Planet affects a star's spin

Jan 13, 2011
An artist's conception of HD 189733b, which some have dubbed the "Bulls-eye" planet because of the bright "hot spot" shown here. Credit: David A. Aguilar (CfA)

The discovery of a hot Jupiter exoplanet that transfers orbital momentum to its host star may hold the key to a clearer understanding of the evolution of common planetary systems, according to findings presented by Dr. Edward Guinan, a professor of astronomy at Villanova University in Villanova, Pa.

Guinan announced the find at a press conference held at the opening of the 217th American Astronomy Society meeting in Seattle, Washington.

The discovery is of special interest because it represents a rare case in which a research team was able to make an independent age determination of the planet system by studying the system’s faint red dwarf companion star. The discovery opens a new gateway to learning about the dynamics and evolution of many other planetary systems that also contain close-in hot-Jupiter type planets.

HD 189733b, the hot Jupiter , orbits an orange (dwarf K) star HD 189733 in the constellation Vulpecula (the Fox). It orbits at only three percent of the distance of the Earth from the Sun: i.e. ~0.03 AU) with an orbital period of only 2.2 days (for comparison the Earth takes 365 days to orbit our Sun).

The host star is about 63 light-years away and has a mass and diameter about ~80 percent that of our Sun. This star, invigorated by its hot Jupiter planetary companion, appears to have been spun up (rotating ~ >2x faster than our Sun -- having a ~12-day rotation period) and is gaining angular momentum from magnetic and tidal interactions with its close-in Jupiter-size planet. The star, however, is being spun-up at the expense of the planet’s orbital angular energy.

The loss in the planet’s orbital momentum in the past may explain why it (and other similar planetary systems) orbit so close to their host stars. While the planet is spiraling in toward the star, and is most likely doomed, there is a possibility that the interacting magnetic fields of the star and planet could create a tidal-magnetically locked orbit -- rotation that might allow the planet to survive. The most likely scenario, however, is that the planet will draw closer to the star and its atmosphere will be eroded away by the star’s intense radiation and strong winds. The planet will ultimately be ripped apart by the star’s gravity if it survives the star’s radiation and winds.

HD 189733 Ab is a relatively rare eclipsing that was discovered in 2005 (by Buchy et al.) and has attracted much attention in astronomical circles because it hosts a transiting hot Jupiter exoplanet. The system is relatively bright (e.g., it can be seen with binoculars). The eclipses by the planet permit substantial information to be gained from observing the system inside and outside the planetary eclipses. For example, spectroscopic studies by other teams (e.g., G. Tinnetti et al.) reveal that its hot atmosphere contains water vapor, carbon dioxide, sodium, and, interestingly, organic molecules of methane and particulate haze.

The Villanova team, which includes undergraduates Thomas Santapaga and Ronald Ballouz, found that this system is over five billion years old. The Jupiter-size planet has been estimated to be very hot at ~1,500 degrees Fahrenheit by other researchers. HD 189733b has one of the shortest known orbital periods of only P = 2.22 days and is only 0.031AU from its host star (i.e., only ~8.75x the radius of the host star). The exoplanet system includes a cool red dwarf companion star (HD 189733B). This faint companion star is located at ~12” distance to the K-dwarf. At the distance of HD 189733 this corresponds to a separation of ~220 AU. (For comparison this is 220x the distance of the Earth from the Sun, or over 5.5x further than the distance of Pluto from the Sun.) The presence of this red dwarf star makes a reliable age estimate of the binary system possible via activity-age relations developed at Villanova.

A full-globe map of the "hot Jupiter" planet HD 189733b. The map reveals a "hot spot" that is offset from the substellar point (high noon) by about 30 degrees. The offset may indicate jet stream winds of up to 6,000 mph. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Heather Knutson (CfA)

“Planetary systems like HD 189733 with short period, “hot-Jupiter” planets are very common -- over a hundred have been discovered so far,” Guinan noted. He continued, “HD 189733 and dozens of other planetary systems like it, many of which were recently discovered by NASA’s Kepler mission, may also be undergoing the same process of strong magnetic interactions between their close-in large planets and their host stars.”

“The big clue that is different here is that we know the age of HD 189733 from the study of its coeval faint .” This discovery should help in our endeavors to try to better understand the dynamics of other planetary systems like HD 189733, he added.”

Of the over 500 exoplanets that have been discovered to date, HD 189733 is the only one of a handful whose age and physical properties have been well determined. Studying these planets and their systems can help astrobiologists determine where best to search for habitable worlds beyond our own solar system.

“This study may help explain how and why hot Jupiters form and evolve. It may help explain this whole class of planets,” Guinan remarked.

