China takes over as US solar power firms fail

Sep 18, 2011 by Bill Savadove
A masked worker sorts silicon wafers at the manufacturing centre of solar cell maker Trina Solar in Changzhou in 2009. China's solar power firms are having their day in the sun with the collapse of overseas competitors, but the new giants are struggling with low prices and overcapacity like others in the industry.

China's solar power firms are emerging as the industry's dominant force after the collapse of foreign competitors, but the new market leaders are already struggling with low prices and overcapacity.

As the workshop of the world, China has used cheap labour and state support to build a solar industry from scratch in just over a decade as part of a broader strategy to move up the manufacturing value chain from cheap toys and clothes.

China is the world's second biggest oil consumer, and polluting fossil fuels account for 90 percent of its total energy use, but the country is making large strides forward in clean energy.

Analysts say Chinese firms now have 70 percent of the growing global market in , thanks to aggressive pricing and the collapse of three US competitors in the last two months.

"The position of Chinese players has certainly been enhanced this year," said Tang Xiaodong, a Shanghai-based analyst at independent investment advisory firm CEBM.

"Lower costs are the direction of the industry and the advantages of Chinese firms on this front have been manifested more clearly."

China's solar panel prices have fallen to around $1.2 per watt of generation, down from about $1.7 last year and much lower than the global average of about $2.0 in 2010.

But the downward price spiral has hurt revenues across the industry, and Chinese companies are themselves feeling the pain.

"Everyone is facing falling prices, increasing inventories and dire straits," said an official at Yingli Green Energy, one of China's biggest solar companies, speaking on condition of anonymity.

Critics argue that Chinese companies have unfair advantages in the form of access to cheap capital from China's state-run banks.

However, they are not alone in receiving government assistance -- the latest US solar firm to file for bankruptcy was Solyndra, which had a $535 million loan guarantee from President Barack Obama's administration.

It joined Evergreen Solar, once listed on the Nasdaq exchange, and high-profile Intel spin-off SpectraWatt.

Residents walk past a line of solar power panels installed for public electricity supply in Shenyang, in northeast China's Liaoning province in 2009. As the workshop of the world, China has used cheap labour and state support to build a solar industry from scratch in just over a decade as part of a broader strategy to move up the manufacturing value chain from cheap toys and clothes.

But even before the collapse of those three US companies, China was already home to the world's largest producer of solar panels, Suntech.

"There is a periodic murmur from industry, trade groups and elements in the US government that unfair subsidies in other countries put the US at a distinct disadvantage in the ," said US-based analysis firm GTM Research in a recent report.

China's Suntech, which is listed on the New York Stock Exchange, counters such criticism by saying consolidation of the emerging industry was natural.

"The recent high-profile bankruptcies of innovative solar enterprises are unfortunate," Suntech said in a statement to AFP.

"However, competition among aggressive and innovative companies is critical to driving efficiency, productivity, and industry growth."

Chinese companies are almost solely focused on exports, with as much as 95 percent of production sold overseas according to some estimates, and they have responded to falling prices for solar panels by ramping up shipments.

But analysts expect domestic demand for solar products to rise with the introduction of a new national "feed-in" tariff -- a price the government guarantees to pay to producers of feeding into the grid.

"The days of China's PV (photovoltaic) production being purely for export are coming to an end," GTM Research said, referring to solar power technology.

Explore further: Morocco wind farm, Africa's biggest, starts generating power

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Asian competitors shadow German solar industry

Aug 18, 2009

Germany's solar power industry, until recently the world leader in the technology, is facing an unprecedented crisis, analysts say, outshone by cheaper competitors from Asia, most notably Chinese firms.

China solar panel makers see boost from Copenhagen

Dec 03, 2009

In Trina Solar's brilliant white factory in eastern China, masked workers in lab coats turn silicon wafers into solar power cells capable of harnessing the sun's clean and limitless energy.

Clouds gathering over German solar sector: study

Jul 16, 2010

Germany's once innovative solar energy sector seems to have lost some of its lustre and is increasingly being put in the shade by rivals in China and the United States, a study said on Friday.

US, Europe look to China for clean energy sales

May 17, 2010

(AP) -- U.S. leaders want China's clean energy boom to drive technology exports and are sending a sales mission to Beijing this week. But Beijing wants to create its own suppliers of wind, solar and other equipment and is ...

Recommended for you

Switch on sunlight for a brighter future

20 hours ago

Imagine sitting in a windowless room yet having the feeling of the sun shining on your face. This unique experience is now possible thanks to the COELUX EU-funded project which recreates the physical and ...

US urged to drop India WTO case on solar

Apr 23, 2014

Environmentalists Wednesday urged the United States to drop plans to haul India to the WTO to open its solar market, saying the action would hurt the fight against climate change.

Is nuclear power the only way to avoid geoengineering?

Apr 23, 2014

"I think one can argue that if we were to follow a strong nuclear energy pathway—as well as doing everything else that we can—then we can solve the climate problem without doing geoengineering." So says Tom Wigley, one ...

