Robotic surgery 'tremendous benefit' to patients, researchers say

Jan 12, 2011

Robot-assisted surgery dramatically improves outcomes in patients with uterine, endometrial, and cervical cancer, said researchers at the Jewish General Hospital's Lady Davis Institute for Medical Research in Montreal. Moreover, because of fewer post-operative complications and shorter hospital stays, robotic procedures also cost less.

These results were published in late 2010 in a series of studies in The Journal of and The International Journal of Gynecological Cancer.

To date, adoption of robotic surgery has been slowed by fears that it will raise overall healthcare costs. In Canada, robotic procedures are not yet covered by any provincial healthcare plan.

"To the contrary, robotic surgery definitely benefits patients and society," said Dr. Walter H. Gotlieb, Head of Gynecologic Oncology at the JGH Segal Cancer Centre. "Patient quality of life is dramatically improved, their hospital stays are much shorter and they use far less narcotic pain medication. The majority of our patients need nothing stronger than Tylenol."

In a robot-assisted operating room, the physician sits at a computer console and manipulates multiple robot arms, rather than working directly on the patient. The technology was developed to overcome the limitations of minimally invasive surgery (MIS), including such notoriously difficult procedures as laparoscopy for cancer.

"Laparoscopy is the gold standard of treatment for , but unfortunately the learning curve is too steep for most surgeons," said Dr. Gotlieb, also Director of Surgical Oncology at McGill University. "A recent U.S. study said that only about six percent of gynecologic oncology surgeons offer laparoscopy to most of their endometrial cancer patients, despite its well-established advantages."

"At the Jewish General Hospital, we went from only 15 percent of our endometrial cancer patients benefiting from MIS by to 95 percent using robotic surgery. In we did not perform MIS at all before, whereas now all of our patients benefit from it."

Moreover, contrary to Isaac Asimov and other 20th-century science fiction writers, who predicted that people would react to robots with fear and loathing, patients – even elderly patients– are the most enthusiastic boosters of robotic surgery.

In a letter addressed to the hospital's director of professional services, one patient with a very complex case of endometrial cancer heaped praise on her "surgeon and his robot" and called the device a "marvel."

Explore further: Almost 2,000 lung cancer patients missing out on surgery every year

Provided by Jewish General Hospital

2.3 /5 (3 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

McSleepy meets DaVinci

Oct 19, 2010

In a world first, a completely robotic surgery and anesthesia has been performed at the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC). The DaVinci surgical robot, which lets surgeons work from remote locations, was ...

Recommended for you

Video: Is that double mastectomy really necessary?

Oct 24, 2014

When Angeline Vuong, 27,was diagnosed with cancer in one breast earlier this year, her first reaction was "A DOUBLE MASTECTOMY. NOW. " Turns out, she's far from alone: a recent JAMA study of 190,000 breast cancer cases in ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

pdriscoll
5 / 5 (1) Jan 12, 2011
Far be it from me to be one to cast aspersions on a new technology, but -- and I am indeed withholding far more critical commentary -- this article does robotic surgery such a disservice. NO new technology (and I mean that emphatically) deserves such praise, given the added initial costs of training, capital expenditure, learning curve (less than laparoscopy, really??) and other drawbacks. I can guarantee that there will be challenges to such pollyanna-esque pronouncements on robotic surgery. While it may ultimately offer an opportunity for certain surgeries that CANNOT be accomplished safely without robotic involvement, such over-the-top praise that is dispensed in this article creates a balloon expanded so fully that it has no destiny but to pop.