Nile crocodile is actually two different species

Sep 15, 2011 by Deborah Braconnier report
Nile crocidile (Crocodylus niloticus). Image: Wikipedia.

(PhysOrg.com) -- Researchers from the Fordham University in New York have uncovered evidence that what the world has looked to as the iconic Nile crocodile is actually two different species of crocodile that are only distantly related. The new research is published in Molecular Ecology.

The researchers, led by Evon Hekka, began this study when a colleague of hers, Michael Klemens from the Wildlife Conservation Society, sent her a DNA sample of some crocodiles that he had been in close contact with in an oasis in Ennedi Plateau, Chad. The travel guide he had been with suggested that they jump in the water and swim with these crocodiles as they were known for their docile behavior. Because of the odd nature of the behavior, Klemens had taken a tissue sample from a dead crocodile located nearby and sent it to Hekka.

Hekka had been working on Nile crocodile samples when she received this one from Klemens and when the results came back from the DNA sequencing, she repeated the test because she was convinced that she had done something wrong.

Hekka and her team began collecting various different Nile crocodile samples, including museum samples of some 2,000-year-old mummified crocodiles for a total of 180 different samples. It was determined that there was indeed two different of crocodiles known as Crocodylus niloticus and Crocodylus suchus.

All of the mummified crocodile remains were of the C. suchus and indicate that recognized a difference in species. The Greek historian Herodotus wrote that Egyptians were selective when choosing crocodiles for their ceremonies and generally chose the tamer and more docile crocodiles.

The distinction between the two species will have implications when it comes to conservation. The current range of the C. suchus is shrinking and their numbers are declining. While both species used to overlap in areas, the more aggressive C. niloticus has taken control of the region and pushed the docile C. suchus to more interior regions. The range of the C. suchus is under threat from oil industries and oil extraction and the have seen a decline in numbers due to unregulated trading of skin and bush meat.

This new evidence shows that C. suchus is much rarer than what was previously known simply as the Nile crocodile. While some areas in West Africa were hoping to be able to increase their trade in skins to increase revenue, this new study is likely to stop that from happening and may even reduce the amount they are allowed to trade.

Explore further: Alternate mechanism of species formation picks up support, thanks to a South American ant

More information: An ancient icon reveals new mysteries: mummy DNA resurrects a cryptic species within the Nile crocodile, Molecular Ecology, DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2011.05245.x

Abstract
The Nile crocodile (Crocodylus niloticus) is an ancient icon of both cultural and scientific interest. The species is emblematic of the great civilizations of the Nile River valley and serves as a model for international wildlife conservation. Despite its familiarity, a centuries-long dispute over the taxonomic status of the Nile crocodile remains unresolved. This dispute not only confounds our understanding of the origins and biogeography of the ‘true crocodiles’ of the crown genus Crocodylus, but also complicates conservation and management of this commercially valuable species. We have taken a total evidence approach involving phylogenetic analysis of mitochondrial and nuclear markers, as well as karyotype analysis of chromosome number and structure, to assess the monophyletic status of the Nile crocodile. Samples were collected from throughout Africa, covering all major bioregions. We also utilized specimens from museum collections, including mummified crocodiles from the ancient Egyptian temples at Thebes and the Grottes de Samoun, to reconstruct the genetic profiles of extirpated populations. Our analyses reveal a cryptic evolutionary lineage within the Nile crocodile that elucidates the biogeographic history of the genus and clarifies long-standing arguments over the species’ taxonomic identity and conservation status. An examination of crocodile mummy haplotypes indicates that the cryptic lineage corresponds to an earlier description of C. suchus and suggests that both African Crocodylus lineages historically inhabited the Nile River. Recent survey efforts indicate that C. suchus is declining or extirpated throughout much of its distribution. Without proper recognition of this cryptic species, current sustainable use-based management policies for the Nile crocodile may do more harm than good.

via Discover

Related Stories

Borneo's crocodiles 'no longer endangered'

Jun 28, 2010

Wildlife officials in Malaysian Borneo are pushing to have its saltwater crocodiles removed from a list of endangered animals, saying the reptile's numbers have strongly recovered in recent years.

Malaysia scientists tag Borneo saltwater crocodile

Jun 29, 2011

Wildlife researchers in Malaysia are to track a saltwater crocodile by satellite, they said Wednesday, in a bid to find out why nearly 40 people have been attacked on Borneo island over a decade.

No place for crocodiles in Philippines: official

Sep 14, 2011

Efforts to save the Philippine crocodile, a "critically endangered" reptile, could go in vain as bureaucrats oppose their release into the wild, a top Philippine environment official said Wednesday.

Endangered crocodiles released to fight extinction

Jan 27, 2011

Nineteen of the world's most critically endangered crocodiles were released Thursday into the wild in the Philippines as part of efforts to save the species from extinction, conservationists said.

20 endangered Siamese crocodiles hatch in Laos

Aug 26, 2011

(AP) -- One of the world's rarest crocodile species has moved a little bit further from extinction with the hatching of 20 wild eggs plucked from a nest found in southern Laos.

Rare crocs found hiding in plain sight in Cambodia

Nov 18, 2009

(AP) -- Conservationists searching for one of the world's most endangered crocodile species say they have found dozens of the reptiles lounging in plain sight - at a wildlife rescue center in Cambodia.

Recommended for you

Orb-weaving spiders living in urban areas may be larger

Aug 20, 2014

A common orb-weaving spider may grow larger and have an increased ability to reproduce when living in urban areas, according to a study published August 20, 2014 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Eli ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

GSwift7
1.5 / 5 (2) Sep 16, 2011
This is complete BS. Anybody with five minutes on Google can figure out why.

Anyone here care to take a guess?

Here's a hint:

Schmitz et al (2003)

lol. This "news story" should be removed from physorg. You've been conned.
DavidMcC
3 / 5 (2) Sep 17, 2011
This is complete BS. Anybody with five minutes on Google can figure out why.

Schmitz et al (2003)



Do you always cite inadequate reference details, GSwift7?
GSwift7
1 / 5 (1) Sep 18, 2011
This was recognized as a unique species ten years ago. They are in decline mainly because they are less agressive than the other, more dominate species. My reference was adequate if you bother to read it. This is ten year old news. The only point to this "story" is to block the oil exploration mentioned above. This is just a publicity stunt. There's no way anybody can protect these dwarf crocs from the larger and more agressive ones, and there's no reason they should unless you want to destroy the other species. There's only room for one there.

Do as I suggested, and google the species she says is "newly discovered" and you'll see that that's far from true. This is hardly a new discovery, and nobody would ever confuse the dwarf crocs with the big ones.
GSwift7
1 / 5 (2) Sep 18, 2011
The larger nile crocs are mainly downstream, while the dwarf crocs are mainly inland. The ancient Egyptians even knew that the dwarf crocs were different, and the Egyptians prefered them for ceremony because they are easier to handle since they are more docile. Nearly all the mumified crocs are this type. The range of the two species overlaps, but the larger, more agressive species has been pushing the smaller weaker and more docile species back for centuries. They were thought to have been driven out of existence until the 2003 study discovered that they still have a sustainable population in the interior of the african continnet. This is common knowledge, and I was able to find many pages about crocodiles that discuss this issue with only a few minutes on google. The DNA work was done prior to 2003 and they published in 2003 after substantial confirmation. The above article is total bs.