Happiest places have highest suicide rates says new research

Apr 21, 2011

The happiest countries and happiest U.S. states tend to have the highest suicide rates, according to research from the UK’s University of Warwick, Hamilton College in New York and the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.

The new research paper titled Dark Contrasts: The Paradox of High Rates of Suicide in Happy Places has been accepted for publication in the Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization. It uses U.S. and international data, which included first-time comparisons of a newly available random sample of 1.3 million Americans, and another on suicide decisions among an independent random sample of approximately 1 million Americans.

The research confirmed a little known and seemingly puzzling fact: many happy countries have unusually high rates of suicide. This observation has been made from time to time about individual nations, especially in the case of Denmark. This new research found that a range of nations - including: Canada, the United States, Iceland, Ireland and Switzerland, display relatively high happiness levels and yet also have high suicide rates. Nevertheless the researchers note that, because of variation in cultures and suicide-reporting conventions, such cross-country scatter plots are only suggestive. To confirm the relationship between levels of happiness and rates of suicide within a geographical area, the researchers turned to two very large data sets covering a single country, the United States.

The scientific advantage of comparing happiness and suicide rates across U.S. states is that cultural background, national institutions, language and religion are relatively constant across a single country. While still not absolutely perfect, as the States are not identical, comparing the different areas of the country gave a much more homogeneous population to examine rather than a global sample of nations.

Comparing U.S. states in this way produced the same result. States with people who are generally more satisfied with their lives tended to have higher suicide rates than those with lower average levels of . For example, the raw data showed that Utah is ranked first in life-satisfaction, but has the 9th highest suicide rate. Meanwhile, New York was ranked 45th in life satisfaction, yet had the lowest suicide rate in the country.

The researchers then also tried to make their comparison between States even fairer and yet more homogeneous by adjusting for clear population differences between the states including age, gender, race, education, income, marital status and employment status. Even with these adjustments. This still produced a very strong correlation between happiness levels and suicide rates although some states shifted their positions slightly. Hawaii then ranks second in adjusted average life satisfaction but has the fifth highest suicide rate in the country. At the other end of the spectrum, for example, New Jersey ranked near the bottom in adjusted life satisfaction (47th) and had one of the lowest adjusted suicide risks (coincidentally, also the 47th highest rate).

The researchers (Professor Andrew Oswald from the University of Warwick, Associate Professor of Economics Stephen Wu of Hamilton College and Mary C. Daly and Daniel Wilson both from the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco) believe the key explanation that may explain this counterintuitive link between happiness and draws on ideas about the way that human beings rely on relative comparisons between each other.

University of Warwick researcher Professor Andrew Oswald said:

“Discontented people in a happy place may feel particularly harshly treated by life. Those dark contrasts may in turn increase the risk of suicide. If humans are subject to mood swings, the lows of life may thus be most tolerable in an environment in which other humans are unhappy.”

Professor Stephen Wu of Hamilton College said:

"This result is consistent with other research that shows that people judge their well-being in comparison to others around them. These types of comparison effects have also been shown with regards to income, unemployment, crime, and obesity."

Explore further: Less privileged kids shine at university, according to study

More information: Download the data - "Suicide Rates and Happiness Across U.S. States 

Related Stories

Suicide spikes for U.S. middle-aged

Feb 19, 2008

A five-year study on suicide in the United States found a 20 percent increase in the suicide rate among 45-to-54-year-olds, out-pacing any other age group.

Recommended for you

Why are UK teenagers skipping school?

Dec 18, 2014

Analysis of the results of a large-scale survey reveals the extent of truancy in English secondary schools and sheds light on the mental health of the country's teens.

Fewer lectures, more group work

Dec 18, 2014

Professor Cees van der Vleuten from Maastricht University is a Visiting Professor at Wits University who believes that learning should be student centred.

How to teach all students to think critically

Dec 18, 2014

All first year students at the University of Technology Sydney could soon be required to take a compulsory maths course in an attempt to give them some numerical thinking skills. ...

User comments : 11

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

pauljpease
5 / 5 (2) Apr 21, 2011
Makes sense. There is good evidence that depressed people have more accurate views of their life. If regions differ in their REPORTED level of happiness, it could be due to cultural norms. That is to say, if more people in an area exaggerate their level of satisfaction, or for some reason feel more satisfied then they ought to considering the reality on the ground, the average person will feel pressured to agree with the majority and so will also report general life satisfaction. The effect of this "happiness bubble" is that those with a very realistic view of life, e.g. depressed people, will feel even more out of touch with other people in the community. This could make those people feel even more hopeless and drive them to suicide, compared to people who live around other people with less happiness inflation, so to speak.
Fig1024
3.8 / 5 (4) Apr 21, 2011
letting all the unhappy people kill themselves is one way to boost the average happiness level

Besides, happy people are much more eager to distance themselves from unhappy people, they don't want any "downers", don't want to hear about people's problems - cause if they immersed themselves in world of problems, they wouldn't be so happy themselves. And when you isolate depressed people, that's when they are most likely to commit suicide. Isolation is key
that_guy
5 / 5 (1) Apr 21, 2011
I agree with pauljplease, but I would like to restate the issue more succinctly.

The happier everyone else seems to be, the more hopeless it feels to be the failure who isn't.
Husky
not rated yet Apr 21, 2011
ah yes, makes you stick out in the prozac crowd
xznofile
1 / 5 (1) Apr 21, 2011
Folks, there's money to be made from this study, marketers make a note: the suicide rate is a scale for social homogeneity. (join the in-crowd and don't be a looser)
MadLintElf
5 / 5 (1) Apr 21, 2011
Anyone ever read childhoods' end by Arthur C. Clark, as the population became happier, suicide rates skyrocketed.

As crime went down, suicides went up.

He was a man before his time!

BB
curt_doolittle
4 / 5 (1) Apr 22, 2011
Interesting comments.

HERE IS THE REASON:

The reason countries/states are happier is wealth.
People who are unhappy are attracted to happier locations.
The first thing that people 'buy' with wealth is spatial freedom: their own place.
The primary reason for suicide? Loneliness and depression caused by living alone.

"no matter where you go, there you are"
"there is no substitute for friends and family."

rwinners
not rated yet Apr 22, 2011
Ok. Much more data is needed to make any sense of this data.
Age and financial condition of the suicides would be most important. Conditions of upbringing, second. Anyone else want to suggest some parameters?
rwinners
not rated yet Apr 22, 2011
Religion? Abusive relationships? Come on, someone use the grey matter.
rwinners
not rated yet Apr 22, 2011
Oh, and what are the happiest US states???
hush1
not rated yet Apr 24, 2011
Isn't the highest-at-risk-group psychologists and psychiatrists? Don't they all live in Hawaii?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.