Fuel error cost Russia three navigation satellites: official

Dec 17, 2010

The costly launch failure that caused Russia to delay the deployment of its own satellite system was the result of a fuel miscalculation, a commission charged with probing the accident said Friday.

A Proton-M failed to reach its initial orbit during the December 5 launch, causing it to dump the three high-tech Glonass-M satellites near the Hawaii Islands.

It marked an embarrassing setback to Russia's much-publicised attempts to introduce a global rival to the US (GPS), a programme that was first begun by the Soviet Union in 1976.

The last three satellites would have enabled Russia to fully deploy the system next year, meeting Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's commitment to equip all new cars sold in Russia with readers in 2012.

Space officials said the calculation mistake was easy to correct, and that they were relieved that there was nothing wrong with the actual rocket itself.

"We have no questions regarding the Proton," investigating commission chief Gennady Raikunov told the Interfax news agency. "Its launches could be resumed."

Raikunov said the fault lay with the Energia Rocket And Space Corporation, which designed the carrier.

He said that the company failed to account for the fact that the updated version of the rocket had bigger fuel tanks, which weighed more when filled to the top.

"This increased the payload weight and the rocket did not have the energy to deliver the satellites to orbit," the space official said.

Energia officials could not be reached for comment Friday.

Explore further: Building a better team—on Mars

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Russia probes navigation system spending after crash

Dec 07, 2010

Russia launched a probe Tuesday into whether the money assigned to create a satellite navigation rival to the US GPS system was being wisely spent, prosecutors said, after the latest launch ended in failure.

Russia plans to launch six satellites

Mar 27, 2007

Russia will add six satellites to its global navigation system, GLONASS, in 2007, a spokesman at Moscow's Research Institute of Space Instrument-Making said.

Recommended for you

Building a better team—on Mars

4 hours ago

Sometime in the next quarter-century, NASA plans to send the first humans to Mars, a mission that will push the boundaries of teamwork for a handful of astronauts who will spend as long as three years together ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

NotAsleep
5 / 5 (1) Dec 17, 2010
So "close enough" isn't an acceptable answer for "Is that enough fuel"?
DigiMc
not rated yet Dec 18, 2010
So they filled the tanks to the top and that still wasn't enough fuel?
eachus
not rated yet Dec 18, 2010
So they filled the tanks to the top and that still wasn't enough fuel?


Um, yes. Or that was too much fuel. If you put too much fuel in the first stage of a vehicle, it will sit on the pad until it burns enough fuel to take off. Saturn V, used for lunar missions, was notorious for being slow off the pad. Technically, it didn't have too much fuel (and LOx), but the engines took about 5 seconds to reach full thrust after ignition, and even then the thrust to weight ratio was 1.03. (There were hold-downs which only released when all the engines had reached full thrust to insure it didn't go sideways first.)

What happened to the Russians though, was putting too much fuel in an upper stage. Hmm. More like the boosters on a Russian launcher share fuel with the sustainer engine. Drop off the booster engines before enough fuel is burned, and you have plenty of fuel--and delta-v--left but the engine is still burning when you hit the ocean. Oops!

More news stories

Climate change and wildfire: Synthesis of recent findings

Concerns continue to grow about the effects of climate change on fire. Wildfires are expected to increase 50 percent across the United States under a changing climate, over 100 percent in areas of the West by 2050 as projected ...

New method for producing clean hydrogen

Duke University engineers have developed a novel method for producing clean hydrogen, which could prove essential to weaning society off of fossil fuels and their environmental implications.