Russian cosmologist suggests life could exist inside a black hole

April 13, 2011 by Bob Yirka report

Russian cosmologist suggests life could exist inside a black hole

Enlarge

The stable periodic orbits of photon and planet. See http://arxiv.org/abs/1103.6140

(PhysOrg.com) -- Going out on a limb, Russian cosmologist Vyacheslav Dokuchaev, of the Institute for Nuclear Research at the Russian Academy of Sciences in Moscow, has speculated in a paper published in arXiv, that due to the very unique conditions that exist past the event horizon in certain (charged and rotating) black holes, life could very possibly exist, and could very well have evolved into advanced civilizations.

Black holes, as we all know, are entities that exist in space that have such strong that everything around them gets sucked in and swallowed up, never to be seen again. Well, not exactly, scientists know that deep inside rotating, charged , past the (the point where time and space become one) things switch back to what would be considered normal (the Cauchy horizon) at least to the extent that photons can orbit the singularity. And it’s the existence of these photons that leads Dokuchaev to believe that other objects could conceivably exist as well, some of which could possibly harbor life forms; albeit their world would be radically different from what we know due to the presence of dramatic amounts of light from the photons that would also be trapped orbiting the singularity with them, not to mention constantly fluctuating tidal forces and bombardment by other energy sources.

Dokuchaev, whose field is the study of the orbiting entities that do actually exist within the small subset of black holes, known as charged rotating black holes, as opposed to the Schwarzschild black hole (no movement) or Kerr black hole (no charge), clearly realizes that though his proclamations might be a bit extravagant, his science is clearly not. His theories expand on previous research that has shown that elementary light particles (photons) have been found to orbit the in such black holes, in stable, periodic orbits. He asserts that there is no evidence to suggest that something larger, such as a planet with complicated chemistry could not do the same.

Of course, if what Dokuchaev suggests is true, we’d almost certainly never know about it due to the impossibility of emissions from any such advanced escaping the immense gravity of the black hole in which they live; so the argument is rather moot, though certainly intriguing.

More information: Is there life inside black holes? by Vyacheslav I. Dokuchaev, arXiv:1103.6140v2 [gr-qc] http://arxiv.org/abs/1103.6140
via Technology Review

© 2010 PhysOrg.com

3.5 /5 (13 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

eachus
Apr 13, 2011

Rank: 4.7 / 5 (3)
Interesting but the headline is misleading. Stellar mass and smaller black holes have these (potentially weird) rules inside. Larger black holes are unlikely to have significant charge, and for supermassive black holes, even the maximum possible rotation is unlikely to be significant inside.

Of course, there is the limiting case that our universe may be considered as a black hole. Then the possibility of life is axiomatic. (But not the type of life Vyacheslav Dokuchaev is suggesting.)
Quantum_Conundrum
Apr 13, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (6)
Wow...

You can actually get paid in the "scientific community" for making a completely pointless theory like this, but can't get paid for actually trying to solve real world problems that actually matter to people...
frajo
Apr 13, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (5)
You can actually get paid in the "scientific community" for making a completely pointless theory like this
Yes. It's called research in theoretical physics.
but can't get paid for actually trying to solve real world problems that actually matter to people...
That's called engineering. A good engineer does not necessarily need to understand theoretical physics.
Cave_Man
Apr 13, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (4)
You can actually get paid in the "scientific community" for making a completely pointless theory like this
Yes. It's called research in theoretical physics.
but can't get paid for actually trying to solve real world problems that actually matter to people...
That's called engineering. A good engineer does not necessarily need to understand theoretical physics.

All hes trying to say is wheres my nuclear fusion powered jacuzzi hot tub already ffs its taking them long enough.
Tachyon8491
Apr 13, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
I am aware of several black holes with a form of life inside them here on this planet who can be found sitting behind imposing walnut desks and deflect other lives with dramatic gravitational forces.

