Online anonymity icon dislikes Facebook model

Mar 15, 2011 by Glenn Chapman
Christopher "moot" Poole, the founder of Internet anonymity haven 4chan, thinks Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg is mistaken when it comes to online identities. Remaining unknown online frees people to blaze ahead with creative endeavors they might otherwise shy away from for fear of being embarrassed, Poole said at the South By Southwest festival.

The founder of Internet anonymity haven 4chan thinks Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg is mistaken when it comes to online identities.

Remaining unknown online frees people to blaze ahead with creative endeavors they might otherwise shy away from for fear of being embarrassed, Christopher "moot" Poole said at the South By Southwest festival ending Tuesday in Texas.

"To fail where you are identified by your real name is really costly," Poole said. "Being anonymous lets people poke and prod all they want without fear.

"Anonymity is authenticity."

Poole said Zuckerberg's model in which everyone gets an online identity they take with them about the Internet was "totally wrong" and threatened to strip online life of the "innocence of youth."

"At 4chan people are judged by the wit of their contributions, not who they are," Poole said. "In terms of content creation it allows you to play in ways that you wouldn't be able to otherwise."

Anonymity will remain sacrosanct at 4chan, which has earned a reputation as the birthplace of group Anonymous and a refuge for those keen on sharing thoughts while cloaking identities.

"4chan is the dark part of the Internet," Poole said of the online message board started in 2003 as a place for fans of Japanese comics and culture.

"The ticking, beating heart notorious for its memes and for its exploits, the activism," he said. "I don't recommend you go poking around without knowing what you are clicking on."

On any given day, there are about 16,000 people "waiting and watching" 4chan's random message board, according to Poole.

4chan not only shuns identifying website users it keeps no archive of comments.

"It is this constant waterfall of content popping up and then falling off the site," Poole said. "It has led to this survival of the fittest idea where stuff that resonates with the community stays on the site and that which doesn't falls into the abyss."

Poole's latest project is Canvas, an online forum where people add their touches to drawings or graphics started by others.

"People describe it as 4chan 2.0," Poole said.

"But, that is not the purpose of it," he continued. "It is to take all the things that I learned in eight years to build this great site for people to play, share, collaborate and hang out."

He showed how a glamour shot of Internet-born pop star Justin Bieber was transformed at Canvas into an image of a porcine young man complete with double-chin.

In another example from a test version of the website, a bare-bones sketch that appeared to be a bowler hat and a head at Canvas was given many forms, one of them a play on works by late Belgian surrealist painter Rene Magritte.

"It is a place where people go to find and manipulate images," Poole explained, saying he was inspired by an online refrigerator magnet game.

In a deviation from the 4chan credo of absolute anonymity, Canvas is in private test mode using a Facebook Connect platform based on recognizing people by profile identities at the world's most popular social network.

"We sort of needed it," Poole explained. "This is a way to filter out trolls, people who want to come in and mess things up."

People can request to be part of the Canvas test group at website www.canv.as/sxsw.

Explore further: Cyber risks for those with heads in the cloud

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Trendsetters revel in technology in Texas

Mar 11, 2011

Innovators and trendsetters are heading to Texas for a technology festival renowned as a springboard for Web sensations such as Twitter and Foursquare.

Bye-bye trolls? Blizzard forums to use real names

Jul 07, 2010

(AP) -- Activision Blizzard's move to require people to use their real names if they want to post messages in online forums for games is the latest sign that online anonymity is falling out of favor with many companies.

Recommended for you

Cyber risks for those with heads in the cloud

11 minutes ago

Australian home computer users and businesses are being warned to consider more closely the risks associated with cloud computing, as well as its many advantages.

Seniors are attractive targets for online fraud

3 hours ago

Victims of online fraud need greater support to help them overcome the often serious health effects that follow discovery of the deception, QUT cybersecurity researcher Cassandra Cross says.

Internet in 'coma' as Iran election looms

May 19, 2013

Iran is tightening control of the Internet ahead of next month's presidential election, mindful of violent street protests that social networkers inspired last time around over claims of fraud, users and ...

Bernanke forecasts gains from computer technology

May 18, 2013

(AP)—Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke says pessimists who are forecasting that the economy will not reap sizable benefits from the computer revolution are likely to be proven wrong.

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

ormondotvos
5 / 5 (1) Mar 15, 2011
So we need anonymity to free up creativity (presumption of benevolent creativity) but we have to have ID on Canvas because "trolls" have negative creativity.

Make up your mind, big fella!
JJC
not rated yet Mar 16, 2011
@ormondotvos more like we need anonymity, but it turns out there is no money in that so you need a Facebook style page to earn some cash.
shull_anthony
not rated yet Mar 16, 2011
my suggestion would be to think of creative ways to secure anonymity for people who are behaving and then make people who are abusing that privilege authenticate and be known. that would entail writing a machine learning algorithm that can go over posts, identify trolls, and then log their ip address as a suspected troll. then you can put the onus on the suspected troll to authenticate via facebook or appeal the decision.
wiyosaya
not rated yet Mar 16, 2011
my suggestion would be to think of creative ways to secure anonymity for people who are behaving and then make people who are abusing that privilege authenticate and be known. that would entail writing a machine learning algorithm that can go over posts, identify trolls, and then log their ip address as a suspected troll. then you can put the onus on the suspected troll to authenticate via facebook or appeal the decision.

IMHO, what you suggest would not be easy to do. Someone testing a new idea or being creative might be labeled as a troll since being creative is sometimes associated with "rocking the boat." Your program might then force them to identify themselves incorrectly.
Beard
not rated yet Mar 17, 2011
So we need anonymity to free up creativity (presumption of benevolent creativity) but we have to have ID on Canvas because "trolls" have negative creativity.


It's only a problem because a single person can easily destroy the entire image if they want to. Trolling a text thread is much more difficult and sometimes impossible if the users are savvy enough. This can lead to a "trolls trolling trolls" situation in which both parties are aware that they are trolling eachother but play along anyway.

More news stories

Apple's Cook to face Senate questions on taxes

A Senate panel says Apple Inc. is avoiding paying billions of dollars in U.S. taxes, but the world's most valuable company says it is complying with the laws and pays "an extraordinary amount" in taxes to the U.S. govern ...

Space drives e-mobility

An ESA business incubation start-up company is helping major car manufacturers to develop electric vehicle concepts and improve safety systems by turning ideas quickly into virtual prototypes.

New factor to control oncogene-induced senescence

An article published on the journal Nature describes the major role that Pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH) —an enzyme of cellular energy metabolism— plays in the regulation of the cellular senescence induce ...