucial component of future quantum information processing technologies. Among these technologies, a quantum communications system based on light will enable vastly improved performance ...

Large scale qubit generation for quantum computing

July 27, 2011

( -- "Many people are trying to build a quantum computer," Olivier Pfister tells "One to the problems, though, is that you need hundreds of thousands of qubits. So far, scalability has been something ...

Learning more about phase transitions in small systems

June 23, 2011

( -- "People want to understand phase transitions in a finite system by quantum simulation," Luming Duan tells Duan is a professor at the University of Michigan, located in Ann Arbor. "Being able ...

Recommended for you

Researchers discover new rules for quasicrystals

October 25, 2016

Crystals are defined by their repeating, symmetrical patterns and long-range order. Unlike amorphous materials, in which atoms are randomly packed together, the atoms in a crystal are arranged in a predictable way. Quasicrystals ...

Making silicon-germanium core fibers a reality

October 25, 2016

Glass fibres do everything from connecting us to the internet to enabling keyhole surgery by delivering light through medical devices such as endoscopes. But as versatile as today's fiber optics are, scientists around the ...

Controlling ultrasound with 3-D printed devices

October 25, 2016

Ultrasound is more than sound. Obstetricians use it to peer inside a woman's uterus and observe a growing baby. Surgeons use powerful beams of ultrasound to destroy cancer cells. Researchers fire ultrasound into materials ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 18, 2011
The computational power and informational density of classical computers is limited with uncertainty principle in the same way, like at the case of quantum computers. It means, for consumer electronics operating at room temperature it has no meaning, whether you would decrease the number of atoms in classical transistors to the physical limit for the sake of their information density or whether you would increase the redundancy of quabits for the sake of their sufficient reliability - the effectiveness of both devices will converge to the same value.

Of course, the quantum computers running at the (near) zero temperature would supersede the classical computers running at room temperature pretty much - but the classical computers would run a way better at these low temperatures as well.

My subjective opinion simply is, the era of quantum computing is sorta hype without significant contribution for consumer electronics.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.