Volcanic artifacts imply ice-age mariners in prehistoric Greece

Aug 29, 2011 By Larry O'Hanlon
Credit: Vokabre via flickr

Mariners may have been traveling the Aegean Sea even before the end of the last ice age, according to new evidence from researchers, in order to extract coveted volcanic rocks for pre-Bronze Age tools and weapons.

A new technique which dates obsidian -- volcanic glass which can be fashioned into tools -- suggests that people were mining for obsidian in Mediterranean waters and shipping the once valuable rocks from the island of Melos in modern day as far back as  15,000 years ago.

"Obsidian was a precious natural rock-glass found only in Melos, some in [the modern-day Greek areas of] Antiparos and Yali," explained Nicolaos Laskaris of the University of the Aegean in Greece. "From there it was spread all over the Aegean and in the continent too through contacts of trade."

If you wanted to have sharp tools and weapons in the days before bronze, you needed places like Melos. But you also needed a boat to get there. The evidence that people were crossing over to Melos even before the end of the last ice age comes from obsidian artifacts found in the Franchthi cave on the Peloponnese peninsula in southern mainland Greece -- far from the island of Melos. Previous geochemical work had already established the artifacts were from Melos, but figuring out when they were brought from the island is a trickier problem.

"They were sailors, certainly, especially in the Aegean region they followed little islands jumping like a frog reaching also Asia Minor and the Greek mainland," said Laskaris, who with his colleagues has published a paper about the discovery in the Sept. 2011 issue of Journal of Archaeological Science. "Until now only in Franchthi cave obsidians had been found at circa 8,500 B.C. Now we prove earlier contact with coastal sites was a fact."

Laskaris and his colleagues turned to a method called obsidian hydration dating (OHD) combined with a newer technique known as secondary ion mass spectrometry of surface saturation (SIMS-SS) to determine how much water had penetrated the obsidian surfaces that were exposed to the air by prehistoric humans who were chipping the rocks to make tools and weapons.

"A freshly exposed obsidian surface contains microscopic cracks, into which water absorbs over time," explained researcher Ellery Frahm, of the University of Minnesota Twin Cities, and president-elect of the International Association for Obsidian Studies. The OHD method alone is not very reliable at dating the fractures on the rocks, because it has a couple of serious limitations, she said.

The first is the fact that it’s difficult, when looking at the rock surface through a microscope, to see and measure how deep the fuzzy water diffusion zone penetrates into a rock.

"Where do you measure along this fuzzy line? Second, the diffusion front isn't really where it looks to be. A straw appears to bend in a glass of water due to the difference in refraction index of air and water, so the diffusion front in obsidian isn't really where it appears to be either for the same reason," Frahm explained.

But when SIMS-SS, the new mass spectrometry technique, is added to the picture, scientists can actually quantify the water that penetrates a rock.

"SIMS can directly measure the water in obsidian over a depth," Frahm said. "A particle beam removes ions from the obsidian in extremely thin layers, it is like individually measuring the composition of each onion peel layer." That way the change in content can be plotted with depth, revealing exactly how it changes.

Using the new SIM-SS method, Laskaris and his colleagues were able to determine that Melos obsidian artifacts were making it to the mainland earlier than previously believed. That naturally implies that people were crossing between islands very early in some unknown types of boats.

Explore further: Tropical depression 21W forms, Philippines under warnings

Provided by Inside Science News Service

4.6 /5 (8 votes)

Related Stories

New technology for dating ancient rock paintings

Mar 11, 2009

A new dating method finally is allowing archaeologists to incorporate rock paintings — some of the most mysterious and personalized remnants of ancient cultures — into the tapestry of evidence used to study life in prehistoric ...

Human precursors went to sea, team says

Aug 17, 2011

Early manlike creatures may have been smarter than we think. Recent archaeological finds from the Mediterranean show that human ancestors traveled the high seas.

Carbon dating identifies South America's oldest textiles

Apr 13, 2011

Textiles and rope fragments found in a Peruvian cave have been dated to around 12,000 years ago, making them the oldest textiles ever found in South America, according to a report in the April issue of Current Anthropology.

Recommended for you

Better forecasts for sea ice under climate change

23 hours ago

University of Adelaide-led research will help pinpoint the impact of waves on sea ice, which is vulnerable to climate change, particularly in the Arctic where it is rapidly retreating.

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

SteveL
5 / 5 (1) Aug 29, 2011
I don't know of any biological reason that mankind could not have had civilizations before the last ice age. I read recently that DNA changes take a long time to get locked into a genome. We wouldn't have been significantly different than we are now, either physically or our mental capacity. But, 50,000 years would do a lot of erasing of any evidence. I've long thought this ancient astronauts/Gods stuff was a bunch of smoke and that there is no reason humans could not have developed methodologies to accomplish things in the past that we have since forgotten. Knapping for instance. Give a modern person a piece of obsidian and tell them to make a knife out of it. Good luck - BTW - I have one..
eachus
5 / 5 (1) Aug 29, 2011
The dating process is fine, but the boats are still products of imagination. We know that the sea level in the western Med has varied significantly in modern times. During the Younger Dryas the water level in the Mediterranean Sea (and the global level of all oceans) rose sharply about 11000 years before present. So was Melos an island 12-15000 years ago? Probably not.

That is not to say there were no boats back then. The problem with studying cultures and civilizations more than 11000 years ago is that the remains are mostly under water. People lived mostly on coastlines, and when the water level rose, they moved inland. There have been chance findings of sites under 100 feet of water, but most under water sites are also under a lot of mud.
YawningDog
3 / 5 (1) Aug 29, 2011
To say that ancient boats are a product of our modern imaginations is a bit of a stretch. And the comment about Melos probably not being an island? If the Mediterranean Sea rose by 2,464 ft (751 M), it may have been covered by water. But that seems unlikely. Your 1st paragraph is a comical litany of false logic. The 2nd says nothing (stuff underwater gets covered with mud over time? How profound).

There is a considerable body of evidence that supports the idea of a world encompassing seafaring culture existing before written language appeared.

The basic need of Mesolithic and Neolithic mankind during the last 10,000 years B.C. was material for better axes for making improved water-vehicles, such as canoes and sailing ships out of the bark and wood furnished by the biggest and lightest trees available.

With the advent of metals, the need for tin necessitated more and wider exploration. Thus we find artifacts all over the world.
SteveL
4 / 5 (1) Aug 29, 2011
I'm with YawningDog on the issue about boats. Just because we haven't discovered any over 10k yrs old doesn't mean they didn't exist. Everything decays over time.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.