User comments : 12

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Vendicar_Decarian
2.3 / 5 (9) Sep 18, 2011
Poor Americans... They don't seem capable of being competitive in any global market.

I guess they will have to lower their standard of living to compete with labor from Somalia.
XQZME
2.1 / 5 (7) Sep 18, 2011
All because some idiots in search of government grants created a hoax that caught the attention of ideologists who adopted their alarms to promote population control, social justice, redistribution of wealth, and global government and also caught the attention of crony capitalists as a movement to promote extremely expensive, job destroying, renewable technology for more government development and manufacturing subsidies, grants and bailouts. There are too many idiots in politics!
TheSpiceIsLife
3 / 5 (4) Sep 19, 2011
"Critics argue that Chinese companies have unfair advantages in the form of access to cheap capital from China's state-run banks." - When the other side wins they call it "unfair".

Maybe the other side is just a better player ;)
dirk_bruere
not rated yet Sep 19, 2011
The PV industry seems to be following the IC market in its boom-bust cycle. In which case, in a couple of years having a PV factory will once again be a licesnse to print money.
antialias_physorg
5 / 5 (1) Sep 19, 2011
The PV industry seems to be following the IC market in its boom-bust cycle.

This boom-bust cycle has been with us since the advent of industrializations (look up how many fledgling car, plane, or even steam engine manufacturers went from boom to bust in the early days of the respective technology)

The best player wins. In a global market that's the player that can manufacture the cheapest. Crying over 'unfair' conditions never got anyone anywhere (and as the article noted the US government wasn't above creating unfair conditions itself by handing out cheap loans - so crying 'foul' is doubly hypocritical)

For solar products the solution seems obvious: Change the marketing angle. People who buy solar panels are, for the most part, eco-conscious. Buying from a source that has strict anti-pollution laws and doesn't exploit its labour pool should be a winning argument.
frajo
3 / 5 (2) Sep 20, 2011
The best player wins.
You mean "the winner is - by definition - the best"?
VHS vs. Betamax, Windows vs. OS/2 - there are lots of historical examples where the economical winner was (and is) technically inferior.

In a global market that's the player that can manufacture the cheapest.
Read physorg.com/news/2010-12-eu-india-limit.html :
For years, generic producers have simply had to prove their medicines are equivalent to the original drug to be approved. Under new rules, they would have to conduct clinical trials, which cost millions of dollars, to duplicate the data produced by the original company.
So the sentence has to be changed into "In a global market that's the player that is allowed to manufacture the cheapest."
NotAsleep
not rated yet Sep 20, 2011
Poor Americans... They don't seem capable of being competitive in any global market.

It's difficult to compete in a market where the biggest player is willing to die to win:
http://business.b...t=ias_c2

Eventually, China's production will no longer be sustainable and the pendulum will swing back to the west. Perhaps it won't bring us back to the 80s and 90s... but the world will start to find balance
holoman
not rated yet Sep 20, 2011
How does a company receive $ 500 million and fails.

It sounds like some funny business in Silicon Valley.

Chinese are good at lowering the price to capture market
share then rainsing the prices back up.

A strategy that has worked for 20 years.
frajo
not rated yet Sep 22, 2011
Eventually, China's production will no longer be sustainable and the pendulum will swing back to the west. Perhaps it won't bring us back to the 80s and 90s... but the world will start to find balance

Depends how you define "balance". Some historians argue the world lost its balance 500 years ago, when the Occident began to subjugate and ransack the rest of the world.
Read the wiki on admiral Zheng He.
CHollman82
2.3 / 5 (3) Sep 22, 2011
Poor Americans... They don't seem capable of being competitive in any global market.

I guess they will have to lower their standard of living to compete with labor from Somalia.


We should all admire china, who's complete lack of workers rights and environmental regulations allow them to produce the cheapest widgets in all the world... at the expense of the well being of the planet and everything living on it.
CHollman82
1 / 5 (1) Sep 22, 2011
How does a company receive $ 500 million and fails.

It sounds like some funny business in Silicon Valley.


Yes and they were recently raided by the FBI to try to uncover such funny business.
Vendicar_Decarian
1 / 5 (2) Sep 22, 2011
"We should all admire china, who's complete lack of workers rights and environmental regulations allow them to produce the cheapest widgets in all the world..." - CHoll

It is the beauty of a free and unregulated market.

More news stories

Google+ boss leaving the company

The executive credited with bringing the Google+ social network to life is leaving the Internet colossus after playing a key role there for nearly eight years.

Facebook woos journalists with 'FB Newswire'

Facebook launched Thursday FB Newswire, billed as an online trove of real-time information for journalists and newsrooms to mine while reporting on events or crafting stories.

Genetic legacy of rare dwarf trees is widespread

Researchers from Queen Mary University of London have found genetic evidence that one of Britain's native tree species, the dwarf birch found in the Scottish Highlands, was once common in England.