Q&A: Saying goodbye to the space shuttle

Jul 11, 2011 By Jenny Hall
Atlantis' Maiden Launch at NASA's Kennedy Space Center in Florida, in April of 1985. Credit: NASA

With the final launch of the Atlantis, NASA retires its space shuttle program. We spoke to Professor Chris Damaren of the University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace Studies about the end of an era in manned space travel.

Damaren researches spacecraft dynamics and control systems. He also serves as  Vice-Dean, Graduate Studies in the Faculty of Applied Science and Engineering.

What does the end of the space shuttle program mean for Canada and the United States?

We lose regular access to low earth orbit and to the International Station. There are other ways to get there, though—the Russian Soyuz Vehicle for example. But that’s not something that the we can depend on on a regular basis.

What will be the successor to the shuttle program?

Prior to this year there was something called the Constellation Program, which was a road map that would see the United States back on the moon by 2020 and ultimately sow the seeds for a manned visit to Mars. The Obama administration put the brakes on the program and has replaced that with a focus on more input from the private sector.

So there’s no official program waiting the wings.

No, that’s the problem. We’re kind of in limbo at the moment. But that said, there are a lot of things going on in space exploration. There are still plans to visit Mars on a regular basis with robotic vehicles. None of that’s changed.

The shuttle is optimized for one thing, and that’s manned space flight. That’s the bit that’s in limbo.

What about the International Space Station?

There is still an implied commitment from NASA to run the space station until at least 2020, probably beyond that. The feeling is now it will be thought of as a national lab, like a terrestrial-based lab but it will be in space.

Can you say anything about the future of manned space travel by North Americans?

There’s not a well-defined answer at this point. There are a number of things that people have talked about. Obama has mentioned the possibility of landing on an asteroid. That would involve a flight of longer duration than we’re used to, certainly much longer than getting to the moon. But who is going to develop the vehicles? These are the kinds of details that are lacking.

Why would we want to land on asteroid?

They’re seen as a source of raw materials. They’re very rich in certain kinds of minerals.

So it seems like we’ve reached the end of the era of exploring space just for its own sake, out of a fundamental curiosity.

That’s a good point. I think on a fundamental level that still drives us. Why do we engage in space exploration? The same reason Jacques Cartier and Henry Hudson and people like that hit the ocean and decided to head in the direction of North America. I think that still exists.

What would  private sector-driven manned spaceflight be like? The layperson’s stereotype is that rich people will be able to buy tickets to space.

That’s how it is initially going to manifest itself. The first forays of private companies will be things like Richard Branson bankrolling visits to space for people with money. But I don’t  think that’s what Obama is referring to when he says that rather than NASA developing the Constellation Program, we expect the private sector to step in. I think he’s expecting them to do the kinds of things that is currently doing.

Because presumably there’s a return to be made.


What role does Canada play in the future of public or private sector space program?

Our main interaction on the manned front has been participation via our astronaut program. I’m not sure where that fits. I could see us continuing to visit the space station, obviously by different mechanisms than the shuttle. We have taken on new astronauts fairly recently and I would see them taking part.

So maybe this isn’t as big a deal as it seems?

In the short duration it is, but in the long term, it’s not as bad as people are making out. It’s just that we have to wait for different mechanisms to manifest themselves.

Explore further: MAVEN studies passing comet and its effects

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

NASA needs new 'breakthrough,' says Obama

Jul 06, 2011

NASA needs new technology breakthroughs to revitalize its mission to explore the universe, President Barack Obama said Wednesday as the shuttle Atlantis was preparing for its final mission.

Leonardo attached to Space Station

Mar 02, 2011

After a flawless launch last Thursday and a textbook docking on Saturday, the Space Shuttle today delivered the European-built Leonardo Permanent Multipurpose Module to the International Space Station.

Will the U.S. continue to 'reach for the stars'?

Apr 28, 2011

With the space shuttle program winding down — Discovery returned from its final mission in March, Endeavor is scheduled for its last flight this Friday, and Atlantis should launch at the end of June — ...

Space Adventures wants to fly you to the moon

May 06, 2011

Space Adventures – the company that brought the first space tourists to the International Space Station – has longer space tourist excursions planned for as early as 2015: a trip around the Moon. ...

Why shuttles are being retired, what's next

Jul 08, 2011

Thirty years of flight by NASA's space shuttles will end once Atlantis returns home from this last mission. The space agency will be looking to deeper space exploration, but the future is still somewhat unclear.

Recommended for you

MAVEN studies passing comet and its effects

31 minutes ago

NASA's newest orbiter at Mars, MAVEN, took precautions to avoid harm from a dust-spewing comet that flew near Mars today and is studying the flyby's effects on the Red Planet's atmosphere.

How to safely enjoy the October 23 partial solar eclipse

41 minutes ago

2014 – a year rich in eclipses. The Moon dutifully slid into Earth's shadow in April and October gifting us with two total lunars. Now it's the Sun's turn. This Thursday October 23 skywatchers across much ...

How to grip an asteroid

1 hour ago

For someone like Edward Fouad, a junior at Caltech who has always been interested in robotics and mechanical engineering, it was an ideal project: help develop robotic technology that could one day fly on ...

Image: Comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

3 hours ago

It was 45 years ago when astronomer Klim Churyumov and Svetlana Gerasimenko, one of his researchers, unwittingly began a new chapter in the history of space exploration.

Extreme ultraviolet image of a significant solar flare

3 hours ago

The sun emitted a significant solar flare on Oct. 19, 2014, peaking at 1:01 a.m. EDT. NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory, which is always observing the sun, captured this image of the event in extreme ultraviolet ...

Heavy metal frost? A new look at a Venusian mystery

22 hours ago

Venus is hiding something beneath its brilliant shroud of clouds: a first order mystery about the planet that researchers may be a little closer to solving because of a new re-analysis of twenty-year-old ...

User comments : 0