Driving change in diagnosis of personality disorders

Jan 26, 2011 By Kate Cohorst

University of Notre Dame psychologist Lee Anna Clark recently began work on a five-year study that will contribute to revolutionizing the way personality disorders are diagnosed and further cement Clark’s standing as one of the world’s preeminent research psychologists.

The study, funded through a $2 million grant from the National Institute of Mental Health, will expand on Clark’s previous work establishing a trait-based approach to diagnose personality disorders. The research will be conducted in partnership with Oaklawn Psychiatric Center, a local nonprofit mental health agency.

“Diagnosis is the first step toward treatment,” says Clark, William J. and Dorothy K. O’Neill Professor of Psychology at Notre Dame. “If we can figure out the components of personality disorder, then it should be easier to figure out how we can develop treatments that will address these different components.”

Clark joined the Department of Psychology faculty this fall, after 17 years at the University of Iowa. She recently also was voted president-elect of the Society for Research in Psychopathology.

Her personality research started in graduate school and coincided with the publication of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 3rd edition (DSM). For the first time, the DSM—considered the “bible” for making psychiatric diagnoses—switched to a criteria-based approach to diagnose all mental disorders, and additionally highlighted personality disorder as requiring separate attention.

But despite this advance, Clark believed that applying the same model to diagnosing personality and other disorders was a mistake, so she set out to find a better method.

“Our personalities are a complex combination of personality traits, attitudes, preferences, and so on,” Clark says. “It’s necessary to measure the whole domain of personality traits in the abnormal range, not just to have a few criteria.”

After 12 years of research, she published the Schedule for Non–adaptive and Adaptive Personality, or SNAP, a now widely used test that assesses disorders by measuring personality traits across the normal-abnormal spectrum.

“It’s proven to be a pretty good measure of personality traits in abnormal range,” Clark says. “But it’s not perfect. Now we need figure out what other traits are necessary.”

Her latest research will expand on the SNAP project, looking at what other traits should be measured. It also will study functioning—or why some people with extreme are adjusted and able to function well in society, while others are not.

The first two phases of the project include data gathering from patients at Oaklawn and from their adult friends and family. The last phase will be a preliminary test of how the assessment tool might work in a clinical setting, with physicians and invited to refer patients to the study. Clark and her collaborators will diagnose the patients and provide clinicians with the information, then follow up six months later to find out how useful it was.

Clark’s collaborators at Notre Dame are David Watson, Andrew J. McKenna Family Professor of Psychology, and Gitta Lubke, John Cardinal O’Hara, C.S.C., Associate Professor of Psychology. Also working on the project are postdoctoral associate Eunyoe Ro, project coordinator Laura Gumbiner, and a number of graduate students.

Clark also is currently one of 11 members of the work group revising the Personality and Personality Disorders section of the DSM-5, which is due out in 2013. The group is proposing that the DSM switch the way are diagnosed to a trait-based system. While the DSM-5 will use the existing system, Clark is hopeful her research will provide the information needed to make the change in the next revision.

Such a switch would be a validation of her lifetime of work. “The switch the DSM is making is very exciting for me,” she says. “What distinguishes my work over my career is that from the beginning, I said ‘We have to find a better way to do it.’”

Explore further: Hormone level predicts how the brain processes social information

Related Stories

Health-improving tattoos

Nov 22, 2010

Heather Clark isn’t your average tattoo artist. She won't take requests, and her tattoos won’t be permanent. They won’t even make people look hip — but they will keep them healthier.

Exercise could help prevent, treat eating disorders: study

Jan 13, 2011

When treating an eating disorder, exercise is rarely considered therapeutic; it’s more likely to be viewed as dangerous for patients already obsessed with their weight. But a new University of Florida study shows that ...

Is it really bipolar disorder?

Mar 25, 2010

A study from Rhode Island Hospital has shown that a widely-used screening tool for bipolar disorder may incorrectly indicate borderline personality disorder rather than bipolar disorder. In the article that appears online ...

Recommended for you

Depression, suicide and the workplace - Q&A

Mar 27, 2015

Expert opinions on the potential link between depression and the suspected mass murder-suicide of a Germanwings co-pilot who flew an Airbus into the French Alps Tuesday, killing all 150 people on board:

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.