Insights into the story of the eye

Jul 04, 2011
Figure 1: Optic vesicles, formed by ESCs cultivated over nine days under modified SFEB conditions, have undergone invagination to yield optic cup-like structures. Green fluorescence indicates expression of the retina-specific gene Rax in the optic cups. Copyright : © 2011 Yoshiki Sasai

( -- Although it is well established that embryonic stem cells (ESCs) have the capacity to develop into every adult cell type in the body, mysteries abound regarding the process by which the differentiation of these cells is coordinated during the formation of complex tissues.

The eye, for example, is a very sophisticated organ, consisting of several highly organized layers of specialized cell subtypes, which initially develops from a largely homogeneous known as the ectoderm. This process initiates with the formation of a bubble-like optic vesicle, which subsequently folds back on itself to form a two-layer ‘optic cup’, with the inner surface forming the sensory tissue of the neural retina and the outer surface forming the supporting tissue of the retina pigment epithelium (RPE).

How this actually happens remains unclear and controversial. “One strong hypothesis was that the invagination of the retina is caused by pushing from the lens, which itself invaginates from the surface ,” explains Yoshiki Sasai of the RIKEN Center for Developmental Biology, Kobe. He adds that although some studies support this idea, others have proven ambiguous or contradictory. However, recent stem cell research from Sasai and colleagues not only offers powerful new insights into retinal development but also provides surprising evidence in favor of an alternative hypothesis, originally proposed over 100 years ago.

Getting organized

At the turn of the 20th century, German developmental biologist Hans Spemann, a legend in the field of embryology, uncovered evidence indicating that invagination of the optic cup and subsequent lens formation occur spontaneously, without any external force. “This mechanism has been under debate for many decades since that time,” says Sasai. Using a specially designed strategy for the cultivation of mouse ESCs, his group has now provided vital support for this model by demonstrating successful differentiation of an appropriately layered and structured mouse retina in vitro, in the absence of external physical drivers.

Sasai and colleagues’ technique was an adaptation of serum-free culture of embryoid body-like aggregates (SFEBq), a cell culture system that they had developed previously to coax the development of ESCs into organized layers of cerebral cortical neurons. “The retina is another clearly stratified structure, and we tried to see whether we could achieve more complete development of layered structures that resemble postnatal tissue from stem cells,” explains Sasai.

After a week under these improved culture conditions, their ESCs developed into hollow spheres of neuroectoderm epithelial cells, precursors of nervous system tissue, which subsequently sprouted dome-shaped vesicles expressing the retina-specific gene Rax. Over the next few days, these vesicles spontaneously folded inward to form structures that closely resemble the optic cup observed in natural embryonic development (Fig. 1). Both of these newly formed layers exhibited gene expression profiles matching their natural counterparts, with no evidence for the onset of lens formation or other ectodermal influences that might represent physical triggers for this developmental process.

By closely observing this in vitro optic cup formation with a powerful fluorescence microscope, the researchers were able to characterize the details of invagination at various stages. Initially, the optical vesicles consisted exclusively of a single type of epithelial cell, but as the outermost edge of the vesicle flattened, indented and finally underwent full invagination, the cells formed distinct subpopulations that also closely resemble their counterparts in the naturally developing neural retina and RPE.

Figure 2: Cultured neural retina layers develop into highly organized structures composed of distinct layers. Fluorescent labeling indicates the photoreceptors in the outer nuclear layer (green), the bipolar cells of the inner nuclear layer (red) and the ganglion cell layer (blue). Copyright : Reproduced from Ref. 1 © Mototsugu Eiraku et al.

Sasai and colleagues determined that the earliest morphological changes in the vesicle appear to arise from pulling force generated by ‘motor proteins’ acting on microscopic filaments within the indenting epithelial cells. These motor proteins become less important as invagination proceeds in earnest; later stages instead appear to be powered by a pushing force generated by the physical expansion and active proliferation of cells within the developing retinal tissue.

