Cloned trees raised in separate places react differently to drought

July 25, 2011 By Amina Khan

Nurture matters - in plants as well as people. Cloned trees raised in different places and environments react differently to drought conditions even though they're genetically identical, scientists have found.

"Turns out the trees have a memory, and they are adapted to the environment in which they're grown," said Richard Meilan, a Purdue University molecular tree physiologist who was not involved in the study.

Researchers have long been interested in how much genes, versus environment, contribute to a creature's biology and behavior; the many "twin studies" performed with humans attest to that fascination. Such studies have clearly shown that even genetically , though startlingly similar, bear distinct differences.

Plant growers had often noticed that a plant purchased from one nursery would be sickly while the same plant from another nursery, perhaps even cloned long ago from the same bush or tree, would flourish - a phenomenon referred to as the "nursery effect."

To figure out what might be going on, Canadian researchers grew clones from that were genetically identical but raised in different parts of Canada. They did this for three types of poplar varieties - Okanese, Walker and DN34. In each case, some variants came from Saskatchewan and the others from regions with different amounts of and sunlight.

Reporting July 11 in the , the researchers found that in the case of the Walker and DN34 clones, trees grown in different places reacted very differently when they were deprived of water.

Walker poplars raised in Alberta took two full days longer than their Saskatchewan to respond to the simulated drought by closing up holes in their leaves, called stomata, to minimize water loss. And DN34 poplars raised in Manitoba closed their stomata two days sooner than DN34 poplars from Saskatchewan.

Okanese clones, however, took the same time to close up against the drought, regardless of where they were from.

The scientists also detected differences in gene activity that could be responsible for these differences, they said. The Okanese poplars' gene patterns matched regardless of origin - but varied widely for Walker, and especially for DN34, poplars depending on where they'd been raised.

"We're talking literally hundreds of genes doing something different in response (to drought), in plants from one location versus the other," said study co-author Malcolm Campbell, a genome biologist at the University of Toronto. "It's really quite stunning."

The oldest clone of the three, DN34, dates to the 1900s - implying that differences strengthen with age. The youngest, Okanese, dates only to 1986 and showed no differences.

But Stephen DiFazio, a population geneticist at West Virginia University who was not involved in the study, said the researchers hadn't entirely proved that the were 100 percent identical at the time of the experiment. Mutations could have accumulated over time, he suggested.

Explore further: Twins become more different as they age


Related Stories

Time of day matters to thirsty trees, researcher discovers

November 23, 2009

The time of day matters to forest trees dealing with drought, according to a new paper produced by a research team led by Professor Malcolm Campbell, University of Toronto Scarborough's vice-principal for research and colleagues ...

Can clonal plants live forever?

August 17, 2010

Despite the many cosmetic products, surgical treatments, food supplements, and drugs designed specifically to reverse the biological effects of aging in humans, long-lived aspen clones aren't so lucky. Researchers at the ...

Gene helps plants use less water without biomass loss

January 11, 2011

( -- Purdue University researchers have found a genetic mutation that allows a plant to better endure drought without losing biomass, a discovery that could reduce the amount of water required for growing plants ...

Recommended for you

Study suggests fish can experience 'emotional fever'

November 25, 2015

(—A small team of researchers from the U.K. and Spain has found via lab study that at least one type of fish is capable of experiencing 'emotional fever,' which suggests it may qualify as a sentient being. In their ...

A huge chunk of a tardigrade's genome comes from foreign DNA

November 23, 2015

Researchers from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill have sequenced the genome of the nearly indestructible tardigrade, the only animal known to survive the extreme environment of outer space, and found something ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jul 26, 2011
I also beg those researchers to check out how symbiontic bacteria, fungus etc could affect these different behaviour. Such external modifiers could have been obtained from their nursery environment.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.