What do Facebook and Rembrandt have in common? Everything

August 5, 2011

Facebook and artists like Rembrandt have much in common, says the author of "Friending the Virgin: some thoughts on the pre-history of Facebook" in the open access journal SAGE Open.

The main commonality lies in the act of portraiture, which consists of more than just the realistic depiction of a subject, but also a number of rhetorical decisions closely intertwined with evolving ideas of identity and society, according to author Larry Friedlander. The article points out the complex negotiations that artists had to make when painting some of their most famous works, similar to the choices people make today with respect to selecting images, interests, and descriptions to represent themselves on .

"In traditional portraiture pose, , prop, costume, glance provided the raw materials out of which a specific presence was evoked," wrote Friedlander. "For example, in (the) portrait by of Nicolaes Ruts, the sitter presents himself to the viewer with admirable directness. Ruts was a Mennonite fur trader and his sable coat and hat refer to his trade. Nothing extraneous distracts from the image's message: this is a merchant, a rich man, evidently serious and respectable."

Similarly, today's Facebook –or any social networking site— profile allows contemporaries to share their collective portraiture. This may seem easier than sitting for a portrait, but Friedlander contends that today's tools of text, pictures and video almost allow for more potential for failure than the paintbrushes of masters.

"Anxiety, the subject's and the viewer's (of the painted portrait), is hidden well beneath the surface. But it is there precisely in the artist's effort to smooth those anxieties out of existence," wrote Friedlander. "We, in contrast, wear our anxieties on our sleeves. But both Rembrandt and Facebook strive for mastery over the challenges of representation."

Explore further: Has the mystery of the Portrait of Maud Abrantes been solved?

More information: doi: 10.1177/2158244011415423

Related Stories

Has the mystery of the Portrait of Maud Abrantes been solved?

February 9, 2010

A century after Amedeo Modigliani painted the Portrait of Maud Abrantes, the mystery behind the painting might be solved. Ofra Rimon, Director and Curator of the Hecht Museum at the University of Haifa, discovered that hidden ...

Facebook shrinks Web page fonts

November 4, 2010

Facebook set some users to squinting by shrinking text size on pages of the world's most popular online social networking service.

Recommended for you

Robo-whiskers mimic animals exploring their surroundings

August 4, 2015

Many mammals, including seals and rats, rely on their whiskers to sense their way through dark environments. Inspired by these animals, scientists working at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and Illinois' Advanced ...

3 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Telekinetic
2.3 / 5 (3) Aug 05, 2011
What do Facebook and Rembrandt have in common? Nothing. And to speak of them in the same breath is disgusting. Say good-bye to civilization.
Milou
not rated yet Aug 06, 2011
Now really? I agree with Telekinetic. Might as well compare the cave man drawing in the "cave" with facebook, Rembrandt and your child's drawing. All the same with their interpretation of the "sameness"!!!! "...their collective portraiture. This may seem easier than sitting for a portrait, but Friedlander contends that today's tools of text, pictures and video almost allow for more potential for failure than the paintbrushes of masters....". Failure is no kidding (Duuhhhhhh...).

"...But both Rembrandt and Facebook strive for mastery over the challenges of representation." The word "Mastery" is way overrated expression for Facebook.
Bob_B
not rated yet Aug 06, 2011
Puke science for pukes.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.