The star cataloged as HD 189733 is a mere 63 light-years away. Its location is indicated in this deep, wide-angle image of the sky centered on the northern constellation of Cygnus. Although HD 189733's planet is considered too hot and inhospitable to support life, the work is a step toward measuring conditions and chemistry on other extrasolar planets where life could exist. Photo: Akira Fujii; Image: NASA

In conducting this study the research team, which includes Villanovans Thomas Santapaga, Ronald L. Ballouz, Scott E. Engle, Laurence E. DeWarf, along with Styliani (Stella) Kafka from the Carnegie Institute in Washington, D.C.’s Department of Terrestrial Magnetism, observed the exoplanet system using the Clay Telescope at the Carnegie Institution of Washington’s Las Campanas Observatory in Chile. Observations of the eclipse timings of HD 189733 continue at Villanova using the Four College Automatic Photoelectric Telescope (FCAPT) located in southern Arizona. The eclipse timings made with this telescope over time could provide evidence that the orbital period of the system is indeed decreasing.

Guinan’s Jan. 10 presentation of the team’s findings at the 217th AAS Meeting are from a paper titled, “Some Like It Hot” -- Evidence for the Shrinking Orbit of the 2.2-day Transiting Hot Exoplanet HD 189733b -- Evidence of Transfer of Planet Orbital Momentum to its Host Star” (AAS 217th Meeting Abstract 343.12).

“One of the most amazing results of our team’s research is that a planet-size body that is only 1/1000x times the mass of the host star can make such a large impact by magnetically interacting with its to the extent that it causes the star to spin up, activating a strong magnetic dynamo of the star that produces the observed strong X-ray coronal emissions, large starspots and other phenomena,” Guinan concluded.

Explore further: Thermonuclear X-ray bursts on neutron stars set speed record

Related Stories

Hazy red sunset on extrasolar planet

Dec 11, 2007

A team of astronomers have used the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope to detect, for the first time, strong evidence of hazes in the atmosphere of a planet orbiting a distant star. The discovery comes after ...

The star, the dwarf and the planet

Oct 19, 2006

Astronomers have detected a new faint companion to the star HD 3651, already known to host a planet. This companion, a brown dwarf, is the faintest known companion of an exoplanet host star imaged directly ...

X-Ray observations of an extrasolar planetary system

Oct 22, 2010

( -- The majority of extra-solar planets (about 278 of them) are more massive than Jupiter. About 20% of this majority group orbit their stars at a distances of less than one-tenth of an astronomical ...

Learning from hot Jupiters

Dec 15, 2010

The possibility of discovering a planet that is small, cool, rocky, orbiting a sunlike star and able to host life -- an Earth twin, in other words -- has made the search for planets outside of our solar ...

Richest planetary system discovered (w/ Video)

Aug 24, 2010

( -- Astronomers using ESO's world-leading HARPS instrument have discovered a planetary system containing at least five planets, orbiting the Sun-like star HD 10180. The researchers also have tantalising ...

Recommended for you

How can we find tiny particles in exoplanet atmospheres?

16 hours ago

It may seem like magic, but astronomers have worked out a scheme that will allow them to detect and measure particles ten times smaller than the width of a human hair, even at many light-years distance.  ...

Spitzer telescope witnesses asteroid smashup

Aug 28, 2014

( —NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope has spotted an eruption of dust around a young star, possibly the result of a smashup between large asteroids. This type of collision can eventually lead to the ...

Witnessing the early growth of a giant

Aug 27, 2014

Astronomers have uncovered for the first time the earliest stages of a massive galaxy forming in the young Universe. The discovery was made possible through combining observations from the NASA/ESA Hubble ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 13, 2011
Does this imply that our Sun has *not* ingested a Hot Jupiter ??
not rated yet Jan 13, 2011
What's funny is that nay-sayers here on earth will tell us.. naaa Earth/Jupiter/Saturn don't impact the sun's influence... but we're happy to believe it happens on stars we observe out there..
5 / 5 (2) Jan 13, 2011
What's funny is that nay-sayers here on earth will tell us.. naaa Earth/Jupiter/Saturn don't impact the sun's influence... but we're happy to believe it happens on stars we observe out there..

You don't think Jupiter being at 5.2AU and HD 189733b being .03AU makes any difference in the prominence of the effect, right?
1 / 5 (1) Jan 14, 2011
Hot Jupiters are being seen as more frequent than previously thought. Good. My conclusion of our Jupiter is that it is a "mini-Sun" meaning that it should have been a Sun, but did not traverse far enough away from its Parent, our Sun. This, of course, could be a common occurrence in the life of Suns.

The size, dominance, and location of our Jupiter, and any hot Jupiter, should lead scientists to study our Jupiter immediately in depth. It's in our own backyard. Look at the night sky. There is no doubt (dtxx) that it has an effect on us here on Earth, let alone its relationship with our Sun. Glad you pointed that out.