Seriously, I think the theoretical thinking here has it wrong from the moment of formation of black holes - the origin of exobiotic molecules e.g. as accepted in Type II carbonaceous chondrites and observed in large molecular clouds (LMCs) as also protostellar envelopes, and which may be assumed to be a primary evolutionary phase of phylogeny, I think is very unlikely to originate and evolve beyond an event-horizon.
PinkElephant
Apr 13, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (4)
He asserts that there is no evidence to suggest that something larger, such as a planet with complicated chemistry could not do the same.
Yeeeeeeah.... Aside from the rather obvious complication of constant super-high-energy photon/particle bombardment and gravitational tidal stressing/heating, rather swiftly turning any such "planet" into a rarefied cloud of high-energy plasma (or rather, preventing any such planet from coalescing in the first place...)
Vendicar_Decarian
Apr 14, 2011

Rank: not rated yet
"You can actually get paid" - QC

Get Lost... Worthless MoneyGrubber
ZephirAWT
Apr 14, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (5)
If vacuum can be formed with black hole matter, then no one could protest against dense aether concept, forming the vacuum. From certain perspective common galaxies are forming the extended surface (atmosphere composed of dust of stars) of black holes at their centres. We just cannot see these galaxies as a black holes, because we aren't sitting at the sufficient distance from them, so that their event horizon appears bellow surface of galaxy. The farther we can get from black hole, the more the event horizon grows relatively to the black hole neighbourhood. It's similar dispersive effect, like the observation of objects inside of landscape under the fog - from sufficient distance such object disappear inside of fog and they cannot be seen.

Anyway, it's evident, the physicists are taking the concept of black holes very loosely in contemporary physics - you could actually say what you want about it and you'll always get some money for it. Which is the most important thing in this world
farmerpat42
Apr 15, 2011

Rank: 4 / 5 (4)
Wow...

You can actually get paid in the "scientific community" for making a completely pointless theory like this, but can't get paid for actually trying to solve real world problems that actually matter to people...


I'd guess that this theory was just a tangent to some other research he was doing. So he's not getting paid to talk about life in black holes, it was just something that came up during some more practical black hole investigation and he is using it to relate the principle of what a blackhole is on the inside.
Rank 3.5 /5 (13 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • revamping general concept and cosmological principle
    createdMay 25, 2012
  • Transiting Exoplanet Light Curve
    createdMay 25, 2012
  • Math behind Theoretical Physics
    createdMay 24, 2012
  • Do we know whats at the center of galaxies yet?
    createdMay 23, 2012
  • Structure of the Milky Way?
    createdMay 20, 2012
  • What would it take to terraform Pluto and Charon?
    createdMay 19, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - General Astronomy

More news stories

SpaceX capsule has 'new car' smell, astronauts say (Update)

SpaceX's Dragon cargo vessel smells like a new car, said astronauts at the International Space Station after opening the hatches Saturday following the spacecraft's landmark mission to the orbiting lab.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 21 hours ago | popularity 4.5 / 5 (20) | comments 1

Australia hails surprise super-telescope decision

Australia has hailed a surprise decision giving it a role in a radio telescope project aimed at revolutionising astronomy, vowing to draw on its decades of experience in space science.

Space & Earth / Astronomy

created 21 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (4) | comments 2

Astronomers seize last chance in lifetime for Venus Transit

Astronomers are gearing for one the rarest events in the Solar System: an alignment of Earth, Venus and the Sun that will not be seen for another 105 years.

Space & Earth / Astronomy

created 21 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (3) | comments 2

Astronauts enter world's 1st private supply ship

(AP) -- Space station astronauts floated into the Dragon on Saturday, a day after its heralded arrival as the world's first commercial supply ship.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 21 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (6) | comments 0

Sophisticated simulations predict future warming

The chances of our planet being hit by a global warming of 3 degrees Celsius by 2050 is as likely as it being hit by an increase of 1.4 degrees, new research shows. Presented in the journal Nature Geoscience, the British study ...

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created May 22, 2012 | popularity 4.4 / 5 (9) | comments 51


Browser wars flare in mobile space

The browser wars are heating up again, but this time the fight is for dominance of the mobile Internet.

Scientist: Evolution debate will soon be history

(AP) -- Richard Leakey predicts skepticism over evolution will soon be history. Not that the avowed atheist has any doubts himself.

Dell tablet leak: 10.1-inch display, two-battery choice

(Phys.org) -- Headline after headline talks about vendors’ tablets in the wings as likely number-one contenders for the iPad. Such claims have justifiably been taken with a grain of salt, considering ...

SpotterRF debuts Radar Backpack Kit (w/ Video)

(Phys.org) -- SpotterRF has announced a special radar backpack kit designed to enhance situational awareness for soldiers on the ground. The company says its special radar is designed for warfighters as part ...

Thousands of shellfish found dead in Peru

Thousands of crustaceans were found dead off the coast of Lima following the mystery mass death of dolphins and pelicans, the Peruvian Navy said Friday.

Keep food safety in mind this memorial day weekend

(HealthDay) -- Picnics, parades and cookouts are as much a part of Memorial Day weekend as tributes to the United States' war veterans.