All part of the program

To investigate the further subspecialization of neural retina layer cells, the researchers dissected their ESC-derived optic cups and cultured this cell layer independently. Within two weeks, these tissues had developed into highly stratified structures composed of a diverse array of extremely specialized cell types, each of which was spatially restricted to the appropriate level within the overall neural retina structure (Fig. 2). Aside from some minor differences, such as a relatively reduced population of color-sensing ‘cone’ photoreceptors, these in vitro-derived tissues were largely indistinguishable from a postnatal mouse retina.

In spite of Spemann’s historic predictions of retinal self-organization, Sasai admits that he and his colleagues were surprised by the extent to which such a complex organ can form in the absence of external guidance. “This means that the cells fated to become the retina have a latent, intrinsic order that allows them to form such an elaborate structure by following an internal program,” he says.

Further studies will be required to determine whether these ESC-derived retinas retain full functional capacity in terms of light-sensing and signal transmission, and whether they might be used to repair retinal damage in animal models. If they pass these and other tests, such engineered tissues could prove invaluable as material for transplantation in the treatment of a variety of diseases.

This work may also offer useful starting points for investigating similar ‘internal programs’ that might underlie the autonomous development of stem cell populations into other complex tissues, including the elaborate and heterogeneous structures that comprise the brain. “We are now analyzing the mechanism of self-driven morphogenesis at the cellular and molecular level,” says Sasai, “and we ultimately hope to incorporate these pieces of information into a three-dimensional computer simulation.”

Explore further: Mycologist promotes agarikon as a possibility to counter growing antibiotic resistance

More information:
Eiraku, M., Takata, N., Ishibashi, H., Kawada, M., Sakakura, E., Okuda, S., Sekiguchi, K., Adachi, T. & Sasai, Y. Self-organizing optic-cup morphogenesis in three-dimensional culture. Nature 472, 51–56 (2011).… ull/nature09941.html

Eiraku, M., Watanabe, K., Matsuo-Takasaki, M., Kawada, M., Yonemura, S., Matsumura, M., Wataya, T., Nishiyama, A., Muguruma, K. & Sasai, Y. Self-organized formation of polarized cortical tissues from ESCs and its active manipulation by extrinsic signals. Cell Stem Cell 3, 519–532 (2008).… -5909%2808%2900455-4

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

The self-made eye: Formation of optic cup from ES cells

Apr 06, 2011

Groundbreaking research from the RIKEN Center for Developmental Biology (CDB) shows how mouse stem cells spontaneously form into optic cups, the precursors of eyes. A report on this research, published this week in Nature, sheds ...

The beginnings of the brain

May 13, 2011

All of the tissues and organs of the body arise from one of three embryonic precursors: the ectoderm, mesoderm and endoderm. The ectoderm contributes to several tissues, including the nervous system and the ...

New protein promotes embryonic brain formation

Dec 24, 2010

The various bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling factors play an important role in early neural development in the vertebrate embryo. However, maturation of these tissues ultimately depends on the coordinated ...

Identifying stem cell suicide triggers with ROCK

Oct 11, 2010

A RIKEN-led team of molecular biologists (Japan) has determined why human embryonic stem cells (ESCs) and induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells undergo apoptosis, or programmed cell death, when separated from ...

Novel factor behind ES cells' neural default

Mar 16, 2011

Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) are highly regarded for their ability to give rise to the full range of cellular lineages found in the adult body, but left to their own devices ESCs tend to differentiate into ...

Study reveals how the eye is formed

Apr 06, 2011

( -- Scientists at King’s College London have discovered specific cells responsible for ensuring that different parts of the eye come together during development, according to a paper published ...

Recommended for you

YEATS protein potential therapeutic target for cancer

22 hours ago

Federal Express and UPS are no match for the human body when it comes to distribution. There exists in cancer biology an impressive packaging and delivery system that influences whether your body will develop cancer or not.

Precise and programmable biological circuits

Oct 23, 2014

A team led by ETH professor Yaakov Benenson has developed several new components for biological circuits. These components are key building blocks for constructing precisely functioning and programmable bio-computers.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jul 05, 2011
Sloppy article, IMO. Firstly, there is no one form of eye development, and there is no mention of the species illustrated or described. The retina of the vertebrate eye is well established to be derived from the neural crest, and as such, is part of the diencephalon:
The vertebrate cornea, of course, is a transparent part of the skin, and is thus from the ectodermal.