Existence of exoplanet 'Fomalhaut b' called into question

Sep 26, 2011 by Bob Yirka report
An exoplanet called Fomalhaut b has been photographed in an unexpected spot — so is it even an exoplanet at all? Image credit: NASA

(PhysOrg.com) -- Fomalhaut b, thought to be the first exoplanet photographed directly, has come under increased scrutiny due to evidence of an unexpected divergence from its expected orbit. Paul Kalas, James Graham and their colleagues identified the planet in 2008 while studying photographs taken by the Hubble telescope in 2004 and 2006. At that time it appeared Fomalhaut b orbited just inside a dust cloud that circles around Fomalhaut, the star at the center of that solar system. Now however, new photographs of Fomalhaut b show that it actually crosses into the dust cloud, causing Toronto astronomer Ray Jayawardhana, at a recent exoplanet conference, to suggest that Fomalhaut b may not be an exoplanet after all.

The whole story actually began back in 2005 when evidence arose from studies of the dust belt surrounding Fomalhaut, suggesting that at least one exoplanet (any planet not in our own solar system) existed in the system due to the behavior of the . After years of studying from Hubble, Kalas and his team came upon Fomalhaut b, an apparent exoplanet about the size of Jupiter (and three times its mass), orbiting some 1.72×1010 km from its sun. Unfortunately, more evidence regarding the exoplanet could not be had due to the malfunction of the camera onboard Hubble. It wasn’t until just last year that another picture of Fomalhaut b was finally made using a different camera on Hubble. The problem was, the exoplanet appeared in a different place than astronomers expected; a problem that has various astronomers offering various explanations. Some suggest that the projected was wrong, while others say that maybe it’s not a planet at all, but a background star or something else altogether.

Another problem is that there are other apparent anomalies as well. It’s too bright for its size example. Also, why aren’t other ground-based infrared telescopes able to detect its presence? Jayawardhana says that all of this combined information or lack thereof, should be enough to have Fomalhaut b removed from the exoplanet.eu database. Kalas, in response suggests that 1RXJ1609, an that Jayawardhana and his team are studying, should be reviewed more closely as well.

The whole argument, if that’s what it is, appears to suggest that perhaps more stringent means should be established for classifying exoplanets before they are announced as such. Also maybe, those astronomers in the field who seem to be just as interested in the limelight as in making new discoveries should perhaps take a closer look at how they are coming off to those reading about their spats in the press.

Explore further: Type Ia supernovae stem from the explosion of white dwarfs coupled with twin stars

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Exoplanet caught on the move (w/ Video)

Jun 10, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Only 12 million years old, or less than three-thousandths of the age of the Sun, Beta Pictoris is 75% more massive than our parent star. It is located about 60 light-years away towards the ...

First temperate exoplanet sized up (w/ Video)

Mar 17, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Combining observations from the CoRoT satellite and the ESO HARPS instrument, astronomers have discovered the first “normal” exoplanet that can be studied in great detail. Designated Corot-9b, ...

Volunteers to hunt for 'lost planets'

Dec 20, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- The public are being asked to help Oxford University astronomers find planets orbiting other stars which may have been 'lost' in the data from over 100,000 stars. Volunteers could even find ...

First four exoplanet systems imaged

Dec 13, 2010

Among one of the first exoplanet systems imaged was HR 8799. In 2008, a team led by Christian Marois at the Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics in Canada, took a picture of the system directly imaging three ...

Recommended for you

Exoplanet measured with remarkable precision

22 hours ago

Barely 30 years ago, the only planets astronomers had found were located right here in our own solar system. The Milky Way is chock-full of stars, millions of them similar to our own sun. Yet the tally ...

New star catalog reveals unexpected 'solar salad'

23 hours ago

(Phys.org) —An Arizona State University alumnus has devised the largest catalog ever produced for stellar compositions. Called the Hypatia Catalog, after one of the first female astronomers who lived in ...

New survey begins mapping nearby galaxies

Aug 18, 2014

A new survey called MaNGA (Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory) has been launched that will greatly expand our understanding of galaxies, including the Milky Way, by charting the internal ...

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

jamesrm
4.8 / 5 (6) Sep 26, 2011
Interplanetary Researcher Bitch Fight!
If we can get some media whore scientist like Michio Kaku to referee it a definite for Discovery Science Turbo-shutin!
GreyLensman
5 / 5 (4) Sep 26, 2011
Perhaps the exoplanet database should assign a confidence rating to its listings.
Mike_Syzygy
5 / 5 (2) Sep 26, 2011
and of course if it is noted to have made a 90 degree turn and accelerated in another direction, we will hear nothing of it.
marraco
5 / 5 (1) Sep 27, 2011
Illinois will declare it a planet no matter what.
lengould100
5 / 5 (1) Sep 27, 2011
Perhaps there are actually two planets?